Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi's visit to Taiwan on August 2 has very much roiled the Asia Pacific, sending US-China relations - already at a low point - even further into the deep freeze. Most observers anticipate that the damage will be contained - neither Washington nor Beijing wants a potentially disastrous military confrontation. But the tension is real, and the situation could easily become more fraught if either China or the US miscalculate.
While Pelosi's visit was short, the reverberations were immediate and continuing. China - which asserts that the island nation is simply a renegade province which must be reunified with the motherland -- announced military exercises and initiated live-fire drills around Taiwan, and at times crossed into Taiwanese airspace. China also launched five missiles into Japan's Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ), likely as a way of warning Japan that its role as an American ally (hosting five major military bases and a number of smaller installations) does not provide it with immunity. In response, the White House summoned China's envoy to the US, Ambassador Qin Gang, warning that China's military exercises were “irresponsible and at odds with our long-standing goal of maintaining peace and stability across the Taiwan Strait." Such summons are rare, and demonstrate extreme unhappiness by the host nation.
Why Pelosi chose this moment to lead a congressional delegation to Taiwan is not entirely clear. She has a long history of challenging China, and was particularly offended by the 1989 crackdown ending pro-democracy demonstrations in Tiananmen Square. Her stated reasons - contained in an opinion piece in the Washington Post -- assert that her visit is in accord with the Taiwan Relations Act, which was passed in 1979 in response to the withdrawal of US diplomatic recognition of Taiwan and recognition of the PRC as the sole government of China (the "One China Policy"). The Act -- "designed to maintain peace, security, and stability in the Western Pacific'' -- also states that the American "decision to establish diplomatic relations with the People's Republic of China rests upon the expectation that the future of Taiwan will be determined by peaceful means." Pelosi's article makes clear that she believes that China's rhetoric, as well as its military, economic and cyber pressure on Taiwan, has violated the spirit of the Act (it should be noted that the Chinese do not accept the Act's validity). She also refers to China's moves to curtail democracy in Hong Kong, in violation of the basic law negotiated with Great Britain before the 1997 handover.
This is a particularly sensitive time for China. The Twentieth Party Congress of the Communist Party is due to take place in October, with President Xi Jinping intent upon an unprecedented third term. Domestically, Xi needs to appear assertive and determined. With the economy cooling and Covid not under control despite the "zero-tolerance" policy, Xi needs to be seen as a strong defender of China's sovereignty and territorial integrity. To bring that point home, in addition to the military exercises, China also announced the end of cooperation with the US in a range of areas such as climate change. Many Chinese, however, believe that the government has not matched its rhetoric with actions, forcing the government to walk a tightrope -- appearing strong and determined while not allowing the situation to actually get out of hand.
The Pelosi visit also did not go down well with the Biden Administration, already preoccupied with managing the response to the Russian invasion of Ukraine. Many observers see Pelosi's visit as accentuating the continuing incoherence in American policy towards China. After at first urging the speaker to delay her trip, the Administration acquiesced and provided logistical support. Secretary of State Blinken endeavored to strike a reasonable but firm tone with China, asserting that while the US does not seek confrontation it "will fly, sail, and operate wherever international law allows." He also noted that the executive and legislative branches are separate - meaning that as Speaker of the House Pelosi has wide latitude to make decisions without consulting the Biden Administration. America's friends and allies in Europe and Asia worried about the complications from the visit, seeing this as one more issue at a time of increased international tension. One caveat however, was Japan, where officials expressed concern over the tension but also seemed likely to increase funding for the "Self-Defense" forces.
As for Taiwan, despite the international furor, most people went about their business pretty much as usual. But underneath the calm, the stress underscored the increasing generational divide inside Taiwan, with older Taiwanese concerned about keeping a lid on tensions with China while the younger (and decidedly more democratically minded) generation see the strain as further evidence of the widening divide between the Republic of China (ROC) and the People's Republic of China (PRC). That internal divide over Taiwan's future is ultimately where the real danger lies for peace in the Asia Pacific region.