Springfield Ohio represents the best and worst of American immigration

Sources (13) ↓

Donald Trump and JD Vance’s increasingly ugly disinformation campaign targeting alleged pet-eating Haitian immigrants in Springfield, Ohio, highlights the continuing paradox of American immigration: it has powered our nation’s economy since its founding, but also serves as a catalyzing lightning rod for those who fear racial, religious, political and cultural change.

Economically, there is very little disagreement that inbound migration has continued to provide huge benefits to the United States. According to most financial experts and economists, immigration is the difference between America’s strong post-Covid economic growth and recession. In an April speech at Stanford University, Federal Reserve Chairman Jerome Powell credited immigration with keeping the US economy growing at 3% when most forecasts anticipated a mild to severe recession, as happened to most other economies worldwide.

But immigration does not just benefit the overall US economy. Ironically, the influx of immigrants has also staved off the collapse of innumerable smaller towns across America – many of which are in the Midwest, including of course Springfield, Ohio. These towns have seen their next generation move to larger urban centers, leaving behind an aging and shrinking workforce. Immigrant workers – legal and undocumented – have filled the gaps created by emigrating locals. According to AP, “over the past four years, the number of prime-age workers who either have a job or are looking for one has surged by 2.8 million. And nearly all those new labor force entrants — 2.7 million, or 96% of them — were born outside the United States. Immigrants last year accounted for a record 18.6% of the labor force.” In small population centers, the loss of immigrant workers and small business owners would be devastating, which is why Springfield’s elected officials, nearly all Republican, and Ohio Governor DeWine, also a Republican, have asked for an end to the Haitian anti-immigrant rhetoric (DeWine called the reports that Haitians were eating dogs and cats (“a piece of garbage that was simply not true.”)

Hostility towards immigrants is not a new phenomenon in the United States. It has generally been animated by three factors: religion, race and security concerns. From the founding of the Republic until the Civil War, religion was the animating factor, particularly from the 1840s onward. Protestant elites fretting about the influx of Catholic immigrants, particularly from Ireland, and later Italy, Catholic Germany and Poland. This wave of Catholic immigration induced nativist politicians to coalesce into the Native American Party, most commonly referred to as the “Know Nothings” (from their supposed response to queries about their political affiliation). Motivated by the fear that the Pope and Catholic hierarchy would undermine America’s institutions and Protestant identity, Know Nothings became a political force in the 1850s, championing anti-immigrant legislation before imploding over the issue of slavery just before the American Civil War.

Union victory in the Civil War meant the emancipation of millions of African Americans at the same time as a surge in immigration from Asia and Latin America. This changed the focus of anti-immigrant sentiment away from religion and towards racial exclusion. More successful at limiting immigration based on race rather than religion, Congress adopted strict immigration quotas for non-Europeans (including the notorious Chinese Exclusion Act in 1882 and the even more draconian 1924 Johnson-Reed Act) while at the same time allowing states to actively curtail the rights of non-White voters through Jim Crow and other means of non-white voter suppression.

Following the Second World War, American attitudes towards immigration changed again, and were shaped largely by security concerns as the US became a global superpower. Interestingly, in this period of time attitudes towards immigration were generally positive. Stanford’s group on Human-Centered Artificial Intelligence recently created an AI model to track the tone of Congressional and Executive Branch speeches. They discovered that the vast majority of these statements were broadly favorable to immigration, which was perceived as an enormous advantage in the Cold War competition with Russia, bringing in much needed expertise and innovation. Security concerns were clearly present, but most Americans saw immigration as a net positive.

Today, attitudes have shifted again. Race, religion and security have coalesced together as reasons for limiting immigration. 9/11 exacerbated fear of Muslim immigrants, not unlike the anti-Catholic nativism of the early to mid-19th Century, while the large influx of non-white immigrants has once again made race a central theme, particularly in communities hollowed out by globalization, industrial efficiency and changing patterns of work in America. Demonization of migrants will likely get worse before the election, since for Donald Trump and JD Vance, immigration is the one important electoral advantage both believe they have over Kamala Harris and Doug Walz.

The stakes are high. Few doubt that America's immigration system needs real reform, but a second Trump administration would likely create a punitive system approach designed to severely limit legal immigration and expel anyone without citizenship or permanent residency. The damaging consequences to the nation’s economic competitiveness and innovative capacity would likely be incalculable. The damage to America’s moral standing might even be worse.

Sources

Links go to the original publishers. Some require a subscription.

  1. In Springfield, I heard stories about strain, promise – and race (Eugene Robinson/Washington Post) Read article washingtonpost.com
  2. How immigrants are boosting US economic and job growth (Jack Kelly/Forbes) Read article forbes.com
  3. Fed Chair Jerome Powell: Immigration the reason the economy grew 3% in a year: “We needed more people.” (Ian Schwartz/ Real Clear Politics) Read article realclearpolitics.com
  4. How immigrant workers in the US have boost job growth and staved of recession (Paul Wiseman, Gisela Saloman and Christopher Rugaber/AP) Read article apnews.com
  5. Can immigration save small-town America? Hispanic Boomtowns and the uneasy path to renewal (Patrick J. Carr, Daniel T. Lichter, and Maria J. Kefalas/Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science) Read article journals.sagepub.com
  6. Making America 1920 again? Nativism and US Immigration, past and present (Julia G Young/Journal of Migration and Human Security) Read article journals.sagepub.com
  7. Immigration is powering the US economy (Wendy Edelberg and Tara Watson/Time) Read article time.com
  8. Rethinking migration is a security – just not in the way you might think (Erol Yayboke and Marie McAuliffe/CSIS) Read article csis.org
  9. How have attitudes towards US immigration changed? (Edmund L. Andrews/-Human Centered Artificial Intelligence-Stanford University) Read article hai.stanford.edu
  10. Immigration has been a defining, often contentious, element throughout US history (Jessica Bolter/Migration Policy Institute) Read article migrationpolicy.org
  11. A century ago, anti-immigrant rhetoric almost closed America’s doors (Matthew Smith/The Conversation) Read article theconversation.com
  12. When America hated Catholics (Josh Zeitz/Politico) Read article politico.com
  13. How the 19th Century Know-Nothing party shaped American politics (Lorraine Boisenault/Smithsonian Magazine) Read article smithsonianmag.com

All newsletters