The world divides in two - or it seems to, anyway...

Sources (14) ↓

With Xi's state visit to Russia, China becomes a major Eurasian political force, and the US confronts a more complex challenge than ever before

In February 1997, George Kennan, a former diplomat and one of the principal architects of the Cold War policy of containment of the Soviet Union, made a seemingly prophetic warning: Eastward expansion of NATO towards Russia “would be the most fateful error of American policy in the entire post-cold-war era….Such a decision may be expected to inflame the nationalistic, anti-Western and militaristic tendencies in Russian opinion; to have an adverse effect on the development of Russian democracy; to restore the atmosphere of the cold war to East-West relations, and to impel Russian foreign policy in directions decidedly not to our liking.” Needless to say, Kennan’s words were not heeded by then-President Bill Clinton – or indeed by any other NATO ally. Because NATO is a defensive alliance, and because global liberal democratic institutions seemed to be on the ascendant, few worried about Russian perceptions. But Kennan warned that the Russians “would see their prestige (always uppermost in the Russian mind) and their security interests as adversely affected. They would, of course, have no choice but to accept expansion as a military fait accompli. But they would continue to regard it as a rebuff by the West and would likely look elsewhere for guarantees of a secure and hopeful future for themselves.”

Kennan’s warning of Russia’s “looking elsewhere” emerged more starkly than ever between March 20 - 22, when Chinese President Xi Jinping arrived in Moscow for a state visit hosted by Russian President Vladimir Putin. The trip is a statement by Xi and a lifeline for Putin. There is now a strong convergence of interests for both leaders, who have made no secret of their dislike of the current, American-centered world order, which they feel unfairly relegates them to permanent second-class status. Xi made clear his trip to Moscow was in the service of weakening US and Western power. Before he left for Moscow, he warned in a statement that “our world is confronted with complex and intertwined traditional and non-traditional security challenges, damaging acts of hegemony, domination and bullying.”

Both Xi and Putin fear encirclement by NATO in the west and similar set of alliances and understandings in Asia, from AUKUS (Australia, UK and US), the “Quad” (Japan, Australia, India and the US) and renewed security ties with the Philippines as well as the longstanding US alliances with Japan and South Korea. Putin cited fear of NATO expansion (as well as Ukrainian “Nazism”) as his basis for invasion. Both China and Russia would prefer an international order that is more multi-polar, less rules-based (or at least based on Russian and Chinese rules), and less reserve currency dollar dependent, which would undermine one of America’s greatest advantages. A joint communique after the visit stated that China and Russia “urge the United States to stop undermining international and regional security and global strategic stability in order to maintain its own unilateral military superiority.”

The split between a Chinese-Russian bloc and the West could have enormous consequences for the whole world, complicating collaboration on a host of important issues, including scientific cooperation and climate change as well as trade and economic issues. This would make everyone poorer, reduce the global quality of life, and place large parts of the world – particularly poorer nations – at risk. IMF managing director Kristalina Georgieva warned that the longer term costs of geopolitical tensions could range from 0.2% of global output in a limited scenario to almost 7% in a severe one. If technological decoupling is added to the mix, some countries could see losses of up to 12% of GDP.

How much this Russian-Chinese friendship is due to the expansion of NATO is hard to know – Russia has a long history of paranoia and hostility towards its neighbors,and tends to either try to dominate or bully them: one reason the former Baltic republics and Poland are staunch members of NATO. But one thing is clear – a technologically sophisticated China and a resource rich and angry Russia pose a serious challenge to the West in general and the United States in particular. And dangerously for the United States, the nation’s unity and sense of purpose is more fractured than at any time since the end of World War II. America’s global leadership could be tested more severely in the coming years than it ever was during the Cold War.

Sources

Links go to the original publishers. Some require a subscription.

  1. A fateful error (George Kennan/NYTimes (Feb 5, 1997)) Read article nytimes.com
  2. Xi-Putin sign joint statement on deepening strategic partnership and cooperation for the new era (Xinhua/CCTV) Read article english.cctv.com
  3. What to make of Xi’s trip to Moscow (James Palmer/Foreign Policy) Read article foreignpolicy.com
  4. No path to peace: Five key takeaways from Xi and Putin’s talks in Moscow (Simon McCarthy/CNN) Read article cnn.com
  5. In a brother act with Putin, Xi reveals fear of containment (Chris Buckley/NYTimes), Read article nytimes.com
  6. World will divide in two blocs: Democracy vs autocracy (Tom O’Connor/Newsweek) Read article newsweek.com
  7. The world is splitting in two (Michael Schuman/The Atlantic) Read article theatlantic.com
  8. Is the world splitting into two science blocs? (Yojana Sharma/University World News) Read article cset.georgetown.edu
  9. How Xi and Putin’s friendship could test the US (Stephen Collinson/CNN) Read article cnn.com
  10. The dollar is our super power, and China and Russia are threatening it (Fareed Zarkaria/Washington Post) Read article washingtonpost.com
  11. Western democracy is weaker in this new Cold War than the old one (Rafael Behr/The Guardian) Read article theguardian.com
  12. World split into rival economic blocs threatens action (KW Tan/i3 Investor) Read article klse.i3investor.com
  13. The wrong way to view the Xi-Putin meeting (Evan Feigenbaum/Carnegie Endowment for International Peace) Read article carnegieendowment.org
  14. IMF’s Georgieva: Risks of fragmentation is strong (Dan Burns/US News and World Report) Read article usnews.com

All newsletters