How "Sleepwalking" into calamity 110 years ago might have helped prevent a disastrous escalation today

Sources (14) ↓

There are strong indications that Israel and Iran came much closer to all-out war than previously acknowledged following Israel’s April 1 airstrike on an Iranian diplomatic annex in Damascus. The strike killed key Iranian military leaders, and caused Iran to respond with a direct attack on Israel with over 300 drones and ballistic missiles – a steep escalation of the shadow war between the two countries. In response, Israeli leaders planned to launch a much harsher retaliatory strike. As we know now, the Israelis ratcheted down their response to a single missile (which got through), and the Iranians dismissed the attack as irrelevant. For the moment, what looked like the start of an “escalation ladder” to a military confrontation that would have likely engulfed the Middle East was averted.

It’s not often that one looks to the start of World War I for inspiration, but this might be one of those odd times. When parallels between the world of 1914 and today are usually drawn, they frequently focus on the similarities between the world then and the world now: Great Power rivalries, trade competition, societal divisions, and intense nationalism can all be cited as comparisons. Historians also frequently note that the Great Powers - Britain, France, Germany, Austria-Hungary, Russia and perhaps the Ottoman Empire - essentially “stumbled” into the conflict (indeed, the title of one recent book is “Sleepwalkers: How Europe went to war in 1914).” War therefore became inevitable because none of the five major powers could find a way to halt the slide to conflict without unacceptable consequences. Because in hindsight it seems so easy to see what went wrong in 1914, and to apply those parallels to today, it is worth a look at how we have avoided a calamitous repeat of these events - so far.

The answer may be in the ending of the Great War, rather than its beginning. All the belligerent powers believed that they were preserving their place in the world and protecting their country’s futures. As we know now, nothing could have been further from the truth. Four of the five great empires collapsed (Austria-Hungary, Germany, the Ottomans, and Russia), while victorious France and Britain were badly damaged in human and economic terms. The map of Europe was redrawn, ethnic conflict returned with a vengeance, communism, fascism, Nazism all emerged, and the stage was set for an even greater conflict 20 years later. If there is one lesson all can agree on, it is that no nation in at the beginning of the war would have welcomed the outcome – not even the victors.

Historians agree that there were off-ramps for the Great Powers before the disaster that was to become World War I began. President Biden knows this. One of his good friends is Vanderbilt historian Jon Meacham, and Biden has in fact convened meetings of historians – partly as intellectual exercises, but also as a means of looking into the past for lessons to inform the future. Although American power is no longer as overwhelming as it has been in the past, it is still formidable. President Biden, acting in concert with American allies, was therefore able to impose some degree of restraint, particularly on Israel – “taking the win” as he called it, in order to prevent a regional conflict from becoming a much wider war.

Wars are, by their nature, unpredictable – and extremely dangerous. If World War I has taught us anything, it is that “stumbling” into war can lead to disaster for all concerned – especially in an age of nuclear weapons.

Sources

Links go to the original publishers. Some require a subscription.

  1. Have Iran-Israel missile strikes changed the Middle East? (James Landale/BBC) Read article bbc.com
  2. Israel planned a bigger attack on Iran, but scaled it back to avoid war (Ronen Bergman and Patrick Kingsley/NYTimes) Read article nytimes.com
  3. Biden focused on preventing Iran attack from spiraling into a wider regional conflict, While House Official says (Sam Fossum/CNN) Read article edition.cnn.com
  4. Israel halts retaliatory strike on Iran following intervention by Biden (Isaac Jones/MSN) Read article msn.com
  5. Israel’s allies make full court press to urge restraint (Cassandra Vinograd/NYTimes) Read article nytimes.com
  6. Even with flames abroad, Biden keeps one eye on the homefront (Peter Baker/NYTimes) Read article nytimes.com
  7. The Sleepwalkers: How Europe went to war in 1914 (Christopher Clarke) Read article amazon.com
  8. How the trauma and struggles of World War I helped shape the modern world (Geoffrey Mock/Duke Today Read article today.duke.edu
  9. How did WW1 change the world? (Unattributed/BBC) Read article bbc.co.uk
  10. How the Great War shaped the world (Jay Winter/The Atlantic) Read article theatlantic.com
  11. Stumbling into World War I, like sleepwalkers (NPR staff/All Things Considered) Read article npr.org
  12. Germany decides on war (The Diplomat) Read article thediplomat.com
  13. Scoop: Inside Biden’s meetings with historians (Mike Allen/Axios) Read article axios.com
  14. “He’s like an upside down iceberg: Historian John Meecham on Joe Biden” (David Smith/The Guardian) Read article theguardian.com

All newsletters