Germany and the liberal democratic global order

Russia, Ukraine & European politicsInternational order & diplomacy

Sources (10) ↓

Germany’s belated decision to send some of its inventory of Leopard 2 tanks to Ukraine is rightly perceived as an important step in aiding Ukraine to defend itself against Russian aggression. The Leopard 2 is considered to be one of the world’s premier main battle tanks (MBTs), and Poland has also asked for export permission from Germany to send some of its Leopards. Other nations will likely follow suit. Along with the promised American M1 Abrams tank and British Challengers, these German tanks will likely have a major impact on the battlefield – when they arrive. And, when they do arrive, the Ukrainians will be forced to integrate them not only into their inventory but also have to work out supply chain issues: the British Challenger uses different ammunition from the American and German tanks, and the American tank uses different fuel. Each tank also has its own maintenance requirements. Ukrainian crews must also be trained to use them effectively and in teams with the other Western hardware. All this will take time – a precious commodity for Ukraine as it prepares to fend off yet another Russian offensive. But perhaps the most important immediate impact of these tanks is not their military value – though that will be critical – but also the psychological value of knowing that the West is sending some of its most sophisticated military equipment. Nowhere is that more true than in the case of Germany.

It is important to remember that the last time German tanks were seen east of Poland and Romania was when the Wehrmacht invaded the Soviet Union in June 1941 – the second time in just over 20 years that Germany had made a bid for European dominance and to overturn the liberal order championed by France and Britain (the US was not a factor in decision to go to war in 1914, and had withdrawn into isolationism when the Second World War began in 1939). After six years of savage combat and immense destruction, Germany was comprehensively defeated in 1945, its cities in ruins, population dispersed and economy devastated. German leaders and citizens were forced to come to terms with recognition of the country’s wartime past, including the Holocaust and in the east, German atrocities against Russians, Poles, Ukrainians and others. No definitive numbers have every been published, but a upwards of 26 million Soviet military personnel and civilians are believed to have been killed or died of starvation and disease as a result of the German invasion.

The war left an indelible mark on both Germans and victims of German aggression. Germany’s peaceful integration the American-based global order is one of the great success stories of the 20th century, but Germans also determined to go one step further and chart a separate path that was focused on reconciliation with Russia through enhanced economic ties and a pacifist “Ostpolitik” designed to create a special relationship with the USSR and, before the collapse of the Soviet Union, its East European satellites. Germans also felt some degree of kinship with the Russians over the collapse of the Soviet Union and subsequent loss of territory and prestige, which both they and the Russians held to be somewhat analogous with the repressive Treaty of Versailles imposed by the victorious Allies after World War I.

There is thus more than a bit of irony in Germany’s migration across the spectrum into a critical component of the broad coalition supporting Ukraine. Like its NATO allies, Germany spent the Cold War years prepared to fight the Soviet Union. Though it possessed the most powerful economy and the strongest land forces in Europe (after the US military) Germany never carried commensurate political weight, preferring to lend support rather than lead NATO and European political integration. Like its allies, German politicians believed that the fall of the Berlin Wall and the end of the division of Europe would lead to the dominance of that economic and social issues over military strength, which suited the new German perception of itself just fine. Now, though the Cold War has ended, the liberal democratic order is again under threat, and the war is being fought on some of the same battlefields that Germans and Soviets fought over 80 years before. But this time around, if seemingly reluctantly at times, Germany is now a leader in taking risks to uphold the liberal democratic order rather than to destroy it. That is a vast and welcome change.

Sources

Links go to the original publishers. Some require a subscription.

  1. What the Leopard 2 tank could mean for Ukraine's fight against Russia (AP/Canadian Broadcast Service) Read article cbc.ca
  2. What makes Germany’s Leopard 2 tank such a great fit for Ukraine? (The Economist) Read article economist.com
  3. Germany’s Russia policy in tatters (Ben Knight/Deutsche Welle) Read article dw.com
  4. US will send more modern version of Abrams tank (Ellen Mitchell/The Hill) Read article thehill.com
  5. Ukraine weapons: what tanks and other equipment are world giving? (David Brown, Jake Horton & Tural Ahmedzade/BBC) Read article bbc.com
  6. Will Putin survive his “catastrophic” war? (Peter Weber/The Week) Read article theweek.com
  7. Sending tanks will escalate tension but Putin ‘very unwise’ to attack West, ex-Army head says- (Molly Blackall/Joe Duggan/I News (UK)) - Read article inews.co.uk
  8. Germany is rearming and its defense firms stand to profit (Christopher Rauwald, William Wilkes and Tara Patel/Bloomberg) Read article bloomberg.com
  9. US and NATO on path to a full-fledged conflict in Europe (RT News (Russia)) Read article rt.com
  10. Russia fumes over NATO tanks heading to Ukraine, revealing a Kremlin coming to grips with reality (Alexander Nazarayan/Yahoo News) Read article news.yahoo.com

All newsletters