Midterm elections - America's allies relieved that the electoral guardrails hold, for now

Sources (16) ↓

News that the Republican Party fared poorly in the midterm elections - at least when compared against earlier expectations - seems to have alleviated, for the time being, two dual concerns of US allies. The first and most immediate was the worry that the United States might substantially reduce its leading role in supporting Ukraine's ongoing struggle against Russia's invasion. The second worry - not yet entirely alleviated - is about the long-term health of American democracy.

The first of these concerns - that success in the midterms would empower conservative lawmakers to scale back their support for Ukraine's efforts -- seem to have been driven to the back burner by the election results. These concerns were fed by pre-election comments by House Minority Leader Kevin McCarthy that Republican control of Congress would mean "no more blank checks" for Ukraine. Though primarily designed for a domestic audience, McCarthy was only one of a number of conservative legislators and commentators voicing opposition to continuing aid to Ukraine - the list includes many familiar names, most of whom are aligned with former President Donald Trump: Senator Rand Paul, Senate candidate JD Vance, Representatives Marjorie Taylor Green, Jim Jordan, Lauren Boebert and Matt Gaetz, as well as Fox News' Tucker Carlson. Worth noting, however, Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell has been strongly, if quietly, in favor of continuing support for Ukraine. For their part, the Russians seemed a bit confused by the results, with a number of Russian journalists who had claimed credit in advance for a Republican "red wave" scrambling to explain why that did not happen, and the Kremlin itself stating that it had not expected the elections to change US-Russian relations, "which will remain bad."

But the second concern, that of the long term health of the American democratic experiment, is still very much on the minds of US allies - and adversaries. While in the US, both conservatives and liberals agree one of the big losers of the evening was former President Donald Trump, Europeans and other US allies worry that Trump - or Trumpism without Trump - could still make a comeback and undermine America's role in the international system. Writing in Le Monde, Alexandra de Hoop Scheffer asserted that Donald Trump is "not the parenthesis described in European capitals," but "embodies structural changes within American democracy and the questions that drive it about its place in the world." Other commentators have picked up on concerns of "creeping authoritarianism," likening US democracy to the end days of Republican Rome or Weimar Germany. Much of this is based on the internal discussions within America - many influential US writers have warned of the dangers to democracy posed by by the rise of election-deniers.

In view of the election results, those statements now seem a bit overblown. As Leslie Vinjamuri of Chatham House in London stated, "[o]nce again US democracy has surprised and the wisdom of US voters has confounded the pundits and the pollsters. After six grim and hyperbolic years, Americans appear to have voted for stability and calm." Others have noted that perhaps US voters are more attached to democracy than they had believed.

For its part, the Biden Administration has noted that it does not plan to change its approach in Europe or Asia. But as a number of commentators have observed, the President can now be a bit more assertive in his approach to both Russia and China. Biden will meet with Chinese President Xi in Bali on November 14, and likely discuss the war in Ukraine, Taiwan and China's economic practices. He will likely do so with a bit more confidence than he might have had before the midterm elections.

Sources

Links go to the original publishers. Some require a subscription.

  1. Weaker-than-expected GOP results calm Europes]'s nerves - for now - (Emily Rauhala, Rick Noack and Karla Adam/Washington Post) Read article washingtonpost.com
  2. Tough lines on Ukraine and China: Seeing policy fallout from midterm elections (Steven Erlanger and Alexandria Stephens/NYTimes) Read article nytimes.com
  3. Foreign Ministry Spokesperson Zhao Lijian's Regular Press Conference on November 9, 2022 (Chinese Ministry of Foreign Affairs) Read article web.archive.org
  4. What the US elections mean for the US role in the Ukraine war (Ellen Mitchell/The Hill) Read article thehill.com
  5. America's vote shows a desire for stability and calm (Leslie Vinjamuri/Chatham House) Read article chathamhouse.org
  6. Europe's US anxiety (Ivo Dalder/Politico) Read article politico.eu
  7. Mid-term elections won't improve US - Russian relations, Kremlin says (Ann M. Simmons/Wall Street Journal) Read article wsj.com
  8. In Russia, some hope US midterms will mean less Ukraine aid and more chaos (Andrew Osborne/Reuters) Read article wsj.com
  9. Biden expected to bring up Chinese economic practices, Taiwan and Russia's war in Ukraine in first meeting with Xi as president (Amanda Macias/CNBC) Read article cnbc.com
  10. Even without a red wave, this could now be Weimar America (Andreas Kluth/Business Standard) Read article business-standard.com
  11. In wake of election, Ukrainian lawmakers planning trip to Washington (Andrew E. Kramer/NY Times) Read article nytimes.com
  12. Donald Trump is not the parenthesis described in many European capitals (Alexandra de Hoop Scheffer/Le Monde (in French)) Read article lemonde.fr
  13. After the midterms, American democracy looks stronger (The Economist) Read article economist.com
  14. Full list of Republicans who have always voted against Ukraine aid (Katherine Fung/Newsweek) Read article newsweek.com
  15. The end of the road for American exceptionalism (Ishan Tharoor/Washington Post) Read article washingtonpost.com
  16. Facing up to the democratic recession (Larry Diamond/Journal of Democracy) Read article journalofdemocracy.org

All newsletters