What makes us American? Kamala Harris' pending nomination may help us find out

Sources (23) ↓

Is the United States a homeland, an ideal or a people? That question has vexed America from its founding up to the present day, and the interplay of those three concepts says a lot about America’s frame of mind at various times in its history. It may play an outsize role in the next election, with enormous implications for the nation’s future.

The framers of the Constitution tried to balance these concepts of place, idea and people. They were idealists and very much creatures of the Enlightenment, with a belief in rationalism, constitutional government and religious tolerance – but only for "free white males." Believing Europe to be hopelessly corrupted and well aware of the religious and dynastic warfare that had torn the continent apart, the Constitution’s authors deliberately set out to create a Republic that was tied together by the ideals of liberty rather than simply concepts of land or ethnicity, a concept sometimes referred to as "creedal" nationalism. Most of the Founders hoped that America would serve as a shining example for others, a “Citty on a Hill” (John Winthrop’s phrase, later repeated by Ronald Reagan) and an “Empire of Liberty” (Thomas Jefferson’s belief). Or as Benjamin Franklin stated “…our cause is the cause of all mankind….we are fighting for [other people’s] liberty as we defend our own.”

Yet as Kiara Alfonseca, Jedidiah Purdy and Nikole Hannah-Jones have all pointed out, despite its soaring rhetoric American nationality has mostly been defined by exclusivity – by who was not granted citizenship. This is largely because concepts of American citizenship and identity were firmly grounded in English common law: jus solis (right of soil) meant that those of European descent born in America were American citizens and jus sanguinis (the right of blood, or birthright citizenship), which meant that that citizenship was hereditary and could be passed down from parents to children, even if the children were born outside of the United States. The concept was further defined by Congress in 1790, when it declared that “free white persons” could become citizens after a two year wait. But the grafting from English common law was flawed: while 18th century Britain was a relatively homogenous society, 18th century America was most assuredly not – in 1790 there were nearly 700,000 African Americans living in the US, of whom fewer than 60,000 were free. And there were many other non-Europeans, including of course Native Americans, also within the borders of the new United States. America was therefore born multicultural, but hardly free of racial identity politics.

Throughout the 19th and early 20th centuries, America turned inward and more towards the concept of a homeland refuge for those fleeing oppression and poverty as concepts of homeland took precedence over the Founding Fathers’ idealism. Little effort was made to export America’s ideals, and citizenship was expanded grudgingly. Black males were only enfranchised following the American Civil War and the 13th, 14th and 15th amendments to the Constitution, while it took the Supreme Court's landmark Wong Kim Ark decision in 1898 to allow children of Chinese citizens born in the US to become American citizens (a precedent later applied to other non-White immigrants). None of these acts and decisions prevented Jim Crow segregation and voter suppression targeted against non-White populations. Women, of course, had to wait to vote until the passage of 19th Amendment in 1920. Not until the Civil Rights Act in 1964, signed into law by President Lyndon Johnson, did America genuinely make the effort to live up to the stated promises of the Declaration of Independence that “All men [sic] are created equal …. With certain unalienable rights.”

Joe Biden’s decision not to run for President, and then to endorse Kamala Harris, actually brings together these disparate strands of America’s identity – blood, soil and idealism – back into the foreground of America’s conscience. As the American born daughter of non-White immigrants, she personifies what the Declaration of Independence promised, but the Constitution had failed to deliver – an America where anyone from anywhere can become a citizen.

But if Kamala Harris’ elevation to Democratic nominee represents a reversal of much of the Constitution’s unfinished business, the MAGA Republican version of America is focused more than ever on the imagery of race and the homeland – the idea of a happier, mythologized past. As Adam Server states in an essay in The Atlantic, "if America is a creedal nation, then anyone can be an American. But if real Americans are those who share a specific history, then some of us are more American than others.” Much of the MAGA imagery and commentary – demonization of non-White immigrants, coded statements about “real” Americans, the subordination of women (including exhortations to have more babies), an emphasis on law and order at the expense of civil liberties – come straight from the ideologies of various 20th century authoritarian states – Nazi Germany, the USSR and Fascist Italy. The emphasis on national mythology and conformity created a powerful sense of pride and belonging for those on the inside, but underneath the façade these regimes were deeply oppressive and insecure. They were also remarkably unstable – wobbling across the spectrum between paranoid insularity to paroxysms of exported violence. That pattern continues through to the present day: Putin's Russia has clear parallels to the authoritarian regimes of the 1930s. Former President Trump’s admiration for Putin and his comments to evangelicals that "you won’t have to vote anymore” if he wins the next election have only made this authoritarian link more explicit.

President Biden’s speech following his decision not to run was a return to the idealistic aspects of American exceptionalism, which he called “the very nature of who we are…. America is an idea, an idea stronger than any army, bigger than any ocean, more powerful than any dictator or tyrant. It’s the most powerful idea in the history of the world.” Although Biden has never been lauded for his rhetoric, his July 24 statement hit the nail on the head: “…America is at an inflection point, one of those rare moments in history when the decisions we make now will determine [the] fate of our nation and the world for decades to come.” Biden is right. The implications are profound, not just for America but also for the rest of the world.

Sources

Links go to the original publishers. Some require a subscription.

  1. July 24, 2024 Remarks by President Biden in statement to the American people (The White House) Read article whitehouse.gov
  2. Historians say that Biden’s withdrawal shows that American democracy is working (Greg Jaffe/Washington Post) Read article msn.com
  3. Can American democracy survive the pressure it’s under? A historian has the answer (NPR Interview with Allen Guelzo) Read article npr.org
  4. How the Founding Fathers understood US citizenship (Amy Briggs/National Geographic) Read article nationalgeographic.com
  5. America: creedal or tribal (Paul D. Miller/Providence) Read article providencemag.com
  6. Understanding democratic decline in the United States (Vanessa Williamson/Brookings) Read article brookings.edu
  7. What’s next for American democracy?: 18 experts lay out our ongoing challenges (Democracy Journal vol 70) Read article democracyjournal.org
  8. To my fellow Americans from abroad: Don’t let our democracy fall into authoritarianism (Kim Brening Solomon/Kansas City Star) Read article kansascity.com
  9. Is America a “City on a Hill” or a nation on the precipice? (Carlos Lozada/NYTimes) Read article nytimes.com
  10. Is America still a nation of ideas? (Jedidiah Purdy/Politico) Read article politico.com
  11. Our founding ideals of liberty and equality were false when they were written (Nikole Hannah-Jones/Teaching American History) Read article teachingamericanhistory.org
  12. Who gets to be a “real American” has always been about exclusion (Kiara Alfonseca/FiveThirtyEight) Read article fivethirtyeight.com
  13. How Trump’s definition of a “real” American has grabbed an audience – and what our research shows as why (Fritz Holznagel/ Eric Taylor Woods and Robert Schertzer/The Conversation) Read article theconversation.com
  14. Trump revives “Blood and Soil” rhetoric at New Hampshire rally (Alex Woodward/Independent) Read article independent.co.uk
  15. JD Vance’s empty nationalism (Adam Serwer/The Atlantic) Read article theatlantic.com
  16. Blood and Soil: Revolutionary nationalism as the vanguard of ecological sanity (Enda Miller/Amerika – Note: this is an extremely right wing website) Read article amerika.org
  17. Decoding JD Vance’s brand of nationalism (Farah Stockman/NYTimes) Read article nytimes.com
  18. What must the United States do to sustain its democracy? (Peter Dizikes/MIT News) Read article news.mit.edu
  19. 72% of Americans say the US used to be a good example of democracy but isn’t anymore (Janell Fetterolf and Sofia Hernandez Ramones/Pew Research) Read article pewresearch.org
  20. Historically low faith in US institutions continues (Lydia Saad/Gallup) Read article news.gallup.com
  21. Historian compares America’s current divisions on the past and how we can overcome them (Judy Woodruff in conversation with Heather Cox Richardson/PBS News) Read article pbs.org
  22. Black and Slave population of America from 1790 to 1880 (Statista) Read article statista.com
  23. Trump supporters wasted no time in claiming Kamala Harris is ineligible to be president but they’re wrong (Charlie Hunt/The Conversation) Read article msn.com

All newsletters