Politically, the United States and the United Kingdom - along with much of the industrialized West - have grappled with a populist backlash against the established political order that has destabilized the culture and political systems in both nations. Both the US and Britain have been beset by working class anger over declining economic standards, with much blame attached to immigration as a cause. This has translated into catalyzing moments for both nations. In the United States, the culmination of years of populist inspired instability were the events leading up to the January 6, 2021 insurrection, supercharged by then-President Donald Trump's efforts to overturn the results of the election. In Britain, the decisive issue was Brexit, the decision to leave the European Union. The past three years have told a vastly different story in both countries, despite many seeming =similarities.
Britain marked the third anniversary of Brexit on January 31, with the impact of the decision to leave becoming more apparent - almost in real time. Alone amongst the advanced economies of the world, the UK is the only major economy projected to shrink in 2023 - including heavily-sanctioned Russia. There are other reasons for the UK's economic distress, including Covid and growing income inequality, but Brexit is a key factor: Bloomberg News estimates that the British economy is losing £100 billion a year in output due to Brexit as farmers and industry are unable to find sufficient workers, small companies struggle to sell goods to the EU, and off-shore investment has moved elsewhere. As Fareed Zakaria has noted, British voters put nationalism and politics above the economy when they voted to leave. Despite statements to the contrary by British politicians asserting that Brexit has set the stage for rapid growth and returned sovereignty to the British people, there is a very large - and growing - number of Britons who regret the vote. One in five who voted for Brexit now wish they had not, and a recent YouGov poll shows that 56% of Britons view Brexit as a mistake, while 36% believe it was the right decision. Ironically, the economic downturn has hit pro-Brexit districts hardest. While Britain will not rejoin the EU anytime soon, The Economist points out that there are a number of areas where Britain can negotiate a better relationship with the EU to mitigate some of the difficulties. But whether that is politically feasible is anyone's guess
In the US, the populist surge embodied by former President Trump now looks to be fading. The narrower than expected Republican majority in the US House of Representatives is having a hard time agreeing on what cuts it would make, and has offered no policies in place of President Biden's priorities. The recent economic report of 517,000 new jobs and 3.6% unemployment now makes it even less likely that people will look for radical solutions. Most economists had anticipated a recession by now, and some still expect it, but in fact this jobs report now makes that seem even more remote . Much of the credit goes to Biden's economic policies, which have been focused on what the White House calls "bottom up and middle out" economic policies. By targeting weaknesses in the economy - infrastructure, in particular -- but also looking towards future oriented investment in low income regions of the US, Biden has consciously attempted to raise productivity in those areas where the middle class dream has faded. In so doing, the President and his advisers clearly hope to de-fang much of the anger and frustration felt by millions of Americans who believe that they have been left behind - and might be willing to destabilize the political system to register their disapproval. It is too soon to see if this approach will be successful - there is still the threat to the economy posed by Republican hardliners in the House -- but it is an interesting phenomena that some of the greatest challenges to the US economy in the past 50 years are being met by forward-looking policies promoted by the oldest President in American history.