On May 14, the Biden administration indicated that it would increase tariffs on a range of Chinese products: duties on semiconductors and solar cells are to increase by 100% (from 25 to 50%) while duties on lithium ion batteries, steel and aluminum products will more than triple, from 7.5% to 25%. The single biggest increase will be on imported electric vehicles (EVs), with the duty increasing by an eye-popping 400%, from 25% to 100% per automobile. The Administration claims that these tariffs are necessary to protect domestic industries from China’s “unfair trade practices” – activities which the White House website says includes technology transfers, intellectual property and innovation. Administration officials have charged that without these tariffs, subsidized Chinese goods would eventually swamp their American counterparts.
These tariffs put two of the Biden Administration’s priorities in direct competition with one another. On the one hand, the new duties reflect Biden’s desire to revive American manufacturing and create new middle class jobs, particularly in Midwestern states such as Michigan and Ohio, where manufacturing has declined mightily in the past 50 years. But by raising the cost of solar panels, EVs and batteries, the tariffs also undermine big portions of the Administration’s clean energy agenda, which will now have a much harder time achieving its goals without inexpensive Chinese imports.
This is particularly true where EVs are concerned. The number of Chinese vehicles on American roads is currently small, but the US auto industry has reason to worry about the future: Chinese EVs have come a long way from their startup origins and are now efficient, attractive and generally well made. They are also (relatively) inexpensive: a BYD Seagull, for example, costs between $10-12,000 and has a reputation for quality workmanship.
By focusing on creating attractive, inexpensive vehicles, Chinese companies such as BYD and Nio have found a niche neglected by American auto manufacturers. Their approach - making cheap EVs available to lower income consumers -- stands in stark contrast with the American auto industry, which has aimed its EVs at more affluent buyers. Over time, these imports could dramatically undercut Tesla and other American EV manufacturers and compete directly – and most likely extremely effectively – with gas vehicles. Elon Musk recently warned Tesla investors that without tariffs, Chinese car companies “would pretty much demolish most other car companies in the world.”
America’s car industry has seen this scenario play out before. In the 1970s and 80s, US auto manufacturers were caught flat footed by the emergence of lower cost, higher quality cars from Japan. Not unlike the current situation, Honda, Nissan and Toyota went from producing cars no American consumer would buy to producing cars people wanted very much. After contentious negotiations with the Japanese government and its auto industry, Japan agreed to “voluntary” caps on exports to the United States. Despite the limitations on Japanese vehicles, American car manufacturers were forced to make painful changes – cutting costs, improving efficiency and producing higher quality and more reliable models. Japan also ameliorated friction with US trade authorities by building factories in the United States, thus circumventing trade restrictions and making their cars, for all intents and purposes, a hybrid of Japan and America.
At best, the tariffs will likely only work for a few years. China has already announced an investigation into POM (polyoxyethylene) copolymers produced in the US and its allies, and is likely to retaliate with additional tariffs on US products, which will reverberate in the United States. More ominously, Chinese cars are now increasingly competitive without subsidies – the Chinese government is actually phasing those out. Without a significant retooling of the American auto industry (again) – including a much stronger focus on middle class and lower middle class consumers, American auto makers will find themselves losing market share both domestically and abroad.