Russia’s war and the transition to a renewable energy future

Sources (13) ↓

After initially looking like a massive blow to a clean energy future, Russia’s war in Ukraine seems have hugely accelerated efforts by Western governments to move away from the carbon economy

In the short term, the war in Ukraine has been a disaster for those hoping to move to a clean energy future. The world’s governments, already behind UN-mandated targets to decarbonize and embrace clean energy before the invasion, have accelerated their use of coal, oil and gas as a result of the decreased flow of Russian energy. According to the World Economic Forum, Russian oil and natural gas – the country’s only meaningful export -- accounted for 2/5 of Europe’s pre-war energy. US and European sanctions on Russia were therefore designed to target the only important Russian export to the West as a means of exerting pressure on Russia’s otherwise underdeveloped economy. But it came at a cost: as Steve Cohen from Columbia University’s Climate School of the Planet put it, “Europe is like a junkie trying to attack its favorite drug pusher.” To make up for the shortfall in Russian energy supplies, Germany and other European nations ceased to decommission their aging nuclear plants, and burned more (and dirtier, when necessary) coal to provide energy.

The immediate impact of sanctions was a spike in energy costs and an overall growth in inflation across the world. There were fears that the crisis set off by the Russian invasion would prove far more devastating to the global economy than the oil crisis of the 1970’s, given the centrality of energy to virtually all of modern life. As the International Energy Agency put it, “the energy crisis today has multiple dimensions: natural gas, but also oil, coal, electricity, food security and climate. Therefore, the solutions are similarly all encompassing. Ultimately what is required is not just to diversify away from a single energy commodity, but to change the nature of the energy system itself, and to do so while maintaining the affordable, secure provision of energy services.

But interestingly, the worst predictions for an energy Armageddon did not occur. In part, this was because somewhat milder winter than usual aided the transition in Europe. But a more important factor has been the emphasis by governments, particularly in European and North America, to create a more rapid transition away from fossil fuels. The Economist magazine believes that through a combination of policies designed to increase efficiencies and subsidies, the adoption of green technologies has been accelerated by a decade over pre-war expectations. A key reason for this, particularly in Germany, has been the realization that dependency on any one supplier – particularly one as erratic and unstable as Putin’s Russia – is far more dangerous than previously believed. German policy before the invasion was to tie the country’s industrial sector closely to Russian energy imports, believing that such a productive relationship would bind Russia to a peaceful international order. The Russian invasion ended that illusion, and even conservative Germans now refer to renewables as “freedom energy.” As one commentator put it, “heat pumps are patriotic now.”

The Biden administration also has much to gain from this new world of renewables. While the US was never a major importer of Russian energy, it has found itself feeling squeezed by Saudi Arabia and other oil producers. The $400 billion investment underwritten by the Inflation Relief Act is thus an important means of moving away from potentially hostile exporters.

Several commentators, including the Israeli author Yuval Noah Harari, have referred to Russia as “a gas station with nukes.” If Europe and the US accelerate their adoption of renewable technologies, the “gas station” part of the statement won’t even matter.

Sources

Links go to the original publishers. Some require a subscription.

  1. How the Russian war machine sparked a clean energy drive in the West (Ned Temko/Christian Science Monitor) Read article csmonitor.com
  2. Bitter harvest for some in a global economy changed by Russia’s war (Richard Partington, Damion Carrington/The Guardian) Read article theguardian.com
  3. The impact of Russia’s Invasion on Ukraine on climate change policy - (Steve Cohen/Columbia Climate School State of Planet) Read article news.climate.columbia.edu
  4. This is how the war in Ukraine could affect Europe’s clean energy transition (Sverre Alvik/World Economic Forum) Read article weforum.org
  5. Beyond Ukraine: the new economics of green economy – (Ben Martin/Chris Hopkins/Green Economy Coalition) Read article greeneconomycoalition.org
  6. War and subsidies have supercharged the green transition (The Economist) Read article economist.com
  7. The net-zero energy path in the wake of the Ukraine war: a transition, a detour or a different path? (Hamid Samandari, Dickon Pinner, Harry Bowcott, and Olivia White/McKinsey) Read article mckinsey.com
  8. World Energy Output 2022 (Report by International Energy Agency) Read article iea.org
  9. Ukraine war is a wakeup call for a faster transition to green energy (Alice Tidey/Euronews) Read article euronews.com
  10. What’s at stake for the global economy as conflict looms (Patricia Cohen and Jack Ewing/NYTimes ) Read article nytimes.com
  11. Russia: a large gas station with nukes (ClimateChangeFork) Read article climatechangefork.blog.brooklyn.edu
  12. Russia is a gas station with nukes (Yuval Noah Harari/Twitter) Read article twitter.com
  13. Sustainable development goals: affordable and clean energy (United Nations) Read article un.org

All newsletters