On September 16, two economists at the Hoover Institution on the Stanford campus, Lee Ohanion and Joseph Vranich, published the working paper "Why company headquarters are leaving California in unprecedented numbers." The study became the centerpiece of a Wall Street Journal editorial entitled "California's corporate exodus."
Yet on October 24 Governor Gavin Newsom announced that California was poised to become the fourth largest economy in the world, citing a Bloomberg analysis from the same day. This would move the state's economy past that of Germany, and mean that California's economy will soon rank behind only the US as a whole, China and Japan.
Can both of these headlines be true? Yes, apparently. The ranking is a result of both California's economic resiliency and Germany and the euro-zone's continued economic travails - perhaps as much as 15% depreciation in the euro over the past year. As a whole, the American economy has remained strong despite high inflation, and California is an enormous piece of the larger US economy. But it is not just the eurozone's and Germany's problems that matter. As the Bloomberg author, Matthew Winkler, notes "The market capitalization of California companies in this business [cycle] increased 731% the past three years, or 1.74 times more than their German counterparts....The truth is that California outperforms the US and the rest of [the] world across many industries."
California has benefited greatly from two complementary advantages: the state economy is resilient, but has also remained in the forefront of emerging technologies, particularly in the field of renewable energy. The resiliency comes from the wide range of goods and services - according to the annual UCLA-Anderson School of Management forecast, also just released, "leisure and hospitality, health care and social services, technology, and construction, each of which posted solid gains in 2021. Increases in defense spending and demand for technology will likely keep the state’s economy growing." Agriculture is also a hugely important part of the state's economic competitiveness.
But - the Hoover study does demonstrate that the state has indeed lost a large number of corporate headquarters in the past three years (Tesla, CBRE, Oracle, McKesson, etc), and for a variety of reasons, all of them well-known. Housing costs are prohibitive, taxes are high, regulations are restrictive (some for good reasons, others less so), labor is expensive, litigation costs are high and transportation is difficult. Income inequality is the highest in California of all 50 states, largely due to housing and transportation issues (workers must frequently live far away from their jobs, which disproportionately affects blue collar workers). And of course, remote work has made it much easier for white collar workers to live anywhere in the US, and most of the US is less expensive than California. But worthy of note, according to the Bloomberg report California's unemployment rate is now below that of Texas.
Importantly though, where the Golden State's economy has grown the fastest recently is in what it does best - new technologies. The push for renewables was growing stronger even before the Russian invasion of Ukraine, and that surge has only increased - it is now the fastest growing sector of the state economy. Much of this is due to California's ability to attract talent, which in part hinges on the state's welcoming attitude to those with diverse backgrounds. Those individuals are disproportionately represented in startups relating to technology and innovation, one of the primary factors in the state's continuing success in these areas.
The President of United Airlines once stated (in 2006) that "California is a perplexing place. We cannot afford to do business there, but we also cannot afford NOT to be there either." It would seem that this assessment is still valid.