A Tale of Two Systems

Sources (20) ↓

Rishi Sunak's accession as Prime Minister of the United Kingdom caps a wild few weeks of parliamentary maneuvering. Sunak replaces Liz Truss, who resigned on October 20. Her tenure, at only 45 days, was the shortest in the history of the modern UK. While the catalyst for her fall was the promulgation of an unvetted budget long on tax cuts for the wealthy but short on the specifics of how those cuts would be offset, the broader issues contributing to the instability are far more worrisome, not just for the UK but for the West. Sunak will be the third Prime Minister in the three years since Theresa May left office in 2019. He will also appoint the fourth Chancellor of the Exchequer in that same period of time.

The instability in Great Britain, and the general instability in most Western democracies, contrasts mightily with the face put forward by China at the conclusion of the 20th Congress of the Communist Party of China (CPC), which this past weekend annointed Xi Jinping as Secretary General of the CPC for an unprecedented third term (unprecedented since Mao,anyway). Indeed, the contrasts are both implicit and explicit. Chinese leaders have sought to emphasize that political disorder in democracies is a by-product of the inevitable decline of the West, while asserting that the Chinese Communist Party has provided both stability and wisdom - and a model for future generations.

Chinese officials do have reason for self-congratulation - China has lifted more people out of poverty, and done it faster, than any regime in history. It has created a transportation network that is the envy of many Western nations (certainly when compared with the slow pace of high-speed rail in California) and an industrial sector that has become the workshop of the world, producing many of the items Americans take for granted.

Chinese media outlets have made much of this comparison between Chinese stability and Western disorder, often explicitly. The Global Times, an English language publication produced under the auspices of the official People's Daily, stated in an editorial that "[c]ontrary to Western media hype, the CPC has already demonstrated a high level of stability that is sorely missing in much of the world. The CPC has proven its legitimacy to the people through concrete actions." It also quotes a Chinese scholar (Wang Yiwei, director of the Institute of International Affairs at Renmin University) that the turmoil "shows that the Anglo-Saxon pattern can't lead the world, as those old measures such as tax cuts can't solve new problems." Similar points have been made by the South China Morning Post in Hong Kong, which commented on Beijing's efforts to projecting a steady hand in contrast with the UK's electoral disarray.

But - there are actually some less flattering comparisons between China and the short-lived Truss government in the United Kingdom. Like China, the decision to choose Truss (and Sunak) as Prime Minister was made by a tiny minority - 142,000 Conservative voters - out of a population of 67.1 million people in the country (and 47,074,000 eligible voters) - just 0.3% of the population. In China, Xi was elected to his unprecedented third term by about 2000 members of the Party Congress, but in fact most decisions - including who will be China's next leader - are made by the 204 members of the Central Committee, who in turn are directed by the Politburo Standing Committee of only seven members. And that committee just got even more homogeneous at the Party Congress: all members are close allies of Xi - and all are men cast from the same mold as Xi.

One of the elements which makes democracy so messy is that it puts disagreements and dysfunctionality on display. But it also provides a range of voices and options which should serve as a self-corrective check against extremes - at least in theory. Xi's decision to concentrate almost unlimited power in his own hands undoes the Party's principle of consensus leadership. This principle has been a guiding assumption for Chinese leaders since the days of Deng Xiaoping, who remade Chinese politics after Mao's death in 1976. Deng believed that the over-centralization of power in Mao's hands had led to many mistakes - some of them disastrous, including the Great Leap Forward (1958-62) and Great Cultural Revolution (1966-1976). By giving himself a third term, Xi has reshaped Chinese politics, and in the process removed the guardrails that Deng put into place. He now has a freedom to act that no Chinese leader has had since Mao. But he - and his leadership team - now own the entire system, and any mistakes he makes are now his. Such monochromatic leadership could prove dangerous as China seeks to navigate an exceedingly unpredictable world.

Sources

Links go to the original publishers. Some require a subscription.

  1. Liz Truss' downfall sparks talk of decline of democracy in the UK (Tobias Burns/The Hill, carried by MSN) Read article msn.com
  2. UK Electoral Statistics (Office for National Statistics, Government of the United Kingdom) Read article ons.gov.uk
  3. Liz Truss resignation: World media and politicians react to Truss departure (Elsa Maichman and James FitzGerald/BBC) Read article bbc.com
  4. The world reacts to UK PM Liz Truss’ resignation (Al Jazeera) Read article aljazeera.com
  5. The days before Britain’s Prime Minister resigned were wild. The next few days could be worse (Imogene West-Knights/Slate ) Read article slate.com
  6. Rishi Sunak: The most urgent problems facing the new Prime Minister (BBC Editors) Read article bbc.com
  7. Shortest-serving Truss resigns after failed tax-cut plan, showing old Western democracy ‘cannot solve new problems' (Chen Qingqing, Xu Yelu/Global Times) Read article globaltimes.cn
  8. UK's political chaos an embodiment of the country's confusion in the post-Brexit era (Global Times Editorial) Read article globaltimes.cn
  9. How does Truss political turmoil play into China narrative of a West in decline? (Stella Chen/South China Morning Post) Read article scmp.com
  10. For his third term, Xi Jinping surrounds himself with loyalists (Chris Buckley/NY Times) and These seven men now lead China (Chris Buckley, Keith Bradsher, Claire Fu and Joy Dong/NY Times) Read article nytimes.com
  11. China's XI claims third term and Communist Party Leader (Keith Zhai, Chun Han Wong/Wall Street Journal) Read article wsj.com
  12. China’s 20th Party Congress Report: Doubling down in the face of external threats (Bonnie Lin, Brian Hart, Samantha Lu, Matthew Funiaole/CSIS) Read article csis.org
  13. The importance of the 20th CPC national congress to the world (Danny Haiphong/Friends of Socialist China) Read article socialistchina.org
  14. No turning back for Xi Jinping (The Economist) Read article economist.com
  15. Xi Jinping has fallen into the dictator trap (Susan Shirk/NY Times) Read article nytimes.com
  16. What happens when Chinese leaders cling to power? It isn't pretty (Minxin Pei/Bloomberg) Read article bloomberg.com
  17. From "Uncle Xi" to exalted ruler (NYTimes) Read article nytimes.com
  18. A sense of crisis has defined Xi's rule: it will define China's future (thanks to Antonio Yung) - (Nectar Gan and Selina Wang,) Read article cnn.com
  19. The world according to Xi: Security, socialism and soldiers (Nikkei Asia) Read article asia.nikkei.com
  20. On the eve of China's party congress, what's ahead for China's economy (ChinaFile conversation with a range of perspectives) Read article chinafile.com

All newsletters