A funny thing happened on the way to the (Tech) exit:

Sources (10) ↓

(Please note - delivery of the roundup may be somewhat delayed or missed during the month of April)

As is now commonly known, the pandemic has vastly changed the workforce landscape across America. Or rather, it accelerated already existent trends: how we work, the way we work and where we work. A number of important studies in the past two years - many from reputable institutions -- strongly indicated that these trends would undermine California's premier position as the epicenter of the tech world, resulting in a Golden State that was at once less innovative, poorer and more unlivable.

There were good reasons for some of these prognostications. California has indeed experienced a net exodus of population - so much that the state lost a congressional seat in the 2020 census. The combination of what the journalist Francis Cairncross called "the death of distance" - meaning the ability to work from anywhere -- along with frustrations over the high cost of doing business, a heavy regulatory load, a lack of affordable housing, and the state's seemingly intractable environmental issues (most particularly the rapidly expanding fire season) seemed to portend a mass exodus. The loss of iconic firms such as Tesla, HP, Oracle, Palantir, Charles Schwab and McKesson -- put an exclamation mark on what looked like the end of California's place at the top.

Turns out that this prognosis might have been a bit premature. A recent study by The Brookings Institution - and amplified by LA Times business correspondent Michael Hiltzik -- indicates that while California faces significant challenges, it remains in the forefront in many indicators of innovation, prosperity and job creation. The Brookings study notes that the size and depth of the ecosystem matters a great deal, and has remained stable over time. The premier cities in the innovation universe- San Francisco and Silicon Valley, New York, Boston, Washington, DC, Seattle, Los Angeles and Austin, have remained stable. "Rising stars" - second tier cities -- include Dallas, Atlanta, Denver, San Diego, Miami, Kansas City, Salt Lake City, St. Louis and Orlando have also seen growth. Every other location composes the third tier. The study notes that the pandemic did lead to dispersal of businesses and individuals - just not as much as was expected. First tier cities actually expanded their footprint by .3%, while second tier cities by .1%, both were lower than before the pandemic, but still positive. The most deleterious effects were on those areas hoping to capitalize on the tech exodus from major hubs.

People have indeed moved out of California, but frequently not that far. The Brookings study notes that workers disperse to exurbs and rural areas within driving distance - the so-called "donut effect." It turns out that there is still a need for in person meetings and team interactions, even in the tech world. Companies also have not moved as far away as initially thought. Corporate headquarters have moved to take advantage of lower taxes, but frequently leave design and creative teams in place in California and other tech hubs. In addition, the Brookings study, as well as other analyses, indicates that proximity to front rank academic institutions and other major companies -- important for cross-pollination -- matters a great deal, since both R&D and world class graduates are critical for the success of tech firms. And people have moved in - and apparently been undercounted. One of the key articles cited by researchers turned out to have under-estimated the number of people coming into the state, making the net exodus appear worse than it really was.

California has been aided in its efforts to retain top talent by mis-steps made by would-be suitors for California-based firms. Recent anti-LGBTQ and anti-abortion legislation in many states - predominantly in the South -- have severly dented the desirability of locations wanting to bring in creative talent from California and other tech hubs. Disney's CEO recently apologized to employees for not taking a stronger line against Florida's "don't say gay" bill, and Texas not only has issues with such legislation but now has serious problems with its increasingly vulnerable energy grid. Climate change, it turns out, affects other states besides California - floods, wildfires and high winds are serious problems in many locations.

California confronts a wide-range of problems, but it also has perhaps the most successful agglomeration of talent, innovation and capital on the planet. As one of the authors of the Brookings study mentioned when interviewed, “The California metropolises really do retain their irreplaceable depth and strength....That’s not to say there won’t be some movement. Early in the period we saw some exiting, especially from the Bay Area, but it turned out that much of it was within California, rather than to Kansas."

Sources

Links go to the original publishers. Some require a subscription.

  1. Superstars, rising stars and the rest: Pandemic trends in the geography of tech (Mark Muro and Wang You/Brookings) Read article brookings.edu
  2. California tech exodus was a bust (Michael Hiltzik/LA Times - thanks to Antonio Yung) Read article latimes.com
  3. Are people leaving the state of California? (Natalie Holmes/California Policy Lab) - . (The study which admits that it undercounted the number of people moving into California). Read article capolicylab.org
  4. The effect of high tech clusters on top inventors - (Enrico Moretti/American Economic Review) Read article pubs.aeaweb.org
  5. The geography of new technologies (Nicholas Bloom, Tarek Hassan, Aakash Kalyani, Josh Lerner and Ahmed Tahoun/Institute for New Economic Thinking) Read article ineteconomics.org
  6. The pandemic's devastating impact on women in the workforce (Michelle Jones/Duke University Human Resources Group) Read article sites.duke.edu
  7. PPIC Blog - Californians and their government - (housing, gas prices and Ukraine) Read article ppic.org
  8. Survey - Two-thirds of college educated workers may avoid Texas because of anti-abortion ban (Maggie McGrath/Forbes) Read article forbes.com
  9. Florida loses out on pivot conference in backlash over don't say gay (Ella Ceron/Bloomberg Equity) Read article bloomberg.com
  10. Disney CEO apologizes, halts political donations after failure to confront Florida's "don't say gay" bill (Curtis M. Wong/Yahoo News/Huffington Post) Read article news.yahoo.com

All newsletters