As the Russian war on Ukraine enters its second year, Russia has a surprising degree of support from many countries who resent Western colonialism and American interventionism. But those countries seem to have forgotten that for Ukrainians, this is a colonial war too – a Russian colonial war aimed at subjugating Ukraine.
The first anniversary of the Russia’s “special military operation” in Ukraine has led to a good deal of commemoration on the part of Ukraine and its partners, including a surprise visit from President Biden to Kiev – the first time a US president has been in an active war zone since Abraham Lincoln observed a battle between Union and Confederate forces inside the District of Columbia in July of 1864.
One of the war’s great stories has been the unity of purpose shown by the West and allies in countering Russian aggression, both with sanctions and direct supplies of military hardware to Ukraine. But for the US and its allies, one of the perplexing counter-narratives has been that while the United States and its allies are fully vested in helping Ukraine defend itself, much of Africa and Asia – and parts of Latin America -- have refused to take sides, particularly in the UN votes. The most recent of these General Assembly votes, including the most recent resolution, on February 23, called for Russia to withdraw its forces from Ukraine. While 141 countries voted in favor of the resolution, and the usual Russian client states (including Belarus, Nicaragua, Syria and Mali) voted against, a surprisingly large number of nations voted to abstain. This list includes the world’s two largest countries, India and China, and also other important Asian and African nations such as Pakistan, Vietnam, Iran, Algeria and South Africa. Of those nations voting for the resolution, only about 40 have actually imposed sanctions.
The rationales vary: Along with Russia, China shares a common sense of grievance against the US led global order, encapsulated in the “friendship with no limits” agreement signed just before the invasion. India has deep ties to the Russian energy sector, and has a long history of purchasing Russian military hardware. Iran supplies drones and other military equipment to Russia, and also chafes under Western sanctions. Other factors cited for neutrality include distraction from more urgent issues such as mounting debt, concerns about food and energy security, inflation and impending recession, a desire not to get caught up in a new Cold War between the West and Russia and China, and fear of nuclear war if the conflict continues. Hard as it is for those of us in the West to believe, many in Asia and Africa believe that the United States and its allies represent the past, while China and Russia represent the future.
But there is a deeper reason for many of the abstentions: a resentment against Western colonialism and American interventionism in the Middle East and Afghanistan, which in the eyes of many in Asia and Africa amounts to about the same thing. A point made by commentators across Africa is that while the US has consistently intervened in the Middle East and Asia, the USSR never imposed colonialism on Africa and was a consistent ally in the struggles against colonial and apartheid regimes – a point which Putin has consistently emphasized in his messaging to African nations. Others note that while Europeans have opened their doors to refugees from Ukraine, they have been busy shutting them to migrants from Africa and the Middle East. They also point to President Trump’s consistent disdain for Africa, which only made these feelings even more visceral.
But there is an irony that many of these African and Asian countries also fail to appreciate, or do not want to see. Ukraine, it turns out, has a strong sense of itself as a victim of Russian imperial aggression – from the time of the Tsars through the days of the Soviet Union, Ukrainians have struggled to hold on to their national and cultural identity in the face of numerous “Russification” campaigns (including a current campaign apparently designed to reeducate Ukrainian school children). That history includes war, occupation, campaigns against Ukrainian linguistic and historical memory, the forced removal of ethnic Ukrainians and their replacement by Russians, and a genocidal campaign of famine. For the people of Ukraine, this war is not just simply an effort to dominate their country by another nation. At a fundamental level, the war represents an effort by Russia – yet again - to destroy Ukraine’s historical memory and national consciousness in order to rebuild the Russian Empire.