The entry of the Taliban into Kabul and the scenes of chaos at the Kabul airport -- effectively ending 20 years of American efforts to build democracy in Afghanistan -- has set off a wave of recriminations both inside and outside the United States. While there is a clear winner - the Taliban -- there are a number of obvious and not so obvious losers.
The obvious losers are the many Afghan people, including women, the educated, those who worked with the Americans and other coalition partners; our allies, many of whom suffered heavy casualties, including two of our closest allies, the British (456 dead) and Canadians (157 lost); and American credibility - the reverberations on American reliability are only just beginning. Less obvious losers are the countries around Afghanistan - Pakistan, Russia, India, Iran and China - all will have to deal with the potential of an unruly neighbor with limited respect for the rules, serious if nascent domestic opposition, and a non-existent administrative apparatus. Concerns over this potential instability run particularly high in Tajikistan, Uzbekistan and Turkmenistan, but even long-time Taliban supporter Pakistan is concerned about having the Taliban in charge in Afghanistan.
President Biden's decision to end America's longest war may have seemed precipitous (and it is clear from the scenes at the airport that the US was not anticipating such a rapid collapse of the Afghan government and military) - but it also demonstrates the futility of the entire enterprise. Massive corruption, incompetent local leadership, tribalism, poor intelligence, and a lack of a coherent strategy all undermined the mission from the beginning. The US actually invaded Iraq before coming near to finishing the mission in Afghanistan, thereby ensuring that Washington's focus was divided and the American experiment in nation building would fail - in both places. A serious blow to the Biden Administration's reputation for competence and a sad end to this chapter of American diplomacy.
Also in this roundup of news - Why California could end up with a bright red governor in a deep blue state, why California cannot take its future for granted, and Disneyland as both corporate monstrosity and iconic image of American craft and design.
Happy Reading!