As the Christmas season approaches, the world's supply chains are continuing to struggle to meet demand. The system which emerged in the 1990s, and gained steam following the accession of China into the WTO, was optimized for maximum efficiency, with companies moving to to take advantage of low cost production by globalizing their value chains. According to Deloitte, as supply chains moved abroad, global trade jumped from 39% of global GDP to 58% between 1990 and 2019 - mostly to the benefit of consumers and companies able to optimize these value chains.
Unfortunately, as we know now, the pandemic exposed that the system -- which excelled at delivering goods at low cost -- was not very resilient. Indeed, the pandemic laid bare a number of issues already in train. In an article published in January 2019 -- before most knew that the Covid-19 would ravage the global economy -- The Economist noted that "slowbalisation" was already afflicting global value chains. Problems becoming apparent included the impact of tariffs and trade wars and stricter criteria for bank lending. In the United States, this set of issues was compounded by other factors: the lack of investment in ports and infrastructure, cuts in the railroad workforce, and lack of coordination and cooperation amongst the key stakeholders. The result has been a system cobbled together and under increasing stress.
As a number of researchers have pointed out, the risks to value chains are growing - and they come from a wide range of sources: political instability (80% of trade involves countries with declining political stability scores), economic issues such as the aforementioned tariffs and trade wars, climate change and related weather events, cyber-events (an increasing concern with the digitization of value chains), etc.
These risks cannot be eliminated, but they can be managed. As a McKinsey report states, technology can help with overcoming, or at least mitigating, some of these risks. Companies can do a better job of contingency planning, build in redundancy and, where appropriate, share information. There is an important role for government as well - the Trump Administration's Office of Science and Technology Policy budget priorities for FY 2021 highlighted the importance of creating development critical infrastructure and U.S. advanced manufacturing to cope with natural and man-made disasters, including cyber-attacks and exploitation of supply chain vulnerabilities. A key element of that strategy was encouraging "reshoring" of manufacturing back to the US.
However, as a Brookings Institution study astutely observed "...design and operation of a supply chain is highly dependent on the product. Functional products with long life cycles and relatively small demand variability require cost efficient supply chains that can be offshored. Innovative products with short life cycles and relatively high demand variability require market-responsive supply chains with nearshored or domestic sourcing and production. Products of critical importance to defense, security, health, and national competitiveness require the federal government to take a special interest in their supply chains. Today, such products include rare-earth metals, artificial intelligence, hypersonic weaponry, 5G technology, semiconductors, pharmaceuticals, synthetic biology, and specialized medical equipment.
As the Brookings Study intimates, not focusing on supply chains is very dangerous. Other countries - particularly China - have already made major investments in strengthening their supply chain resilience both at home and abroad. The trick will be for the United States to do it in a way that does not undermine America's economic competitiveness by stifling one of our great advantages: serving as the linchpin of an open and competitive trading system.
Also in this roundup, California's farmers face a reckoning on water and Alice Waters and Chez Panisse at 50.
Happy Reading!