What does Russia want from Ukraine?

Sources (12) ↓

The overriding issue this week remains Russia's threat to invade Ukraine. Russian President Vladimir Putin has stationed than 100,000 men on the long border between the two countries, and issued a set of demands, including that NATO agree never to admit Ukraine as a member and, more recently, that Poland, Hungary and other former members of the Warsaw Pact (the former Soviet-led alliance in Eastern Europe) withdraw from NATO and remove American and other NATO troops. There are a number of reasons for Russia's posture, some of which are deeply historical and some of which are more recent - and personal - for Putin.

Historically, Russia, Belarus, and Ukraine all consider Kievan Rus, a loose federation of Slavic, Baltic and Finnish peoples centered on Kyiv, the capital of modern Ukraine, to be the historical wellspring of Slavic culture. Since the early 800's, Russian and Ukrainian history have been intertwined, though most of Ukraine was also part of the Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth from 1572 to 1795 - giving Ukraine a somewhat more Western orientation than Russia.

After the collapse of the Russian Empire and the creation of the Soviet Union, Ukraine's boundaries were set - somewhat arbitrarily - for internal administrative purposes rather than based on historical or ethnic frontiers. The somewhat arbitrary nature of these boundaries, and the presence of a sizable Russian minority, has made a clean break between Russia and Ukraine difficult, though Russia's seizure of the Crimea and support of separatists in the Donbas region has - somewhat unhelpfully for Putin - removed many ethnic Russians from the internal Ukrainian equation. His behavior in Crimea and Donbas has also alienated many Russian speakers still living in Ukraine.

But Putin has other reasons than just history on his mind. Russia has not truly prospered under Putin; while job growth is solid, inflation and income inequality are high, standards of living are down, and the economy is hugely dependent on extractive industries such as coal and natural gas. Ukraine - in part because of its more Westernized history - has been steadily drifting away from the Russian sphere of influence. This process accelerated with the collapse of the Soviet Union - an event which Putin has referred to as the "greatest geopolitical catastrophe" of the 20th century. While still beset by corruption and mismanagement, Ukraine clearly has made great progress since ejecting its Moscow-backed President, Viktor Yanukovitch, in 2014 - a serious blackeye for Putin.

The idea of a successful, pro-Western democracy on the borders of Russia is probably a nightmare scenario for Putin, and would surely exacerbate Russia's isolation. But the costs of an invasion would also be extremely high - Russian soldiers coming home in coffins, financial and economic sanctions, international opprobrium, a renewed sense of purpose for NATO (along with the possibility of Swedish and Finnish membership) -- none of this would help Russia in the longer term. Nor would China be particularly happy, with the Winter Olympics set to begin in a few days - though it might help China justify a forcible reunification of Taiwan.

Opinion seems divided on whether Putin will actually invade - some sources see it as all but inevitable, and cite Putin's belief that the West in general and the United States in particular are in disarray and unable to unify. These sources note that he is driven by revanchism and has wanted to retaliate for America's ousting of Russia from Eastern Europe for a long while. Other observers caution that Russia has not even really tried to lay the groundwork for such an invasion at home - the media, under Putin's thumb, has not really built a case internally for invasion, which would seem to be an important consideration before going to war. The only sure thing here is that - once again - Putin has kept the West guessing about his true intentions..

Also in this roundup - Open Table data shows that San Francisco's restaurants are rebounding from Covid and wildfire risks are causing insurers to drop coverage for homes in fire-prone areas.

Sources

Links go to the original publishers. Some require a subscription.

  1. "On the Historical Unity of Russians and Ukrainians" (Vladimir Putin/Office of the Russian President) Read article en.kremlin.ru
  2. A war in Ukraine could have global consequences (The Economist) Read article economist.com
  3. What does Russia want with Ukraine? (Dan Bilefsky/NYTimes) Read article nytimes.com
  4. Putin's Poker (Nina Khruscheva, Robert Skidelski, Hilary Apel, Javier Solana et al/Project Syndicate) Read article project-syndicate.org
  5. Putin has the US right where he wants us (Fiona Hill/NYTimes) Read article nytimes.com
  6. Vladimir Putin does not think like we do (Michael McFaul/Washington Post) Read article washingtonpost.com
  7. Putin rues collapse of Soviet Union as demise of "Historical Russia" (Andrew Osborn and Andrey Ostroukh/Reuters) Read article reuters.com
  8. The Putin Doctrine (Angela Stent/Foreign Affairs) Read article foreignaffairs.com
  9. Is a Russia - Ukraine war inevitable? (Matthew Boulegue/Chatham House) Read article chathamhouse.org
  10. How the United States should respond if Russia invades Ukraine - (Max Bergman/Center for American Progress) Read article americanprogress.org
  11. Open Table shows SF restaurants are rebounding (Amy Coval/SF Chronicle) Read article sfchronicle.com
  12. Wildfire risk drives insurers to pull policies for pricy homes (Leslie Scism/Wall Street Journal) Read article wsj.com

All newsletters