California's economy is strong. Why is everyone so unhappy?

Sources (13) ↓

Most people know Shasta County -- and its primary city, Redding -- as waypoints on Interstate 5 heading to Oregon, but this past week the county made headlines for its recall of the Chairman of the Board of Supervisors. The news is noteworthy because the chairman is a conservative Republican and former police chief of Redding - who was removed, not for malfeasance, but for not being conservative enough. The question is whether this is a flash in the pan or a harbinger of things to come for California. (The city of San Francisco is also facing a set of recalls of its own, with both members of the school board and District Attorney facing tough recalls).

Recent polling from the Public Policy Institute of California (PPIC) indicates Shasta County's frustrations may not be an isolated phenomenon. Californians, PPIC finds, are deeply unhappy with the direction of the state. 66% of all likely voters, including 51% of registered Democrats, believe that the State of California is heading in the wrong direction - both are large increases over the past year (in January 2021, 32% of all Democrats and 50% of all voters believed that the State was moving in the wrong direction).

This feeling of pessimism is mirrored at the national level. Gallup, which has been measuring America's mood in 29 areas for more than 20 years, found that just 38% of Americans feel positive about America's direction - a consistent trend in their polling, though one that has accelerated recently.

The odd disconnect here is that by a range of measures America is doing quite well. Bankruptcies are down, and poverty -- particularly child poverty -- has fallen below pre-pandemic levels. Here in California, the state's economy is booming, the state treasury has shown enormous budget surpluses in the past two years, and the US Department of Labor shows that California's unemployment continues to decline - down to 6.5%, only a bit higher than the overall 6% unemployment in the US economy. There are also many job openings, and frequently not enough trained workers for those openings. The state's budget surplus is being put to use in job training, fire management and suppression, widening access to broadband communications, increasing educational access, and transportation upgrades.

There are a number of likely culprits for this sense of malaise across the US: inflation is most assuredly up - the highest rates in 40 years. Other factors include continuing frustration with the pandemic - and disagreements between factions on the proper response; political tensions in Congress, within the legal system, and now even down to the local level - school boards and city councils are now in the front ranks of American divisiveness. Supply chain disruption also contribute to a sense of frustration.

Despite its consistent blue streak, California mirrors many of these trends -- and adds extremely high housing prices. Indeed, California may even have a larger gulf between urban and rural regions than the rest of the country, given the sense of alienation that emanates from the inland areas of the state, who feel that there votes do not matter much (despite those areas receiving a higher percentage of state resources than the well-to-do regions).

There are some potentially serious consequences to this pervasive pessimism. California is key to Democratic hopes to hold on to the Congress, and frustration amongst Democratic and Independent voters augurs poorly for the November elections. As PPIC's Mark Baldsassare states, a retreat by Omicron and improved economy could help get past some of the pessimism, and Californians would likely respond well if their elected representatives could get past bickering to get things done. But, he notes, that could be a tall order.....

Also in this roundup, in turns out that Confederate street names don't help home prices in many parts of the country.

Sources

Links go to the original publishers. Some require a subscription.

  1. In the far north of California, the far right shows that it has some muscle (Kurtis Alexander/SF Chronicle) Read article sfchronicle.com
  2. Widespread disaffection amongst California's likely voters (Mark Baldassare/PPIC) Read article ppic.org
  3. Our economy is doing well - but many Americans refuse to believe it (Fareed Zakaria/Washington Post) Read article washingtonpost.com
  4. Disrupted California (Lt Gov Kounalakis in discussion with CSIS) Read article csis.org
  5. American happiness hits record lows (Harry Enten/CNN) Read article edition.cnn.com
  6. New data indicates that Americans are more miserable than they've been in half a century (Christopher Ingraham/The Why Axis) Read article thewhyaxis.substack.com
  7. Welcome to America in 2022, where everyone has rights and no one has responsibilities (Tom Friedman/NY Times) Read article nytimes.com
  8. California economy at a glance (US Department of Labor) Read article bls.gov
  9. California's unemployment rate falls to 6.5% (California Employment Development Department) Read article edd.ca.gov
  10. US poverty fell last year (Ben Casselman and Jeanna Smialek/NY Times) Read article nytimes.com
  11. California budget priorities for 2022 (Office of the Legislative Analyst, Sacramento) Read article lao.ca.gov
  12. A pro family agenda for California begins in California (Laura Tyson and Lenny Mendonca/Project Syndicate) Read article project-syndicate.org
  13. Confederate street names lead to lower prices (Kristin Capps/Bloomberg City Lab) Read article bloomberg.com

All newsletters