Governor Newsom's recall in California has crystallized many of the social and economic issues confronting the state. While most people will point to housing, decaying infrastructure, fires, the state's dysfunctional regulatory environment, and high taxes, the real culprit in making the recall a reality is an outdated progressive law coupled with an intense sense of powerlessness in rural California counties. As the state -- particularly in urban and coastal centers -- becomes more Democratic, more diverse, and more urban, these inland regions have been feeling ever more marginalized. The pandemic supercharged all of these trends, with mask mandates and shutdowns particularly angering small businesses and farmers, those who favor limiting immigration, and small-government conservatives.
Recall elections are actually quite rare - only five have taken place in all of US history. California's recall law is actually a bit of an anomaly - it was promulgated by the progressive governor Hiram Johnson 1913, with the express intention of undermining the political clout and economic monopoly of the Southern Pacific Railroad. Like any successful monopoly, the SP used its stranglehold over land transportation to keep costs low and charges high. To ensure a successful recall movement, Johnson set the bar low -- too low in retrospect, since only 12% of Californians need to approve the recall to force its application. To put this in perspective, only 26 states even have a recall on the books, and most require at least double California's number of signatures.
The last time the recall worked was in 2003, when Arnold Schwarzenegger replaced Gray Davis in a special election. But Schwarzenegger was a popular figure with broad name recognition and relatively liberal social and environmental credentials. The current slate of Republicans has none of Schwarzenegger's charisma or name recognition - and many more drawbacks.
The stakes are high - a loss by Newsom has ramifications far beyond the state's borders. A defeat for Newsom would indicate a more conservative trend in national politics, emboldening Republican challenges to the status quo in other states. Also of national import, if Dianne Feinstein were to retire from the Senate, she would be replaced by whomever succeeded Gov Newsom - and if that person were a Republican, it would shift the current balance in the Senate to the Republicans and likely obstruct most of President Biden's priorities. It could also have an impact on the Supreme Court should a vacancy appear. At this point, however, the polls seem to be breaking in Governor Newsom's favor. But clearly, this is one "reform" law that needs to be reformed.
Also in this roundup, global economic warfare heats up as military options lose their appeal and firms with no direct interest in healthcare are now investing in Chief Medical Officers to navigate the complexity of pandemic regulations. Happy Reading!