The arrival of Hurricanes Helene and Milton less than two weeks apart has, at least for the moment, focused public attention on the link between weather events and climate change. While the economic and social effects are profound in Florida, the state’s distress is already impacting insurance markets across the United States as companies seek to spread the risk. In areas prone to flooding and wind events, housing prices are levelling off or declining, even while insurance rates are climbing – and for the first time in the modern era, Americans are considering moving due to climate change, which would make them de facto climate refugees within the United States. The decision by Zillow and Redfin to include climate risk in their listing information will make it even easier to consider climate as a factor in real estate decisions.
Despite modeling that indicates that Florida may be the state most prone to catastrophic events in the nation (that’s saying something coming from California), the extreme polarization in the political electorate has turned preparing for climate change into a political football. Florida Governor DeSantis signed a bill last May banning the term “climate change” in official documents, and even more remarkably, a large number of Florida’s Republican congressional delegation voted against funding the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA), a stance which played well with conservative voters at the time but now looks increasingly like an electoral liability.
Disasters such as hurricanes are obviously intensely disruptive to the economy as they damage infrastructure, rupture supply chains, and destroy housing stock. Recovering can take years, and costs can reach trillions of dollars -- more for states which fail to adequately prepare. But the risks to American security goes far beyond property damage and loss of life in the affected zones. It might therefore be better to say that risks to human life and property damage are part of a broader threat to America’s overall security. The US military and intelligence agencies certainly think so - they have been planning for climate change since at least 2003, when the Department of Defense’s Office of Net Assessment commissioned a controversial report considering climate effects on military readiness. Since that time, the Navy and Marine Corps have purchased equipment designed to support operations in flooded zones (more likely with climate change), and all the services have looked for means to “harden” structures and supply lines, insulating them from extreme weather events. This is particularly important for combat readiness, since many US defense facilities are physically located in coastal regions prone to flooding and storm surge.
As worrisome as these trends are, they pale next to the even greater threats that climate change poses over the longer term. In the most recent National Intelligence Estimate (NIE - a compendium of information from all 18 US intelligence agencies), not one agency voiced a dissent over the impact of climate change as a national security threat.
Harvard University’s Belfer Center and Columbia University’s Climate School have both used the unclassified portions of NIE documents as the basis for climate research, and noted that climate change will exacerbate geopolitical tensions and social instability. In particular, these institutions warn of greater outbreaks of disease, escalating population displacement (meaning climate migration), increased poverty and income inequality in the areas most affected, accelerated competition for resources, and increased civil unrest caused by potentially radicalized populations angry with governments seen as complicit in accelerating climate change. More specifically, climate change also makes navigation possible in the Arctic, opening another potential front in America’s geopolitical tensions with Russia.
Most of these issues have been with us for hundreds of years, and just like the storms themselves, the effects of changing weather patterns will be supercharged, presenting new challenges for agencies charged with safeguarding American security. There is no way to completely wall the United States off from the effects of climate change, and events that seem far away for most Americans -- drought in Mali and Niger, floods in Central America or China, and typhoons in Asia and hurricanes in the Atlantic – will have an impact on here in the US. Failure to plan for climate change not only has local consequences – it is a national security failure as well.
Amongst all the gloom, there is also some good news: At almost the same time as the two hurricanes hit Florida, the United Kingdom closed its last coal-fired power plant. Ironically (and positively), if the country that started the industrial revolution with coal power 142 years ago can end its dependence on coal power today, maybe others can move away from fossil fuels as well.