Immigrants and the American experience

Sources (19) ↓

The deaths of six immigrant workers on the Francis Scott Key Bridge in Baltimore on March 28 is a stark reminder that despite the central role that immigrants have played in building (and rebuilding) America, their work is not only often not only overlooked and frequently unappreciated, it is often hazardous. All six were killed doing hard manual labor and working an early morning shift that most native born Americans would prefer to avoid. All six were described as decent and hardworking members of the community.

There is an odd dichotomy at the heart of the American experience. Most Americans proudly acknowledge that we are “a nation of immigrants,” but many now see immigrants as a source of danger – more than 40% of Americans see immigrants as a threat to the economy, to public health, to public safety, and to American society and culture. This last is clearly underpinned by racism – Donald Trump’s comments about immigrants as “vermin” and “poisoning the blood of America” may seem to be straight out of Joseph Goebbels Nazi propaganda playbook, but these comments are actually quite in line with a long history of Nativist and anti-immigrant rhetoric.

At this time of super-heated commentary, it is worth remembering that, quite literally, immigrants have built America’s economic and industrial infrastructure. The nation’s canals, including the Erie Canal, were built by Irish and German immigrants, who were frequently viewed with suspicion by native-born Americans (especially because many were Catholic). The Transcontinental Railroad was built by immigrant Chinese coming west from California and Irish laborers coming east from St. Louis. In the 18th and 19th centuries, immigrants were essential for the rapid industrialization of the American economy. According to a study commissioned by the National Institutes of Medicine, from 1880 to 1920 “[t]he size and selectivity of the immigrant community, as well as their disproportionate residence in large cities, meant they were the mainstay of the American industrial workforce. Immigrants and their children comprised over half of manufacturing workers in 1920, and if the third generation (the grandchildren of immigrants) are included, then more than two-thirds of workers in the manufacturing sector were of recent immigrant stock.” Immigrants were not just essential to infrastructure development and industry – they were also a vital component of American agricultural production. To this day, approximately 73% of American farmworkers are foreign born – primarily from Latin America. The six Latino workers in Baltimore were thus part of a long tradition of immigrants working tough jobs and, in so doing, helping to build the American economy. But immigrants don’t just provide skilled labor – they are also critical for America’s competitive edge – a 2018 survey showed that 71% of Silicon Valley’s tech workforce was born outside the United States. Immigrants founded over half of the 87 privately held American start-ups valued at $1 billion or more in 2017.

Despite its remarkable reliance on immigrant labor and immigrant brainpower, America has a long history of trying to limit immigration and the rights of immigrants. The First US Congress passed the Naturalization Act of 1790, which specified that only White people could be citizens, thereby excluding Asians, African Americans (both free and enslaved), and Native Americans. It was soon followed by the Alien and Sedition Acts of 1798, the first effort by the young United States to limit immigration. Taken together, the four acts extended the length of time to become an American citizen, allowed the deportation of immigrants deemed to be “dangerous to the peace and safety of the United States,” and limited freedom of speech and banned the publication of “any false, scandalous and malicious writing.” These acts were followed by others, some general and some targeted on specific immigrant groups. The Chinese Exclusion Act of 1882, California’s Alien Land Laws of 1913 and 1920 (primarily targeting Japanese immigration), the Immigration Act of 1917 (the “Barred Zone Act” mostly focused on preventing immigration from the Middle East and Southeast Asia, but also providing for a literacy test aimed at Southern Europeans), the Immigration Act of 1924 (the “Asian Exclusion Act”) the and the Tydings-McDuffie Act of 1934 (to prevent Filipinos from becoming citizens despite the Philippines status a colony of the United States are all examples of efforts to limit immigration to the United States - and there were others.

While a stable border and a stable immigration policy are important, so also is a large pool of immigrants – both skilled and unskilled. Indeed, one reason that the US economy avoided a post-Covid recession and continues to grow is immigration. Thus, the great irony is that the economic security of the United States – including the retirement income for America’s aging population – heavily depends on immigration. Without it, America’s economic future would be very much in doubt.

Sources

Links go to the original publishers. Some require a subscription.

  1. The Baltimore bridge collapse reminds us that immigrants often do unheralded and dangerous work(Loraine Ali/LA Times) Read article latimes.com
  2. Building America – Immigrants and the new economy (New America Research Fund) Read article research.newamericaneconomy.org
  3. The anti-immigrant movement in the US (Selena Rincon/Boston University) Read article sites.bu.edu
  4. Immigration, upward mobility and the American economy (Harvard Business Review podcast) Read article hbr.org
  5. The men who fell from the bridge are the people who built our nation (Petula Dvorak/Washington Post) Read article washingtonpost.com
  6. Immigrants and the D & H [Delaware and Hudson] Canal (The Erie Canal Museum) - Read article eriecanalmuseum.org
  7. Americans showing increasing concern over immigration (Lidia Saad/Gallup) Read article news.gallup.com
  8. Immigration and the American industrial revolution from 1880-1920 (Charles Hirschman and Elizabeth Mogford/National Library of Medicine, National Institutes of Health) Read article ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
  9. A nation built by immigrants (George W Bush Center) Read article bushcenter.org
  10. Abramitzky, Ran, and Leah Boustan. 2017. "Immigration in American Economic History." Journal of Economic Literature, 55 (4): 1311-45. Read article pubs.aeaweb.org
  11. Immigrants make America safer and stronger (Paul Krugman/NYTimes) Read article nytimes.com
  12. Immigrants and the USA workforce (USA Facts) Read article usafacts.org
  13. Immigrant farmers and America’s food production: 5 things to known (Fwd.US/blog) Read article fwd.us
  14. Anti-Immigrant (Southern Poverty Leadership Center) Read article splcenter.org
  15. What history reveals about anti-Semitism and anti-immigrant rhetoric in the United States (Ingrid Anderson/Boston University) Read article splcenter.org
  16. The racism behind anti-immigrant rhetoric is palpable to every American. Including me. (Alan Cumming/NBC News: Think) Read article nbcnews.com
  17. H1B: Foreign citizens make up nearly three-quarters of Silicon Valley tech workforce (Ethan Baron/San Jose Mercury News) Read article mercurynews.com
  18. Why Silicon Valley wouldn’t work without immigrants (Fahrhad Manjoo/NYTimes) Read article fwd.us
  19. How immigrants are saving the economy (Paul Krugman/NYTimes) Read article nytimes.com

All newsletters