Back to the Future? Consequences of the Russian Invasion of Ukraine

Sources (15) ↓

When the USSR collapsed in 1989, the feeling across Europe and the West was that after a terrible 75 year detour caused by the disaster of the First World War (Nazism, Communism and Fascism all took root following the Great War), the transition to a rules-based liberal world order was underway and, indeed, inevitable. Francis Fukuyama famously encapsulated this view in his essay "The End of History," later turned into a book in 1992. The buzzword at the Conference on Security and Cooperation (CSCE) and conference on Conventional Forces in Europe (CFE) following the end of the Soviet Union was the creation of a "Europe whole and free."

Despite the series of low-level conflicts following the collapse of the Soviet Union, from the Balkin conflicts of the 1990s to the seizure of Ukrainian territory in Crimea and Donbas and Luhansk, the idea of a large-scale European land war has seemed remote. No longer - Vladimir Putin has put major war in Europe back on the table, and Russia has now inserted itself into the strategic competition already underway between the US and China. Putin's - and his closest advisors - motives appear to be a complex stew of Russian nationalism, a revanchist desire to restore at least some of the boundaries of the former Soviet Union, and a restoration of Russian greatness, all with a healthy dollop of Russian Orthodoxy mixed in. Much of this rationale was encapsulated in a speech by Putin on February 21, in which he declared that Ukraine had no reason to exist independent from Russia. The speech has been variously described as "paranoid," "fantastical," "unhinged," "crazed," and "divorced from reality". Crazed speech or not, it forms the basis for an invasion whose consequences could be momentous.

For Russia, war in the Ukraine is likely to leave the country economically hobbled as a result of economic and financial sanctions. Russia has deep financial reserves, but will lose access to financial markets and even potentially the ability to export commodities (it is the world's largest exporter of wheat, for example). As a foretaste of things to come, the stock market, the MOEX, lost more than 35% of its value in a major collapse, and the Russian Central Bank had to intervene to prop up the Ruble, which dropped to historic lows. The country's access to Western technology, including semiconductors, will be severely limited. Russia will also likely become less secure, since NATO is remarkably unified about the threat and is already moving troops closer to the border, including into the Baltic states. There will be renewed discussion about NATO expansion to previous neutral countries such as Finland, Sweden and even Austria. Russia has already become diplomatically isolated at the UN and other international fora, and is losing major sporting events such UEFA and Formula 1 racing. All of these moves will likely make the country more dependent on China, where it is already the junior partner in that relationship. And even China seems to have been taken aback by Putin's war, calling for respecting negotiations and territorial integrity, though Chinese leaders may also see something of an opportunity in the conflict as well.

For the US and its European allies, the result will likely be higher costs for energy, increased volatility in the stock market, higher prices for commodities, potentially heavier inflationary pressure, and additional burdens on defense budgets. Europeans in particular will be expected to spend more to counter Russia's military. The US, despite its inflationary spike, looked poised for a strong economic rebound - that may now be less likely. There are now concerns that cyber-warfare could become a serious feature between Russia and the West. Other countries - particularly poorer nations in Africa and Asia, will see costs rise particularly for energy and commodities -- particularly agricultural exports. This could have very negative consequences for the poorer segments of society.

It is often said that you don't really miss something until it's gone. The stability that the world enjoyed with the end of the Cold War has now been lost - and indeed, a new Cold War may now be beginning. But this conflict should also remind the world - particularly those in the West, of the important values represented by a liberal, rules-based international order.

Sources

Links go to the original publishers. Some require a subscription.

  1. Ukraine invasion is Putin's most aggressive move yet to restore Russia's place in the world (Ann M Simmons/Wall Street Journal) Read article wsj.com
  2. Vladimir Putin does not think like we do (Michael McFaul/Washington Post) Read article washingtonpost.com
  3. Statement by President Vladimir Putin (In Russian with English voiceover/CSPAN) Read article c-span.org
  4. Why Vladimir Putin and his entourage wanted war (Alexander Glabuev/The Economist) Read article economist.com
  5. Russia's invasion of Ukraine will change the face of Europe forever (Timothy Garton Ash/The Guardian) Read article theguardian.com
  6. Implications of Russia's invasion of Ukraine (short contributions from Brookings Institute Fellows) Read article brookings.edu
  7. Invasion of Ukraine kicks off new China Russia US competition (Michael Gordon/Wall Street Journal) Read article wsj.com
  8. Russia's lethal identity crisis (Carl Bildt/Project Syndicate) Read article project-syndicate.org
  9. Putin is making a historic mistake (Madeleine Albright/NYTimes) Read article nytimes.com
  10. What we can expect after Putin's conquest of Ukraine (Robert Kagan/Washington Post) - () Read article washingtonpost.com
  11. Ukraine shows why liberal democracy is worth defending (Fareed Zakaria/Washington Post) Read article washingtonpost.com
  12. Russia's Ukraine invasion continues - what it means for US stocks, gas prices and cyber security (Dan Avery/CNET) Read article cnet.com
  13. America's unprecedented attack on Russia's technological fabric (The Economist) Read article economist.com
  14. Decoupling Russia - the global economy's new unknown (Mark John/Reuters) Read article reuters.com
  15. Surprising cracks, if small ones, in Putin's preparation for war (David Ignatius/Washington Post) Read article washingtonpost.com

All newsletters