As democracy takes a beating, political instability is on the rise....
Recent developments around the world point to rising political instability. The consequences could portend a period of extreme turmoil even in countries with long histories of democratic stability.
In just the past three weeks:
In the UK, Boris Johnson survived a vote of No Confidence from within his own Conservative Party on June 6 with a very slim majority - 40% of own party leaders do not believe he should be Prime Minister. Reasons cited included a bungled Brexit, no relief from regulations that Brexit was supposed to fix, "Partygate," and a general sense of malaise within the Tory party. To make things worse on June 23, the Conservatives lost two more usually reliable seats in a by-election, prompting the Tory Chairman, Oliver Dowdon, to release a bombshell resignation letter stating that "someone must take responsibility" for the defeat. Speculation is now rampanton how long Johnson will remain in office as Prime Minister. The only point in his favor at the moment is the lack of a replacement in waiting.
In France, legislative elections this week cost President Emmanuel Macron his parliamentary majority. Macron had built a centrist coalition, Ensemble!, and while he held on to his majority, disillusioned voters who wanted to demonstrate their unhappiness either went to the left (to the New Ecological and Social People's Union (NUPES), led by far-left Jean-Luc Mélenchon, or to the right (Marine Le Pen's National Rally party). Macron has labored to enact a wide range of economic, administrative and financial reforms, and this will now be much more difficult. Both Le Pen and Melanchon were once considered fringe candidates, and both have been somewhat "normalized" by this election. French politics, always tumultuous, are now likely to become more paralyzed than ever.
In Israel, the defection of a small party from the governing coalition has triggered Israel's fifth election in three years, and opens the door for a potential return of former Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu. The election comes at a delicate time for Israel, with both Palestinian attacks and the shadow war with Iran heating up. President Biden is due to head to Israel in July, and will now be greeted by a caretaker Prime Minister. A return to power by Netanyahu would likely complicate the relationship with the Biden Administration.
As for the United States, the ongoing January 6 investigation has clearly demonstrated that the insurrection at the Capitol was far more dangerous - and far more planned - than originally believed. Perhaps even worse, as the January 6 committee unearths more evidence that former President Donald Trump endeavored to subvert the democratic system, the Supreme Court has overturned long standing legal precedent to enact an agenda at odds with views of the majority of Americans. By so doing it has likely inflamed America's already overheated politics and also eviscerated much of its legitimacy in the eyes of the American public. It has also moved away from many of the characteristics that made the United States a model for much of the world to emulate.
These trends are very dangerous - the United States, France, Great Britain, Israel -- and also Turkey, India, Hungary and South Africa, among others -- portend a time of electoral instability at a time when the West needs to address a wide range of issues - the Russian war on Ukraine, a global food crisis, climate change, migration issues -- all are urgent. The cost of electoral dysfunction only make addressing these issues even more difficult.