The Russian invasion of Ukraine has prompted the rapid imposition of the most severe economic sanctions ever imposed on any nation - short of war, of course. The speed and comprehensiveness of these actions, which have gone far beyond what were expected in the event of a Russian attack, have upended calculations on the impact of trade sanctions as a tool in international diplomacy.
Sanctions are often seen as a half-way house between direct intervention and doing nothing, and as such have generally been seen as ineffective in the short-term and dubiously effective in the longer term. Certainly, when looking at North Korea, Cuba, South Africa, Rhodesia, Iran and Venezuela, the impact has been mixed: clearly working in the case of South Africa and Rhodesia, and generally conceded to be painful but not leading to regime change - or even behavior change - in the other cases.
There are several reasons these sanctions against Russia might be more effective than any previous effort. First, the response has been remarkably unified - the collective economic muscle of the United States, European Union, Japan, South Korea, Canada, and Australia is unprecedented. The $42 trillion GDP of the G7 countries (US, Germany, UK, Canada, Japan, Italy, France) alone is nearly half that of global GDPof $94 trillion ($42.5 ) - and that does not account for the rest of the EU, South Korea or Australia, of of whom have imposed their own sanctions. As Paul Krugman has pointed out, not even China - if it chose to bust the sanctions regime - can make up for that loss of trade and income. Based on previous history, President Putin has badly miscalculated that there would never be a unified response of this magnitude in preparing for war - even famously neutral Switzerland has joined in.
Second, these sanctions transcend government actions - a remarkable collection of companies have voluntarily disassociated themselves from the Russian economy, including iconic firms such as Starbucks, Coca-Cola, McDonalds, IBM, Microsoft, Apple, Mercedes-Benz, BP, Shell, Airbus and Boeing. Not all of these happened immediately - McDonalds and Coca-Cola were pressured by shareholders - but in the end they acquiesced. While Russians may be able to do without Big Macs for a while, they will have a very hard time flying across the 11 time zones if planes are grounded due to a lack of spare parts. (It should be noted that a few companies, such as Koch Industries, are continuing to do business).
Third, the sanctions transcend simple economics. Since the start of the conflict on February 24, sporting organizations such as FIFA and UEFA have banned Russian teams from participating, cultural organizations have cancelled programs in Russia and dismissed Russian artists seen as allies of President Putin, social media platforms have cut off offerings from RT and other state media accused of spreading disinformation, and tour companies have ceased operations.
The sanctions imposed on Russia have had and will have a much higher impact than other regimes in the past both because of their extraordinary comprehensiveness and the continued importance of global flows of goods, services and technology. The lack of spare parts, finance, managerial talent and semiconductors will take a tremendous toll on Russian economic development, while the cultural and sporting sanctions make it clear just how isolated Russia has become. Longer term, they will affect Russian efforts to remain competitive across a range of industries and likely make the country even more dependent on China. And despite the seizure of oligarch's yachts and the freezing of their assets, they will likely affect the average Russian much more than the wealthier classes.
There will almost assuredly be long term effects on the global system, however. Not only Russia, but other countries seeing themselves as vulnerable to sanctions such as China and Saudi Arabia will double down on efforts to insulate themselves from future disruptions by developing domestic or alternate industries, sources of goods and services, supply chains, financial mechanisms and technologies, all designed to minimize dependency on outside sources. For example, China and Saudi Arabia are reportedly in discussion to allow RMB to be used for purchases of Saudi oil. These forces will accelerate a process of de-globalization already underway - though the US and China will find it hard to entirely de-couple from one another given the interrelationship of the two economies.
No one knows where all of this will lead - but one thing is clear: the global system that emerges from this disastrous war in Ukraine will be far different than what we saw even a few months ago.