"Jaw Jaw is always better than war war"

Sources (11) ↓

President Biden held his much anticipated meeting with Chinese President Xi at the G20 in Bali on November 20. The meeting was described by the White House as "candid" and by the Chinese foreign ministry as "in-depth, candid and constructive." Biden himself simply called the exchange "blunt." Prior to the discussion, both sides had dampened expectations for any sort of breakthrough. Perhaps because of that, many observers asserted that the three hour meeting - over the allotted time -- was actually something of a success.

It is unusual that the leaders of the two largest economies would wait almost two years to meet face to face, though Biden and Xi have met many times before and have held a number of meetings over phone and video-conference since Biden's inauguration. But the wait might have been worthwhile - both Xi and Biden approached the meeting in stronger positions than they were only a few weeks before. Xi has just been elected to his third term as Chinese leader at the conclusion of the 20th party congress, and Biden and the Democratic Party made a much stronger than expected showing in the US midterms.

Both sides arrived with laundry lists of positions, and each had areas they defined as "redlines" (the term was used by both Chinese and American discussants). For China, the primary red line was, not surprisingly, Taiwan. Xi - no doubt still angered by the visit of House Speaker Nancy Pelosi to the island in July -- noted that Taiwan is a part of China, and therefore an internal matter and not subject to American interference. Biden, for his part, stated that American support for the "One China Policy" has not changed, but challenged China on its "coercive and increasingly aggressive actions toward Taiwan, which undermine peace and stability across the Taiwan Strait and in the broader region, and jeopardize global prosperity." Importantly, though, Biden came away believing that a Chinese invasion is not imminent.

Biden's wish list also included Chinese support to dissuade Russia from nuclear weapons use in Ukraine (he got that, with both the US and China agreeing that "nuclear war should never be fought and can never be won," though China has said this in the past) and Chinese support for encouraging North Korea to act "more responsibly" - though North Korea added its own exclamation point on that with a rocket test immediately after the summit. The Chinese also agreed to again work again the US on climate change - after breaking off cooperation after the Pelosi visit. They also left the door open in other areas where global cooperation is essential - food security, debt relief, health issues and economic stability.

Biden and Xi clearly disagree on trade policy and the promotion of human rights - and were clear about their differences. But where a number of observers saw this as a sign of likely increasing tension, others believe that both Biden and Xi were looking for ways to turn down the temperature on what has become an increasingly acrimonious relationship. As noted above, both leaders are stronger domestically than before, and therefore can be more candid about their positions. The bluntness, as Biden put it, is in international affairs quite often an advantage - huge mistakes can emerge from a lack of clarity about goals and "red lines." As Foreign Minister Wang Yi stated, the primary focus of the meeting "was to prevent China-U.S. relations from getting derailed or out of control, and to find the right way for the two major countries to get along with each other." That will be an ongoing struggle for both China and the US, but both sides clearly do not want a new Cold War, and both agreed to find areas for the potential creation of working groups to resolve differences - though conspicuously, the US and China do not have a working military to military dialogue. More concretely, Secretary of State Antony Blinken will visit China sometime in the future.

None of these agreements resolves the enormous obstacles to US - China cooperation, but they are small but significant steps towards a more cooperative relationship. And as Winston Churchill famously said, "To jaw jaw is always better than to war war."

Sources

Links go to the original publishers. Some require a subscription.

  1. Readout of President Joe Biden's meeting with President Xi Jinping of the The People's Republic of China (The White House, November 14, 2022) Read article whitehouse.gov
  2. President Xi Jinping meets with President Joe Biden in Bali (Chinese Ministry of Foreign Affairs) Read article fmprc.gov.cn
  3. [Foreign Minister] Wang Yi briefs the media on the meeting between US and Chinese presidents and answers questions (Chinese Ministry of Foreign Affairs) Read article fmprc.gov.cn
  4. Biden-XI meeting delivers calmer tone, reminds of fault lines (Paul Eckert/Radio Free Asia) Read article rfa.org
  5. Four key take-aways from President Biden's "very blunt" meeting with China's Xi Jinping (Emily Feng and Vincent Ni/NPR) Read article npr.org
  6. Biden and Xi clash over Taiwan, but Cold War fears cool Nandita Bose and Stanley Windianto/Reuters) Read article reuters.com
  7. The Biden - XI meeting shows that US - China relations will get worse, not better (Josh Rogin/Washington Post) Read article washingtonpost.com
  8. Xi and Biden cool the heat, but the two countries are still on a collision course (Stephen Collinson/CNN) Read article cnn.com
  9. Biden and Xi meet in Bali (Ian Bremmer/G-Zero) Read article gzeromedia.com
  10. For Biden and Xi, a long relationship with mutual rising suspicion (Jude Blanchett/NYTimes) Read article nytimes.com
  11. The world according to Xi Jinping (Kevin Rudd/Foreign Affairs) Read article foreignaffairs.com

All newsletters