Shinzo Abe's complicated legacy

Sources (13) ↓

The assassnation of Shinzo Abe on July 8, while campaigning for a Liberal Democratic Party (LDP) candidate, stunned not only Japan but also most of the world. Widely regarded as the most consequential politician of post-war Japan, he was also one of the most important post-war political leaders in the Asia Pacific region (or, as he coined the term, the "Indo-Pacific") The shock was magnified in Japan by the country's lack of gun violence: In 2021, there was a single murder by firearm a country of 128 million people (and fewer than 10 shootings, not counting suicides or accidents).

Abe's legacy is complicated. More than most countries, Japan's past has a profound influence on its present. Following Imperial Japan's surrender in World War II, the US (mostly a team of lawyers overseen by General Douglas MacArthur) wrote a Constitution for Japan which severely limited the nation's military power. Though the world's second largest economy for much of the postwar period - until superseded by China - Japan's international profile was extremely limited. Abe set out to change that by "normalizing" Japan's place in the world. Many of the themes he identified during his first premiership (2007-8, cut short for health reasons), set the stage for his long run of eight years as Prime Minister between 2012-2020. Abe believed that for Japan to become a globally respected leader, it needed to become more dynamic both domestically and internationally.

Domestically, Abe was determined to pull Japan out of the "lost decades" of economic doldrums through "Abenomics" - a mixture of pump-priming economic stimulus initiatives focused on the stock market and by bringing many more women into the workforce, the latter of key importance given Japan's declining birth rate and low immigration. While he did indeed succeed in increasing employment opportunities for women, his efforts to pump-prime the stock market by encouraging Japan's national pension fund to invest in stocks are now considered to have been somewhat ineffective and indeed, likely to have increased economic inequality, since stocks in Japan are generally owned by wealthier individuals.

It was in the international sphere that Abe achieved his greatest recognition. As Ken Moriyasu of Nikkei Asia emphasized, Abe identified three strategic concerns in the Asia-Pacific for Japan to address: North Korea, China and Russia. His initiatives were therefore designed to expand the network of nations sharing those strategic concerns and economic values and to shore up American and allied integration into the region. In his second term as Prime Minister, he pushed forward the Japanese EU trade agreement, the Japan-UK trade deal, and the Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP) -- all as a means of countering China's economic dominance in the region. In the realm of security, he championed the "Quad," an informal grouping of Japan, the United States, Australia and India (hence the term "Indo-Pacific") and reinterpreted defense guidelines in Japan to allow for increased military spending and deployment by the Japanese Self-Defense Forces. In all these cases, Abe was instrumental in bringing together a group of disparate nations, in large part by building relationships with a wide range of leaders, from Donald Trump to Narendra Modi in India.

However successful Abe's ambitious foreign and security agendas were, his goals were undercut by Abe's support for a range of nationalist and right-wing organizations in Japan, including Nippon Kaigi, which denies Japan's culpability for kidnapping and enslaving Korean "comfort women." Abe also visited Yasokune Shrine in Tokyo, a memorial to Japan's war dead -- including 14 Class A war criminals from World War II (Class A indicates involvement in pre-meditated genocide). These moves severely dampened his ability to work with South Korea or engage with China - both countries have long and painful memories of Japanese aggression in World War II. His embrace of right wing nationalist organizations did not win him any friends in those countries - or anywhere else in Asia.

As expected, Abe's assasination led to an uptick in votes for the LDP, and ensured that the party remains firmly in power. But his inability to help Japan come to terms with its wartime past represents a continuing missed opportunity for the Japan he hoped to "normalize."

Sources

Links go to the original publishers. Some require a subscription.

  1. Shinzo Abe's Formidable Legacy in Japan and the World (Ian Bremmer/Time) Read article time.com
  2. Shinzo Abe's special place (Aurelia George Mulgan/East Asia Review) Read article eastasiaforum.org
  3. Abe's legacy looms large for current Japanese PM (Foster Klug and Mari Yamaguch/MSN) Read article msn.com
  4. Abe left a mark on Asia, not just Japan (The Economist) Read article economist.com
  5. The highlight of Abe's legacy is forging Asia's security (Akhil Ramesh/MSNBC) Read article msn.com
  6. Shinzo Abe's legacy of global economic order (Matthew Goodman/CSIS) Read article csis.org
  7. Shinzo Abe: The legacy of Japan's longest serving Prime Minister (Yuko Kato & Zubaidah Abdul Jalil/BBC) Read article bbc.com
  8. Shinzo Abe's legacy: China, North Korea, Russia (Ken Moriyasu interview with DW News) Read article twitter.com
  9. Abe's nationalism was his most toxic legacy (S Nathan Park/Foreign Policy) Read article foreignpolicy.com
  10. Shinzo Abe: the disputed legacy of a politician who dominated public life in Japan after World War II (Saori Shibata/The Conversation) Read article theconversation.com
  11. The legacy of Shinzo Abe (interview with Frederick Dickinson/Penn today) Read article penntoday.upenn.edu
  12. Shinzo Abe's complicated political legacy (Jeffrey Kingston interview by Miles Parks/NPR) Read article npr.org
  13. The US should support Japan's efforts to legitimize its military (Washington Post editorial) Read article washingtonpost.com

All newsletters