This week, after days of prevarication, Russia's recent reverses on the battlefield have caused President Vladmir Putin to order the mobilization of 300,000 reservists. While the call up was supposed to target men with military experience (that is to say, former draftees), the regime pulled individuals out of jails, homes and workplaces in order to induct them. Some had no military service at all. Western military officials doubt the short term efficacy of the order, and also its long term viability, given the problems Russian commanders are having in logistically supporting those Russian forces already in the field. More ominously for Putin, the order immediately ran into domestic difficulties - exposing growing rifts in Russian society.
Up until now, the majority of Russians have more or less gone along with the Kremlin version that the war is a short term conflict that will resolve itself in Russia's favor, but the call for a draft has highlighted Russian failures on the battlefield and brought the war home to ordinary Russians - even more than the divestment of Western businesses from Russia had done.
Some Russians - those who have clearly doubted the rightness and the wisdom of the invasion -- have chosen to protest, despite an overwhelming police (and secret police) presence and long sentences of up to 15 years for publicly opposing the "special military operation." Despite a news blackout, these protests have clearly extended across all eleven time zones, including deep into the Russian Far East and away from the larger urban centers. Frequently protesters are beaten before being carted off to holding cells. These protesters are not just younger professionals - the elderly, long a source of support for the regime, are also joining in.
Other Russians have chosen to follow in the footsteps of those who have already emigrated. The Moscow Times, in October, 2021, reported on a study by a Moscow based thinktank, Takie Dekla, that five million Russians had already emigrated during Putin's tenure - an article written five months before the invasion of Ukraine. Estimates are that another 500,000 have left the country between the initiation of the invasion and the announcement of the draft. There is now a new rush to the exits - particularly to countries without visa requirements for Russian citizens, such as Turkey, Georgia, and Armenia. At the front of the line are those who are young, able bodied and (mostly) male. Many of those who are leaving or have left are the educated and talented - those most needed to build a modern society. Lines are long at the Finnish border, and flights are fully booked - and expensive. The Guardian reports that one option on the ticket site Aviasales is to choose the destination "wherever I can go."
Putin now realizes how serious this desire to depart is, both in the short and longer term. A new directive exempting certain workers was issued following the draft order, after Putin was bombarded with urgent requests for special status from a range of industries, including IT, airlines and software companies and industry associations - all deeply affected by sanctions and the departure of workers. But this exemption runs the risk of creating even more resentment among those left to fight - as the United States found out in the Civil War and Vietnam when it allowed exemptions for those well off enough to avoid military service - creating a "rich man's war and a poor man's fight." Such resentment could, over time, erode Putin's leadership even further.
It is too early to tell what the net result of the call up will be for Putin. He is squeezed between those who want out of the conflict and "hawks" who believe he should push even harder for a victory, no matter what the costs or the risks. But Putin, who rose through the ranks of the KGB when Russia was still the Soviet Union, should remember Russia's history - in 1917, war and the domestic discontent it engendered led to the collapse of the Romanov dynasty.