The Founding Fathers never anticipated this….

Sources (16) ↓

“History will teach us that ... of those men who have overturned the liberties of republics, the greatest number have begun their career by paying an obsequious court to the people; commencing demagogues, and ending tyrants.” – Alexander Hamilton, Federalist Paper #1.

The framers of the Constitution worried about many dangers to America’s democracy, but perhaps their greatest fear of all was the possibility that the American experiment would be subverted by an autocrat, who, by playing to the mob, would be able to make himself a king in all but name. George Washington was so concerned about this potential for autocracy that he ran for office and retired after two terms as president – in large part so that he could set the example of voluntarily relinquishing power.

The American Revolution was fought (mostly) to overthrow arbitrary governance by the King and Parliament in London, and the authors of the Constitution had no wish to replace a foreign king with a domestic one. They were strongly animated by the principles of the Enlightenment – rationalism, religious toleration, fraternity, natural law, and a belief in the separation of the spiritual and the worldly - between church and state.

Importantly, America’s founders realized that republicanism and democracy had been tried before, and had consistently failed. To understand why, they delved deep into classical history – particularly studying the collapse of democratic Athens and republican Rome. The Founders believed that while both Greece and Rome exemplified the great virtues inherent in rule by the people, their failures also served as a signal warning. Both had been undermined from within: Athenian democracy had fallen into tyranny several times (under Cleon and Athenion) and the Roman republic was fatally undermined by Julius Caesar and ended by his adopted son Octavian (later the first emperor, Augustus). They were also acutely aware of the danger that “factions” (political parties) might play in undermining popular rule. That had happened in Greece and Rome as well as in Britain, which perpetually seemed to be in the throes of constitutional crises and whose own civil war and subsequent military dictatorship a century before loomed large for the Founders. They feared that unscrupulous politicians would exploit internal divisions, leaving the republic susceptible to foreign interference or creating the conditions for a would-be dictator to amass unassailable power.

The framers of the Constitution therefore devised a government which emphasized measured deliberation, and whose legitimacy emanated from the people. Leaders were constrained by laws that checked and balanced their power. Of critical importance, they believed that leaders must exercise their authority as a public trust, understand the limitations of their powers, and remain beholden to the people and the law. What makes the Supreme Court decision so startling is that the Constitution specifically anticipates criminal prosecution of a president, noting that after impeachment, a president removed by the Senate “shall nevertheless be liable and subject to Indictment, Trial, Judgment and Punishment, according to Law.”

The Constitutional “originalists” on the Supreme Court have therefore just delivered a verdict which seems to be greatly at variance with what the writers of the Constitution had in mind. To quote Alexander Hamilton again, what distinguished an American president from the British monarch was that he could be impeached, removed and subject “to the forfeiture of life and estate by subsequent prosecution.” (Federalist 69). That threat was a key reason that Richard Nixon resigned in the wake of Watergate and accepted a pardon from his former Vice President, Gerald Ford.

This is a dangerous time for America. The political landscape is deeply unsettled and polarized. As some observers have noted, America does share some characteristics with the past The American Civil War – itself a cataclysmic breakdown of Constitutional order -- was preceded by a period of great unrest, including political violence inside Congress. For all of their numerous faults, the founders of the Confederacy believed that they were preserving their version of America’s institutions– at least in terms that 19th Century Americans would understand (that is, political participation limited to white male property owners). None argued for autocracy or military dictatorship. By contrast, in today’s America, polling indicates that a substantial number of Republicans have given up on democracy, and have asserted that they would prefer either a military or civilian dictatorship. (Also of great concern: a large number of younger voters also do not believe that American democracy works for them either).

Even if Donald Trump were not the Republican nominee, the Supreme Court’s decision would be dangerous. But Trump's pending nomination and his many statements on political retaliation and weaponization of the Justice Department make the decision even more irresponsible. Perhaps Justice Sonia Sotomayor, joined by the other two liberal Supreme Court justices, said it best. “In every use of official power,” she wrote in her dissent,” the president is now a king above the law.” Exactly the state of affairs America’s founders sought to avoid.

Sources

Links go to the original publishers. Some require a subscription.

  1. The US Constitution, featuring profiles on the Founding Fathers, a comprehensive collection of amendments, and a wealth of historical documents (Eleanor Stratton/US Constitution.net) Read article usconstitution.net
  2. The Records of the Federal Convention of 1787 (Vol 1 ed. Max Farrand) Read article oll.libertyfund.org
  3. The Federalist Papers: No. 1 (Alexander Hamilton -compiled by Lillian Goldman Law Library, Yale University) Read article avalon.law.yale.edu
  4. The Founders anticipated the threat of Donald Trump (Jeffrey Rosen/Wall Street Journal) Read article wsj.com
  5. Civic virtue and why it matters (Jackie McDermott/National Constitution Center) Read article constitutioncenter.org
  6. Why America’s founders tried to recruit a foreign prince to be their king – and how that moment has a warning for today (Richard Hurowitz/Time) Read article time.com
  7. The founding fathers feared that political factions would tear the nation apart (Sarah Pruitt/History) Read article history.com
  8. America is living James Madison’s nightmare: The Founders designed a government that would resist mob rule. They didn’t anticipate how strong the mob would become (Jeffrey Rosen/ The Atlantic) Read article theatlantic.com
  9. Why demagogues were the Founding Fathers greatest fear (Eli Merritt/LA Times) Read article latimes.com
  10. Why do we still have the electoral college? (Marina Bolotnikova in conversation with historian Alexander Keyssar/Harvard Magazine) Read article harvardmagazine.com
  11. Emperor Trump? Supreme Court just expanded the imperial presidency (Noah Feldman/Forbes) Read article bloomberg.com
  12. What the Founding Fathers would have done with Donald Trump (Frank Bowman/Washington Monthly) Read article washingtonmonthly.com
  13. The Republican revolt against democracy in 13 charts (Zach Beacham/Vox) Read article vox.com
  14. Republicans are suddenly sharply pessimistic about democracy (Philip Bump/Washington Post) Read article washingtonpost.com
  15. Where support for American democracy is most wobbly (Philip Bump/Washington Post) Read article washingtonpost.com
  16. Trump 2025 is already coming into view (Thomas B. Edsall/NYTimes) Read article nytimes.com

All newsletters