When Russian President Putin invaded Ukraine in February, 2022, one of the goals he cited (besides eradicating “Nazism” in a country with a Jewish President) was to prevent the further expansion of NATO. No matter how the war ends, that goal has now failed spectacularly. Sweden officially joined the North Atlantic Treaty on March 7, ending more than 200 years of neutrality and joining with Finland as the Alliance’s newest members. Both countries bring significant resources to the Western alliance. Sweden has a modern arms industry and naval and air forces adapted to the Baltic region and Finland remains heavily armed, with a large army and – because it never abandoned conscription – large reserve forces. Remarkably, both nations have discarded policies that were an integral aspect of their national identities, demonstrating how profoundly the Russian invasion has altered their sense of security.
Both Sweden and Finland felt safe enough during the Cold War to remain outside NATO, in part because the Cold War created a stable, if heavily armed, balance. The Soviet Union was an adversary of the United States and its Western European allies, but a cautious one. For both East and West, the Cold War was usually framed as an ideological contest between the United States and its NATO allies and the USSR and its allies (the Warsaw Treaty Organization, or Warsaw Pact). Conflicts occurred on the periphery, mostly in Africa and Asia, but except for the post-Yugoslav conflicts, not in Europe.
That perspective no longer holds. Russia is no longer Communist, but it is far more expansionist – and, apparently, reckless -- than at any time since the early days following the Bolshevik Revolution. When the USSR collapsed, and with it its zone of control in Eastern Europe and Central Asia, most people and most governments believed that, freed of its Communist ideology, Russia would behave like most other sovereign nations. As a result, the US and most of its Western European allies drew down their military forces and defense spending, believing that conflict in Europe was unlikely - the so-called “peace dividend.”
But it turns out the problem was less Communist ideology and more Russian expansionism. While the United States and much of the global West were caught off guard by the Russian invasion of Ukraine, Russia’s immediate neighbors: not so much. Having lived in uneasy proximity to Russia (Poland, Finland and Sweden) or actually as a part of the Russian Empire and the Soviet Union (Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania, Finland (until December 1917) and Poland (until October 1918)), these countries know what Russian domination means, and have no interest in seeing it happen again. They are therefore amongst the most hawkish in standing up to Russian aggression. When President Biden remarked during the State of the Union address that Putin "will not stop if he succeeds in Ukraine," what sounded like hyperbole to many Americans resonated strongly with Russia's neighbors. As they see it, Putin embodies a toxic mixture of Russian paranoia, exceptionalism, and fear of the success of open societies in Western Europe, made worse by Russia's loss of prestige after the breakup of the USSR.
Joining NATO represents an enormous break with the past for both Sweden and Finland. The concept of neutrality has a long tradition in both nations. Sweden’s version dates to 1809, when it lost Finland to Russia. Over time, neutrality seemed the safest course for the country’s security, though it always maintained robust military forces and in modern times has been a frequent contributor to peacekeeping operations. Finland, absorbed into the Russian Empire in 1809, always maintained a high-degree of autonomy and eventually declared its independence from Russia in 1917 during the Russian Revolution. Though on the losing side in World War II, when it fought with the Germans, it was not occupied by Russia and signed a Treaty of Friendship, Cooperation and Neutrality with the USSR in 1948. Putin’s great miscalculation was thus a belief that this status quo would continue. Throughout most of the post-war era, neutrality was popular with the Swedish public, with only 30% of Swedes favored joining NATO in 2019. But after the Russian invasion, a solid majority of 68% favored NATO membership. Finland experienced a similar surge in pro-NATO public opinion, with over 76% of the country favoring NATO membership in a 2023 poll. Russia’s aggression has thus accomplished something that has never happened before – it has brought all five Nordic nations (Denmark, Finland, Iceland, Norway and Sweden) into a single military alliance. At a time when American leadership seems increasingly questionable, this is a significant boost for Western European morale and security - clearly not what Putin had in mind when he began his “Special Military Operation” in Ukraine two years ago.