On May 25, Pope Leo XIV delivered the first encyclical of his tenure, Magnifica Humanitas ("Magnificent Humanity"), and he chose the most consequential topic he could possibly address: the relationship between human intelligence and well-being on one side, and artificial intelligence on the other. According to Simply Catholic, an encyclical is a pastoral letter addressed by the pope to the whole Church, though its subject frequently carries relevance well beyond Catholic circles. This one puts Leo squarely at the center of the defining debate of our time.
What distinguishes the encyclical from most policy discussions is its frame. Rather than approaching AI from a regulatory, business, or geopolitical perspective, Leo addresses something deeper: humanity's place in a future increasingly shaped by non-human intelligence. His central warning is about the concentration of power — including the power to shape perceptions of reality itself — in the hands of a few individuals operating beyond government oversight, who may or may not have the best interests of their fellow human beings at heart. The timing was deliberate: Leo signed the document on May 15, the 135th anniversary of Pope Leo XIII's Rerum Novarum, the landmark encyclical on the social upheaval of industrialization. Leo XIV has drawn the parallel explicitly, describing AI as ushering in a "new industrial revolution."
Significantly, the Pope did not confine himself to Catholic teaching and theology. He drew from a deep well of scholars, philosophers, historians, and artists — many from outside the Catholic and Christian traditions — to build his case. Plato emerges to remind us that the most important human lessons come from time and lived experience, from "rubbing concepts and experiences together like pieces of flint" — a pointed rebuke to AI's promise of frictionless, instant knowledge. Hannah Arendt, a Jewish survivor of Nazi persecution, is invoked to warn that in an era of deep fakes and manufactured reality, the ideal subjects of totalitarian regimes are not the ideologically convinced, but people for whom the distinction between fact and fiction, and between true and false, has ceased to exist. J.R.R. Tolkien's The Lord of the Rings appears with unmistakable purpose: Tolkien's entire mythology turns on the corrupting nature of concentrated power and the moral weight of ordinary people's choices — precisely the encyclical's twin concerns. Martin Luther King Jr. and Nelson Mandela are both cited as individuals of conscience who confronted systemic oppression and changed the world, affirming that human agency still matters.
The most illuminating secular parallel to the Pope's central argument comes from Columbia Law School professor Anu Bradford, whose work provides the analytical infrastructure the encyclical implicitly calls for. In The Brussels Effect and Digital Empires, Bradford argues that the world's digital future is being contested among three competing models: the American market-driven model, which concentrates wealth and power at the top while resisting regulation; the Chinese state-driven model, which subordinates individual rights to state control; and the European rights-driven model, which places human dignity and democratic accountability at the center of governance. Bradford's conclusion — that the EU model offers the most viable template for protecting individuals in the digital age — is precisely what the encyclical endorses, arriving there from moral theology rather than regulatory theory.
The convergence is especially sharp on the question of private power. Leo XIV's alarm that transnational technology firms now surpass many governments in resources and reach is the exact dynamic Bradford maps in Digital Empires. And when the Pope calls for "adequate regulatory tools" and "independent oversight bodies" to ensure that no single company or state can monopolize AI's direction, he is describing, in the language of Catholic social doctrine, the kind of robust, rights-based regulatory framework Bradford argues the EU model alone has the architecture to deliver — and, through what she calls the Brussels Effect, the market leverage to project globally.
Bradford and Pope Leo XIV begin in entirely different worlds. She works from empirical analysis of regulatory systems and geopolitical competition; he works from scripture, tradition, and the theology of human dignity. But they arrive at the same destination: the concentration of AI's power in unaccountable private hands is the defining danger of our moment, and meeting it requires not just technical fixes but a fundamental commitment to the rights and dignity of every person.