"No limits" apparently hits its limits....

Sources (11) ↓

President Xi and President Putin met on Sept 15 in Samarkand, Uzbekistan, at the annual meeting of the Shanghai Cooperation Summit (SCO). The SCO, founded in 2003, started out as a border security forum and has since become a political, economic and security organization. Russia, China, India, a number of Central Asian Republics, Turkey and now Iran are all members.

This is the 38th time the two presidents have held bilateral talks, and the first since they signed their “friendship with no limits” agreement in February just before Russia launched its invasion of Ukraine. The tone of the Putin-Xi meeting was cordial, with Xi calling Putin “my old friend.” Russia and China pledged - in the case of Russia somewhat ironically — to “inject stability into a turbulent world.” The friendly image masked serious issues at the forum, largely caused by Russia’s invasion. As the forum got underway, Putin himself acknowledged Xi’s “questions and concerns.”

The timing of the Summit could hardly have been worse for the Russian leader, with things going from bad to worse in Ukraine. An ongoing Ukrainian offensive has recaptured 3000 square kilometers of Ukrainian territory, most of what Russia had occupied since April. Perhaps worse than the loss of territory is how Russia has lost it: Russian soldiers hastily abandoning their positions, leaving behind equipment and materiel. Nor is the long-term situation much better - the manpower shortage is now so dire that Russia has increasingly turned to mercenary organizations such as the Wagner Group to fill its ranks, and Wagner in turn is now recruiting in Russian prisons - not exactly a recipe for a quality military. Russia has reportedly also turned to Iran for drones and North Korea for artillery to make up its equipment losses.

Russia’s collapse in Ukraine creates diplomatic problems for both leaders. Both harbor deep resentments against the West, both see the liberal international system upheld by the US as a spent force, and both want to create a more multilateral order that benefits their more authoritarian brands of leadership. But they differ on their approach to reach that objective. Xi has asserted that China’s rise is inevitable, while Putin believes that he must aggressively create the conditions for Russia to find its place in the sun - hence the war against Ukraine.

Putin came away from the Summit with no endorsements for his war. Indeed, the Summit highlighted how much the war has isolated Russia politically, economically and financially: draining money, men and materiel from the Russian military, strengthening NATO’s membership, resolve and military capacity while at the same time ensuring that Ukraine will, one way or another, leave the Russian orbit. The Summit also highlighted Russia’s growing dependence on China. Already the subordinate partner in the relationship, for Russia the Chinese connection is a lifeline, filling in some of the economic void created by Western sanctions imposed after the invasion (mostly by buying Russian energy at rock bottom prices and accepting Russian currency rather than dollars). The war is also deeply complicating Russian relations with other countries - Indian Prime Minister Modi publicly castigated Putin at the SCO meeting, telling Putin that “this is not the era of war” and asserting that the solution is “democracy, dialogue and diplomacy.” The four Central Asian members of the SCO also distanced themselves from Russia - probably worried that what happened to Ukraine could happen to them.

For President Xi, the war creates multiple problems as well. Having cast his lot in with Russia, the war now increasingly underlines Russia’s weakness as a partner. The situation is becoming embarrassing: Xi cannot allow Russia to fail, but it also does not want Russian actions to create even more tensions with the US and the West. China has thus far mostly complied with Western sanctions, and, especially before the upcoming Party Congress, Xi does not want to find itself the target of Western sanctions, which could further exacerbate China’s economic difficulties at a sensitive time.

During the First World War, German planners claimed that they were “shackled to a corpse,” having to support a failing Austria - Hungary at the same time they themselves were hard pressed. China’s planners - Xi in particular - might be feeling that same way themselves about now.

Sources

Links go to the original publishers. Some require a subscription.

  1. Putin - Xi Talks: Russian leader reveals China’s “concern” over Ukraine (Tessa Wong and Simon Fraser/BBC) Read article bbc.com
  2. Putin says Xi has questions and concerns over Ukraine (Mukhammadsharif Mamatkulov/Reuters) Read article reuters.com
  3. India’s Modi tells Putin “this is not the era for war”- (Stuart Lau and Sami Saeed) Read article politico.eu
  4. Vladimir Putin and Xi Jinping: An increasingly unequal relationship (Steve Rosenberg/BBC) Read article bbc.com
  5. Xi Jinping won’t ditch Vladimir Putin - for now (The Economist) Read article economist.com
  6. Xi Jinping's coming checkmate of Putin (Diane Francis/The Hill) - ) Read article thehill.com
  7. Beyond meeting Putin, Xi promotes China as Asia’s security leader (Tom O’Connor/Newsweek) Read article newsweek.com
  8. Putin and Xi want to create a new world order. Setbacks in Ukraine could spoil those plans (Nectar Gan/CNN) Read article cnn.com
  9. How the war in Ukraine turned Putin into Beijing's junior partner (Alexander Glabuev/Foreign Affairs) Read article foreignaffairs.com
  10. For Putin and Xi, Ukraine war creates wrinkle in ‘no limits’ friendship (Robyn Dixon/Washington Post) Read article washingtonpost.com
  11. The Wrong Way to View the Xi-Putin Meeting - (Evan Feigenbaum/Carnegie Endowment for International Peace) Read article carnegieendowment.org

All newsletters