News Roundup

Sources (8) ↓

It isn't often that a seismic shift in global relationships takes place so visibly, but the announcement of a new treaty relationship on September 15 -- somewhat awkwardly entitled "AUKUS" -- between the United States, United Kingdom and Australia fits that description. The new alliance (which in some ways is not really so new, since all three countries have pre-existing defense ties) includes cooperation in military, cyber security, AI and quantum communications. The heart of the new arrangement is the sale of nuclear subs to the Australian government, including technology transfers that the US has only shared with Great Britain in the past.

On face value, the US, UK and Australia emerge as clear winners, but the deal also reassures India, Japan, South Korea and Taiwan as well. The losers are France, which finds itself publicly embarrassed by the renunciation of an earlier deal to purchase 16 diesel-electric subs from French defense industries, and China - which, though not publicly named, is obviously the focus of the new deal. Other regional powers - particularly Indonesia - are uncomfortable with the arrangement as well, which creates a clear delineation between the US and China in the Pacific.

For France, this humiliation bites deeply. The security arrangement was negotiated without any French knowledge beforehand (President Macron found out only a short while before the new alliance was announced. The deal represents a loss of prestige - France is the United States' oldest ally (though not a terribly constant one, particularly in the Gaullist era, and it is a huge hit to its defense sector, which has remained a global leader. Perhaps most painfully, it strikes at the heart of French perceptions of remaining a great power - especially with respect to "les Anglo-Saxons." An important point is that while the UK has been beefing up its Pacific presence recently, France continues to have both colonies and a significant military presence in the region.

Both France and China responded to the new deal with anger - France recalled its ambassadors to Washington and Canberra and sent the bill for the cancelled deal to Australia, and China applied for membership in the Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP) and denounced the new alliance and warned that the three nations should "abandon the obsolete cold war zero sum mentality and narrow-minded geopolitical concepts."

For the Biden administration, the deal is representative of the President's philosophy that the US needs to focus on grand strategic issues such as the challenges posed by China and Russia, rather than wasting resources on failed nation-building in places such as Afghanistan. It also reinforces his statement that the US remains committed to global engagement despite the precipitous withdrawal from Afghanistan. President Biden and Secretary of State Blinken clearly have some fence-mending to do with France however, and the deal could also give impetus to the EU to consider how to chart its own foreign policy course independent of the US and Great Britain.

Also in this roundup: Toronto and other Canadian cities emerge as hotbeds of tech innovation outside Silicon Valley, and the digital economy reaches a watershed moment in Asia thanks to Covid.

Sources

Links go to the original publishers. Some require a subscription.

  1. AUKUS reshapes the political landscape in Asia (The Economist) Read article economist.com
  2. The AUKUS Pact will have huge implications for the region (Patricia A. O'Brien/The Conversation (Australia) Read article theconversation.com
  3. A look at the impact of the AUKUS pact by various Chatham House (Royal Institute for International Studies) scholars on whether the new alliance is meaningful or merely provocative Read article chathamhouse.org
  4. US and China jockey in the Pacific on security and trade (Courtney McBride and Lingling Wei/Wall Street Journal) Read article wsj.com
  5. How AUKUS is viewed from Beijing (The Economist) Read article economist.com
  6. A new US alliance reignites age-old tensions with France (David Ignatius/Washington Post) Read article washingtonpost.com
  7. France asks itself if it remains a great power (Norimitsu Onishi/NYTimes) -submarine-deal-australia.html Read article goog_2113914159
  8. Big EU countries want an independent path but are increasingly forced to choose between Washington and Beijing (Lawrence Norman/Drew Hinshaw/Wall Street Journal; Thanks to James Pickering) Read article wsj.com

All newsletters