China's balloon was much ado about nothing. But for domestic reasons, neither side can back down. The implications may be long lasting - and dangerous.
After the US Air Force shot down China's spy balloon on Feb 4, ending a week-long saga, the entire incident should have moved to the backburner. No one was harmed, and as numerous intelligence analysts have pointed out, China's hacking, satellites and human intelligence are likely far more effective at monitoring the US than a slow moving, highly-visible balloon weighing as much as three school buses. But internally in both China and the United States, politics have already gotten in the way of working through the issue productively, despite recent efforts by both countries to ratchet back the tension.
In the US, the balloon's slow pace across the continent gave domestic critics of the Biden administration time to focus on the apparent slow response - though President Biden was advised by the military that shooting down the dirigible over land could create potential hazards to both people and property. President Biden immediately asked Secretary of State Antony Blinken to postpone a planned visit to China, and the US House of Representatives passed a resolution 419-0 condemning China for the episode. Some House Republicans also accused the Biden Administration of a coverup, though no evidence of that exists. For the Biden team, the need for the administration to avoid looking weak domestically and on the global stage could set back any effort to restart talks with Chinese leaders anytime soon.
For China, the balloon has proved a major embarrassment, made worse by the postponement of the Secretary of State's visit.The Chinese government and media have tried to downplay the significance of the balloon, sticking to the story that the aircraft was merely a meteorological device gone off course, despite evidence to the contrary. A Foreign Ministry spokesperson accused the US of "overreacting," and waging "information warfare." It is indeed hard to understand why the incident occurred just before the Blinken visit. Theories run the gamut from poorly-timed routine surveillance to an internal effort to embarrass President Xi. But as in the United States, a desire not to appear weak could make it difficult for Xi to put this incident behind him anytime soon.
US - Chinese relations have been in a downward spiral since the second half of the Trump Administration, and there are significant risks from the two sides not talking. China's military capability has grown significantly in the past decade, in both conventional and nuclear terms. One of the unfortunate ironies of the timing of this latest dustup is that Secretary Blinken's visit was designed to establish a set of "guardrails" for both sides to prevent escalation of such incidents. Given the potential for friction over issues such as Taiwan and the South China Sea - not to mention something unanticipated, such as the collision between a Chinese fighter and a US spy plane in 2001 -- the need for constant communication becomes critical. During the Cold War, not only was there a presidential "hotline" between the President and the Soviet Premier, the commander of NATO (always an American) and the commander of the Warsaw Treaty Organization (always a Russian) also had a direct line of communication. This time around, the commander of the Chinese Defense Minister Wei Fenghi turned down the opportunity to speak with US Secretary of Defense Lloyd Austin to discuss the incident.
The Biden Administration is already looking for a way to limit the damage to US - China relations. In an interview with Judy Woodruff on PBS' NewsHour, Biden stated that he's talked to President Xi and told him that the US "does not seek conflict." The administration has also stated that President Xi might not have known about the flight, possibly as a way of de-escalating the situation. And the Chinese government has not pushed the issue as hard as it could, and even used mocking humor rather than stoking anger domestically. But given internal politics in Beijing and Washington, both sides may have to wait before restarting the conversation, and hope that in the meantime, nothing else goes wrong.