Sweden and Finland apply to join the club

Sources (17) ↓

On May 18, Sweden and Finland formally applied for NATO membership. If accepted - and Turkey is, at the moment, blocking fast track accession -- this would represent an important shift in the European balance of power. Both nations have formidable armed forces - Finland has a large army with a pool of trained reservists, and Sweden has very effective air and naval forces, and a robust domestic arms industry which produces a wide range of state of the art weapons - including the NLAW, the highly portable and highly effective tank-killer used by Ukraine's military.

The move represents an enormous shift in the domestic politics and foreign policies of Sweden and Finland. Sweden adopted its policy of non-alignment in 1814, near the end of the Napoleonic wars. Support for neutrality, including peacekeeping and nuclear disarmament, has become an important element of Swedish national identity.

Finland's neutrality, on the other hand, has been of a different sort: A part of Sweden until 1809, and then an autonomous and increasingly restive Grand Duchy under the Tsars, Finland broke away from the Russian Empire in 1917 following the collapse of the Romanov dynasty. After fighting with the Germans against Russia in World War II (to regain territory seized by Russia in the 1939-40 "Winter War), Finland signed a "Friendship Agreement" with the Soviet regime. The agreement avoided Russian occupation at the cost of 12% of Finland's territory, 20% of its industrial capacity and its second largest city, Vyborg. Finland also agreed to pay reparations and agreed to a neutral foreign policy - the origins of the term "Finlandization."

For both Sweden and Finland, neutrality has been historically quite popular - over the past 50 years, support for joining NATO in both countries was usually below 30%. But the Russian invasion of Ukraine has completely altered this equation, with large majorities now favoring NATO accession in both countries. Both militaries are in favor - the

In some ways, having Sweden and Finland join NATO does not really change much strategically - both nations identify as liberal Western democracies, both are members of NATO's "Partnership for Peace," and Swedish and Finnish military units are interoperable with NATO and routinely exercise with NATO forces. But for Russia, this is a very serious development. For one thing, it adds 837 miles (1348 kilometers) to the border, doubling the frontier between Russia and NATO from about 750 miles to nearly 1600 miles in total. It would put a NATO ally only 137 miles (220 kilometers) from St Petersburg, Russia's second city. It also means that the Baltic Sea would be almost entirely surrounded by NATO members, leaving the Russian city of Kaliningrad as an isolated enclave between Poland and Lithuania.

A Russian spokesperson initially warned of "detrimental consequences" for both Finland and Sweden should they join NATO, but President Putin's reaction has so far been restrained. While asserting that NATO membership would be "unfortunate," he stated that he saw no threat to Russia as long as the region was not "militarized" - and neither Sweden nor Finland will likely ask for the establishment of a NATO base.

Despite Putin's comments, the net result will likely be an even more aggrieved and alienated Russia. That, however, does not seem to worry Sweden or Finland. An unnamed high ranking Swedish defense official stated "it's about time," and former Finnish Prime Minister Alex Stubb asserted "better late than never."

Also in this roundup - neutral Switzerland leans closer to NATO.

Sources

Links go to the original publishers. Some require a subscription.

  1. How Putin's war in Ukraine backfired and fueled Nordic expansion (Patrick Smith/NBC) Read article nbcnews.com
  2. Sweden following Finland's lead on joining NATO (The Economist) Read article economist.com
  3. A new era of NATO expansion deepens the divide between Russia and the West (Robin Wright/The New Yorker) Read article newyorker.com
  4. What are Sweden and Finland thinking? (Stephen Walt/Belfer Center Harvard) Read article belfercenter.org
  5. Are Sweden and Finland going from neutral to NATO? (Phelan Chaterjee/BBC) Read article bbc.com
  6. After 200 years of neutrality, Sweden weighs joining NATO (Steven Erlanger/NYTimes) Link 1 nytimes.com Link 2 reuters.com
  7. Putin sees no threat from NATO buildup, warns of militarization (Reuters) Read article reuters.com
  8. NATO's Nordic expansion (Carl Bildt/Foreign Affairs) Read article foreignaffairs.com
  9. "Common sense being sacrificed" - Nordics joining NATO would be a mistake (Anurag Roushan/R Republic.com/India) Read article republicworld.com
  10. What is at stake if Sweden joins NATO? (Interview with Andreas Persbo/Institut Montaigne) Read article institutmontaigne.org
  11. Is NATO's Nordic expansion a threat or a boost to Europe? (Frank Gardner/BBC) Read article bbc.com
  12. Finland and Sweden joining NATO - everything that you need to know (Newsweek) Read article newsweek.com
  13. Sweden's evolving role with NATO and its implications for the Baltic Region (CSIS) Read article csis.org
  14. Support for NATO membership soars to 76% (Yle news-Finland) Read article yle.fi
  15. Growing support for Swedish membership in NATO (Reuters) Read article reuters.com
  16. Finland's NATO accession bid "better late than never" (DW) Read article dw.com
  17. Neutral Switzerland leans closer to NATO (John Revill/Reuters) Read article reuters.com

All newsletters