Europe grapples with the spectre of deindustrialization

Sources (14) ↓

With cold weather setting in across Europe, businesses and homes are hunkering down for what could be a miserable winter. Cold weather is nothing new for Europe, but cold weather coupled with an energy crisis is something that the continent has not faced since the 1970s. The cause is clear, and the effects could be dire.

As is well known, Europe has become heavily dependent on Russian liquified natural gas (LNG) over the past decades. Hard as it is to fathom now, much of this was by design - a belief that with more of a stake in the Western economy, Russia would, over time, become a more responsible global partner (it was also convenient and relatively inexpensive). While the dependence on cheap Russian LNG was a disastrous miscalculation, worse was the lack of a Plan B if the taps were turned off. And they have been largely turned off - the Russian war in Ukraine has severely restricted European access to Russian natural gas, and the sabotage of the Nordstream 1 and 2 pipelines on September 26 further reduced imports from Russia (the identity of the saboteurs remains unknown, but the most obvious candidate is clearly Russia itself).

The impact of high energy costs are already proving to be severe. Energy rationing is under consideration across the continent, and The Economist magazine's modeling indicates that 100,000 more Europeans could die from the cold than would normally perish this year - mostly the elderly and infirm. Inflation is at about 10%, though recent signs are that this rate is starting to slow. Over the long term, the most profound impact could be on Europe's industry - chemicals, fertilizers, the battery industry, steel, glass -- all have been deeply affected. Many manufacturing facilities have dramatically scaled back, and some - most notably in Germany and France - have shuttered their operations (for example, Germany's Accelor Mittal recently closed two steel mills). The great fear is that once these plants close they may never reopen, leading to the specter of deindustrialization across the EU.

Deindustrialization could have serious consequences in Europe and beyond. There will be an increased strain on social services across Europe, social anxiety will rise, and - as demonstrated by a recent University of Cambridge study - ethno-nationalism flourishes alongside deindustrialization, a potential danger for democracy and national unity across the continent.

Germany's economic downturn is the reason that California's economy is now moving from the world's fifth to fourth largest economy. And indeed, a combination of America's lower cost energy supplies and the US's own economic policies are contributing to worsening Europe's woes - a point made by President Macron on his state visit to Washington. Macron's assertion - that the Inflation Reduction Act's subsidies to encourage clean energy and sustainable industries are encouraging European industries to decamp to the United States - does appear to be the case, particularly in the energy and startup sectors. As Macron has no doubt pointed out, it is not in the US' long-term interest to undermine the economies of America's most important global allies, especially in a time of such global turmoil. As The Economist notes, the Ukraine war caused the US and Europe to unite after the Trump years, but there is danger that economic tensions will pull the two sides apart - "Mr Putin and China’s president, Xi Jinping, would love that." To prevent this, The Economist suggests making European firms eligible for American energy subsidies and integrating trans-Atlantic energy markets more deeply. There is one more possible bit of good news. According to Christopher Knittel, the head of MIT's Center for Energy and Environmental Policy, high energy prices in the United States in the 1970s caused by the Arab oil embargo forced the United States to adopt some much needed fixes to its energy sector, making it much more efficient in the long run. Those lessons, Knittel asserts, should have resonance in Europe today as it grapples to find a response to the deadly combination of war, cold weather, and restricted energy supplies.

Sources

Links go to the original publishers. Some require a subscription.

  1. Europe faces an enduring crisis of energy and geopolitics (The Economist) Read article economist.com
  2. Europe is heading for "deep recession, deindustrialization," (Kenneth Rapoza/Forbes) Read article forbes.com
  3. Europe's descent into de-industrialization (Philip Pilkington/The Spectator) Read article spectator.co.uk
  4. Europe fears its industries will jet to the US as high energy costs force plant closures - (Eleanor Beardsley/National Public Radio) Read article npr.org
  5. Europe may see forced deindustrialization as a result of energy crisis - (Irina Slav/Centre for Global Research - initially published in Oilprice) Read article globalresearch.ca
  6. The European Union spent $13 billion on energy in 2022: five times more than the year before (Brian Evans/MSN-Business Insider) Read article msn.com
  7. Europe's energy crisis brings call for 5 minute showers: Not all are keen on that (Wall Street Journal) Read article wsj.com
  8. Eurozone October PMI adds to evidence that Europe is heading into recession (Jonathan Cable/Reuters) Read article reuters.com
  9. Energy crisis chips away at Europe's industrial might (Clare Denina and Sarah McFarlane/Reuters) Read article reuters.com
  10. Europe could face energy rationing as "really tough winter" looms, Shell boss warns (Ben van Beurden/The Guardian) Read article theguardian.com
  11. Deindustrialization fosters ethno-nationalism: a comparative analysis of ethnonational parties in Europe 1918-2018 (Oliver Stribjis/Cambridge University Press (online mongraph) Read article cambridge.org
  12. In Washington, Macron goes on the offensive for Europe (Claire Gatinois and Philippe Ricard/Le Monde) Read article lemonde.fr
  13. VW exec says that high energy prices will kill battery production in Europe (Joshua Posaner/Politico) Read article politico.eu
  14. What Europe can learn from 1970s oil crisis: Don't fear high prices (Tim McDonnell/MIT Energy Lab) Read article qz.com

All newsletters