Turns out 2022 wasn't such a bad year for democracy after all....

Sources (19) ↓

Hard as it is to recall now, authoritarianism seemed primed to become the dominant political system on the world stage this time last year. Defined by Encyclopedia Britannica as "any political system that concentrates power in the hands of a leader or a small elite that is not constitutionally responsible to the body of the people," leaders such as Vladimir Putin in Russia, Xi Jinping in China, Jair Bolsanaro in Brazil, Viktor Orban in Hungary, Reycip Erdogan in Turkey, and Ali Khameni in Iran all seemed ready to remain in power for the foreseeable future. In the US, Donald Trump, though voted out of office in 2020, also seemed primed for a political comeback with Republicans in the House and Senate anticipating large gains in the 2022 midterms. The "Friendship with No Limits" agreement between Presidents Xi and Putin on February 4, 2022, seemed to solidify the rise of authoritarianism as a dominant force in international relations, a direct challenge posed by China and Russia to the United States and its allies in Europe and Asia.

But suddenly, things went south for countries led by leaders with authoritarian tendencies. The poster child for things gone wrong in a hurry is clearly Putin, whose invasion of Ukraine has swerved catastrophically off course by any objective measure - not even including the morality of initiating such a conflict. Far from making Russia a great power, Putin has driven Russia into a downward spiral, giving the West a sense of purpose it had been lacking, setting the stage for NATO expansion, wrecking the Russian economy, and mortgaging the country's intellectual future as millions of Russia's most productive workers head for the exits either in protest or to escape the draft. In China, President Xi, fresh from his preordained election to an unprecedented third term as Communist Party General Secretary, was forced to end the "zero-tolerance" Covid policy following increasing unrest among the population. Once admired for the low number of Covid-related deaths, the government now seems to have squandered its time: the shutdowns have sapped much of China's productive energy, vaccination rates amongst the senior population are very low, and Chinese vaccines are not nearly as effective as their American and European counterparts. The result will likely be a Covid wave and many deaths. Iran now finds itself in turmoil following the death of a young woman, Mahsa Amini, in Morality Police custody. With school girls and youths in the lead, the regime's hold now seems shakier by the day, and the government is increasingly turning to judicial and extrajudicial executions to control the unrest. And in the American congressional and Brazilian presidential contests, voters (mostly) turned back extremist candidates in favor of those appealing to the democratic center.

As many observers have pointed out, in times of economic, cultural and political unrest, authoritarians seem to offer a safe haven to those craving stability. And indeed, in the short term, authoritarians do have advantages - they can get things done in relatively short order that seem to take democracies an inordinately long time (Exhibit A - High Speed Rail in California, which is the only such project even underway in the United States). Authoritarians can also make solutions to difficult problems seem easy, and can remove the stress of decision-making by taking responsibility for the important decisions regarding national focus and direction. It would, for example, be hard to refute that China's remarkable transformation from poverty-stricken nation to the world's second largest economy could have happened so rapidly without the Communist Party of China's ability to cut through the messy process of building a national consensus. Finally, authoritarian systems can look extremely stable when compared with liberal democracies - an image which most authoritarian leaders take pains to promote.

But in the longer term, democracies possess strengths that autocracies lack - even if those strengths are not always immediately apparent. They can shift gears far more rapidly as their nations go off course - as the United States did in 2020 and in the most recent midterm elections and Brazil and Great Britain have just done. Democracies also promote the rule of law, which is an important element in building a productive and innovative economy. Democracies also allow for dissent, which is an important part of self-correction, an important feature in finding solutions to longer-term problems. Perhaps most importantly, democracies are not prone to disastrous decision-making of the sort exemplified by the Russian invasion of Ukraine. No one doubts that liberal democracy is messy - Mark Twain's remark that "people who love sausage and respect the law should not see either being made" clearly had the US Congress in mind.

The world has seen waves of authoritarian attraction before - in the 1920's and 30's in Europe, and the 60's when US foreign policy seemed to have lost its way and supported many illiberal regimes. There have also been moments when democracies seemed ascendent - Chatham House in London identifies three democratic "waves:'' the first, from the late 18th century to 1918 (American, French and Haitian revolutions), a second from 1945-60 (Germany, Japan and Italy) and most recently 1975 to 1991, with the collapse of the Soviet Union and various military dictatorships from Portugal to South Korea. The latter wave prompted the American political scientist Francis Fukuyama to assert (with more hope than vision) that the world had reached "the end of history" and liberal democracy and free market economics would dominate the 21st century. Fukuyama was wrong, and the reality is that both versions of democracy and authoritarianism will likely be around in some form or another for the foreseeable future.

Democracy is not entirely out of the woods - both Freedom House and the Global Democracy Initiative see democratic norms slipping across the globe, including in the United States. Far right parties have been elected in Sweden and Italy and are strong in France and Germany. But for the moment, the tide of authoritarianism seems to have been reversed. If nothing else, 2022 has renewed the belief that democracy can meet the challenges posed by authoritarian states, even those with access to top-tier technology and a monopoly on the media. Perhaps Winston Churchill was right when he stated that "democracy is the worst form of Government except for all those other forms that have been tried from time to time.…"

Sources

Links go to the original publishers. Some require a subscription.

  1. The future belongs to authoritarian states (Jonathan Adelman/Huffington Post) Read article huffpost.com
  2. What you can expect from an authoritarian (Eric Maisal/Psychology Today) Read article psychologytoday.com
  3. Freedom House interactive map (Freedom House) Read article freedomhouse.org
  4. The Global State of Democracy 2022 (Global State of Democracy Initiative) Read article idea.int
  5. Democracy in retreat as authoritarianism goes global (Washington Post editorial) Read article washingtonpost.com
  6. China, Russia partner up against the West at the Winter Olympics (Tony Munroe, Andrew Osborne, and Humeyra Pamuk/Reuters) Read article reuters.com
  7. Putin's landslide election makes it look like Russia is stable: Don't be fooled (Zach Beauchamp/Vox) Read article vox.com
  8. Xi, Putin and Trump: the strongman follies (Thomas Friedman/NYTimes) Read article nytimes.com
  9. The importance of democracy (Jon Wallace, Hans Kundnani, and Elizabeth Donnelly/Chatham House) Read article chathamhouse.org
  10. Authoritarianism vs. democracy (Marianne Williamson/Newsweek) Read article newsweek.com
  11. "Neglected" democracy vulnerable to authoritarian rule in an era of disinformation (Katherine Murphy/The Guardian) Read article theguardian.com
  12. Understanding the Global Rise of Authoritarianism (Ben Rhodes and Michael McFaul/Stanford Freeman Spogli Institute) Read article fsi.stanford.edu
  13. It was a bad year for authoritarianism (Jonah Goldberg/LATimes) Read article latimes.com
  14. Xi and Putin wanted to create a new world order: Russia's setback in Ukraine could spoil their plans (Nectar Gan/CNN, reprinted in Yahoo! News) Read article currently.att.yahoo.com
  15. 2022: The year the good guys struck back (Michael Hirsch/Foreign Policy) Read article foreignpolicy.com
  16. American authoritarianism isn't going away Read article thenation.com
  17. Lessons from 2022 for Elitists and Authoritarians (Gerard Baker/Wall Street Journal) Read article wsj.com
  18. The authoritarian right is regrouping (Tom Nichols/The Atlantic) Read article theatlantic.com
  19. In rural Georgia, an unlikely rebel against Trumpism (Stephanie McCrummen/Washington Post) Read article washingtonpost.com

All newsletters