On May 23, during his visit to Tokyo, President Biden was asked if the United States would defend Taiwan. This is a fairly routine question for American policymakers visiting Asia, but this time the answer was unexpectedly candid - the President replied with a simple "yes," and in the process potentially upended more than 40 years of American policy. Within hours, White House and State Department officials immediately walked the statement back, asserting that despite the President's remarks, there were no changes in American policy.
What makes this situation unusual is that unlike the United States’ military alliances with Japan and South Korea, the US is not obligated to defend Taiwan. Rather, America’s relationship with the island is often defined as one of “strategic ambiguity.” The terms of the relationship are set out in the 1979 Taiwan Relations Act, which states that “the United States will make available to Taiwan such defense articles and defense services in such quantity as may be necessary to enable Taiwan to maintain sufficient self-defense capabilities.” The question of military intervention remains open, though successive administrations since Jimmy Carter have made clear that the interpretation of defense or no defense of Taiwan is up to the President. This policy of ambiguity has made it possible for China and the United States to have it both ways - the US acknowledges that Taiwan is a part of China (the One China policy) and both sides have been able to pursue a productive diplomatic and economic relationship. At the same time, Washington remains engaged with Taiwan, though not at the official diplomatic level.
There are concerns by some experts that President Biden's comments could be destabilizing. While the Taiwanese Foreign Ministry was quick to welcome the President’s statement, the Chinese Foreign Ministry expressed immediate displeasure. "We urge the US to stop saying or doing anything in violation of the one-China principle and the three China-US Joint Communiqués," China's Taiwan Affairs Office spokesperson Zhu Fenglian commented soon after the President's comments, adding, "Those who play with fire will certainly burn themselves."
What makes the situation particularly delicate at this time, particularly for China, is that President Xi Jinping is preparing for election to an unprecedented third term in October. He is under domestic pressure from China's slowing economy and difficulties in eradicating Covid. Under Xi, China's foreign and security policy have become more assertive both with respect to India and the South China Sea. Relations with the US remain difficult economically (the trade war) and politically, with little military to military communication in the Pacific.
Importantly, America's policy of strategic ambiguity is not only designed to deter China while navigating the complicated regional political environment. It is also aimed at deterring Taiwan's government from declaring its independence from Mainland China - a move which would quite likely provoke a military response from the PRC. For American policy makers, the status quo is therefore the safest alternative to increased tension and a potential confrontation. If any reminders were needed of the dangers of confrontation and conflict, Russia's disastrous war in Ukraine provides a useful warning of the unpredictability of such a collision - and maybe a deterrent to war in the Taiwan straits.