On March 10, China brokered a resumption of diplomatic ties between Iran and Saudi Arabia, anticipating a formal exchange of ambassadors in the near future. The renewal of relations between the two Islamic powers comes after a break of seven years, punctuated by violence and proxy conflicts. The news is significant for all three nations, but maybe the most for China.
There are many reasons for Iran and Saudi Arabia to ratchet down the temperature in their ongoing struggle, which has its origins in the Islamic Schism between Sunni Saudi Arabia and Shia Iran and dates to the end of the 7th Century. The deal lessens Iran’s diplomatic and economic isolation, and the longer term possibility of Saudi investment could be attractive, since such investment might ameliorate some of the economic pain that Iran feels. The population is young, and a weak economy is one source of unrest. For Saudi Arabia, the deal could reduce Iranian support for Houthi rebels in the ongoing and deadly war in Yemen. The Saudi intervention in support of the internationally recognized Yemeni government has been long, expensive and generally ineffective, and it threatens de-facto ruler Prince Mohammad bin Salman’s long term plans for the Kingdom’s development. The lack of movement on restarting the JCPOA (the Iran nuclear deal, which was negotiated in 2015 and from which President Trump withdrew in 2018) may have also made the Saudis feel they to take more control of their own destiny in the neighborhood. Finally, the deal gives Saudi Arabia an opportunity to diversify its great power relationships away from the United States, which have been particularly strained since the murder of journalist Jamal Khashoggi in 2018, a murder apparently sanctioned by bin-Salman.
The real winner in this agreement may be China. President Xi has made no secret of his ambitions to give China a greater profile on the global stage, and this deal does represent a breakthrough for Chinese diplomacy. In May 2022, China proposed a new “Global Security Initiative (GSI),” designed to “contribute Chinese wisdom to the human peace deficit” and “provide Chinese solution[s] to cope with international security challenges.” Under the rubric of the GSI, China proposed a peace plan for the Ukraine-Russia conflict, which as the Washington Post commented, caused scarcely a ripple since it contained “no road map, no sequencing and no confidence-building measures.” This agreement therefore gives a substantive boost to Chinese diplomacy, which has been hampered by its diplomatic support for Russia in its war in Ukraine. It was able to do this because it retains good will with both Iran and Saudi Arabia, buttressed by economic relationships with both countries. But it does come with some risk. China, according to one commentator close to the Saudi government, is now the “godfather” to the agreement and will be expected to remain engaged – an important departure from previous Chinese efforts to limit international exposure to trade and investment. But clearly, China sees the potential upside as worth the risk exposure.
Most commentators initially saw the deal as a problem for the US, distracted by the Ukraine war, noting in particular that it erodes America’s regional role and could make it easier for Iran to avoid rejoining the JCPOA (the chair of the House Intelligence Committee called it “a troubling development that does not reflect well on the Biden Administration.)” Statements by the Administration itself are more favorable, indicating anything that lowers tension in the Gulf region is a good thing – and ultimately, maybe that’s the best way to describe the deal.