Why was House Speaker Kevin McCarthy’s visit with Taiwan’s President not as fraught as Nancy Pelosi’s visit to Taiwan? Internal politics in China and Taiwan may have played an important role in keeping things calm.
House Speaker Kevin McCarthy met with Taiwanese President Tsai Ing-wen at the Ronald Reagan Library in Simi Valley on April 5, despite Chinese warnings that it would "take strong measures" and “resolutely safeguard our sovereignty and territorial integrity.” A Chinese Foreign Ministry spokesperson warned that “China firmly opposes any form of official interaction between the United States and Taiwan.” A number of commentators warned that China’s reaction could be at least as severe as China’s response to former House Speaker Nancy Pelosi’s visit to Taiwan in July, when Chinese officials delivered dire warnings and the People’s Liberation Army fired a missile over the island and simulated a blockade of Taiwan.
The reaction this time was much more muted, and may have had more to do with internal politics in both Taiwan and China than in any sagacity by McCarthy, who is not given high marks for his foreign policy acumen by his colleagues.
For Taiwan, the Pelosi visit was, on the one hand, a welcome show of support from one of Taiwan’s few remaining international supporters. But the Pelosi visit also reminded the Taiwanese of just how vulnerable they are to Chinese pressure. Opinion surveys showed that the majority of Taiwanese, despite increasingly seeing themselves as Taiwanese first rather than Chinese, also felt “less safe” after the visit of Pelosi, thus creating a conflict between identity and security. A second visit by a House Speaker in less than a year therefore might have provoked an even more hostile reaction from China than the Pelosi visit - not a welcome development. Thus, when McCarthy offered to follow Pelosi’s footsteps and visit Taiwan, Taiwanese President Tsai suggested an alternative: that she visit the US instead, a move which changed the focus away from Taiwan to California. Furthermore, Taiwan’s next presidential election is ten months away, and President Tsai’s political party, the Democratic Progressive Party (DPP), probably did not want to be blamed for a potential worsening of the political climate with China.
For its part, Beijing probably had a number of reasons to downplay the importance of President Tsai’s visit, though the Chinese did move an aircraft carrier close to the island and sanctioned the two places she gave speeches – the Reagan Library in Simi Valley and the Hudson Institute (for a speech in New York City). The first reason for the relatively muted response is that while Tsai visited with Speaker McCarthy, there were no meetings with Biden Administration figures. The second reason is that while China’s hardline reaction to the Pelosi visit was generally popular within China, internationally the country’s reputation took a hit, damaging China’s image abroad. Fresh off of brokering a rapprochement between Iran and Saudi Arabia, and with French President Macron in Beijing, an overreaction to the visit could have undone Xi’s efforts at statesmanship.
Finally, there was another cross-Taiwan Straits visit taking place at the same time: former President Ma Ying-jeou of the Kuomintang (KMT) Party visited mainland China at the same time as President Tsai visited the US, the first time a current or former Taiwanese President has visited the mainland since the end of the Civil War in 1949. Ma’s visit, ostensibly to visit the graves of his ancestors, was carefully calibrated by both the KMT and China. Ma used the visit to emphasize the generally positive relationship his KMT has with China, in contrast to the more independence-minded DPP of President Tsai. But – walking a tightrope – Ma did not go to Beijing or visit with President Xi, which likely would have been unpopular in Taiwan. The Chinese, for their part, focused on Ma’s message that “all are Chinese” on both the mainland and in Taiwan, and highlighted his call for closer cooperation by both sides. Given the stressful nature of the region, the relatively muted reaction on both sides of the Taiwan Straits should count as something of a victory.