The world according to (some) Republicans

Sources (11) ↓

After a week of chaotic dealmaking, Kevin McCarthy finally achieved his long coveted goal of becoming the 55th Speaker of the House of Representatives. But as numerous news outlets have pointed out, he takes over a dramatically diminished speakership from his predecessor, fellow-Californian Nancy Pelosi. To achieve his goal, McCarthy essentially negotiated away nearly all of his power to the House Freedom Caucus. This allows the Freedom Caucus to have major input into determining the Republican House agenda, ceding chairs on important committees, including the all-important Rules Committee, which determines what comes to the floor of the House for a vote. In addition to securing the promise of seats on sensitive committees, McCarthy also agreed to allowing any single member to call for a vote of no-confidence in the Speaker (a motion to “Vacate the Chair”).

Short term, the narrowness of the Republican victory in the midterm elections gave McCarthy virtually no cushion of votes to spare, and forced him to negotiate for the Speakership with hardline conservatives. Thus, despite the lack of a “red wave” and the defeat of most deniers of the validity of the 2020 elections, the most conservative faction of the Republican Party – about 11% - ended with greatly disproportionate power. The consequences could prove enormous for the United States over the next two years: The House could paralyze much of the Federal Government’s operations with inquests and budgetary maneuvers, defund important Biden Administration priorities such as aid to Ukraine and, perhaps even more dangerously, refuse to raise the debt ceiling, which in turn could trigger a default by the US Government and potentially crash the global economy.

But there are longer term trends at play here as well. The Republican Party has had both small government and isolationist wings since before World War I, when it opposed intervention on the side of the Allies. This opposition was overcome only with the Germany government’s declaration of unconditional submarine warfare in February 1917, which outraged the American public. After the war, many Republicans again reverted to isolationism, which helped defeat President Wilson’s plans for US participation in the League of Nations. Presidents Harding, Coolidge and Hoover—all Republicans -- looked inward. In Congress, Senators Gerald Nye (R-ND and Robert Taft (R-Ohio), led Congress in the passage of a series of Neutrality Acts in the 1930s, designed to prevent US intervention in foreign conflicts in part because of his assertion that big corporations and arms makers had been the only real winners coming out of the war. Only the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor made America’s declaration of war inevitable (but only on Japan; Germany actually declared war on the United States first).

Following the monumental blow to the international system from the war, both Republican and Democratic parties shared a commitment to an internationalist foreign policy and championed international institutions such as the UN, NATO and the various financial institutions such as the World Bank and IMF – all designed to create prosperity and prevent the reemergence of the grievances that had led to the two World Wars. The US was the prime mover in the creation of these institutions, with help from Great Britain. But the isolationist strain in America remained, personified by Senator Taft (“Mr. Republican),” who remained a vocal critic of big government as well as the internationalist foreign policy championed by President Truman and later President Eisenhower (who narrowly defeated Taft to take the nomination in 1952). Though a Republican, as the former Supreme Allied Commander in Europe, Eisenhower was a firm believer in the importance of alliances and international institutions as a guarantee of peace, despite the costs of American support. Eisenhower’s belief in internationalism persisted through all Republican presidents from Nixon to Ford to Reagan and Presidents HW and George Bush. Best stated by the Royal United Services Institute, Republican foreign policy at this time “was best characterised as taking a ‘realist’ approach to international affairs. This meant support for a strong military, for working closely with allies, partners and friends around the world, for free trade, and for defending human rights and promoting democracy.”

But President Trump exemplified a much darker approach, seeing America’s relations with the rest of the world as transactional, largely in keeping with his personal ethics. He asserted that our allies had taken advantage of the United States, and that international institutions were handouts to freeloaders. His approach to international affairs found a ready audience with primarily White working class voters, particularly those who blamed trade agreements for taking their middle class jobs, saw America as diminished by its foreign entanglements, overrun by migrants who would change the (White) culture, and feared big government “socialism.” And indeed, the failed (Bush) interventions in Afghanistan and Iraq did undermine much of the internal US consensus on the value of American engagement abroad.

While Trump’s influence may be diminishing, the anger and resentment he stoked has now become mainstream in the GOP. Within the Republican Party, the connection between an America fully engaged in the international system and the well-being of Americans has been lost. Internal US political dysfunctionality could translate into destabilization of the international order, with dire consequences for the United States. Transnational problems – coping with climate change, responding to pandemics, international trade agreements – all could be undermined by the lack of American leadership. While the United States will never again have the global dominance it enjoyed throughout the second half of the 20th Century, it still overwhelmingly benefits from the global order it created from the ashes of World War II, indeed perhaps now more than ever. But that assumes that the nation continues to play the indispensable role it has undertaken since 1945.

Sources

Links go to the original publishers. Some require a subscription.

  1. Trump lit the fire that’s burning down Kevin McCarthy’s House (Joshua Green/Bloomberg) Read article bloomberg.com
  2. The Party of One becomes the Party of None (Bill Scher/Politico) Read article politico.com
  3. Speaker debacle puts US security at Risk (Connor O’Brien/Politico) Read article news.yahoo.com
  4. How America defies expectations: In many ways the country has had an exceptional year (The Economist) Read article economist.com
  5. The Republican Devolution: Partisanship and the decline of American governance (Jacob S. Hacker and Paul Pierson/Foreign Affairs) Read article foreignaffairs.com
  6. The Republican party and US foreign policy: what’s next (Kevin Reiss/Royal United Services Institute) Read article rusi.org
  7. How the GOP embraced the world: and then turned away (William I. Hitchcock/Politico) Read article politico.com
  8. Republican Foreign Policy/2016 and beyond (Colin Dueck/Foreign Policy Research Institute ) Read article fpri.org
  9. Preparing for Republican debt blackmail (Paul Krugman/NYTimes) Read article nytimes.com
  10. Bonnie Kristian: De Santis could decide Republicans’ foreign policy (Bonnie Kristian/NYTimes) Read article nytimes.com
  11. What will 2023 bring for America? (Douglas Schoen/Orange County Register) Read article ocregister.com

All newsletters