In a campaign speech in Conway South Carolina on February 9, former President Donald Trump asserted that he’d “encourage” Russia to attack “delinquent” NATO allies “who did not pay their bills.” The comments betrayed a fundamental lack of understanding of how alliances work and generated dismay on both sides of the Atlantic. The normally reserved NATO Secretary General Jens Stoltenberg warned that Trump's comments “undermine the security of us all,” including the United States. President Biden was more direct, calling the comments "shameful," “dumb” and “un-American.”
Trump’s comments might have been shameful and dumb but they were anything but un-American. Indeed, his comments are part of a long continuum of thought in America, one that has frequently wanted to turn away from the outside world. Most European immigrants to America had little love for the countries they’d left (or been pushed out of) for religious, economic and social reasons. During the Revolutionary War, America’s first alliance, with France, was only signed when it became apparent that the Americans would lose the war without foreign assistance (80% of the arms and gunpowder during the Revolution were supplied by France, Spain and The Netherlands). As soon as the war ended, the United States abrogated the treaties of alliance.
Although the United States has been both an immigrant and a trading nation since its foundation as a colonial outpost of Britain, it wanted no political relationships during the 18th and 19th centuries. Some of this was based on an almost messianic belief that the United States had a destiny to become an example for the rest of the world, a “citty on a hill” in the words of John Winthrop. Others simply believed that America would best prosper by avoiding alliances. George Washington’s famous Farewell Address in 1796 warned against the danger of foreign “entanglements.” Thomas Jefferson carried the theme forward in his first inaugural address, asserting that one of the "essential principles of our government" is that of "peace, commerce, and honest friendship with all nations, entangling alliances with none.” These sentiments were made easier given the US’ relatively remote geographic location - countries like Poland or The Netherlands might have had a harder time cutting themselves off from the rest of the world. The United States’ abundant natural resources made isolationism relatively easier as well.
Though the US acquired an overseas empire at the end of the 19th century, it still steered clear of “foreign entanglements.” Woodrow Wilson was elected President for a second term with the slogan “he kept us out of war,” and after the war opposition to the common security clause was a key factor in sinking US participation in the Wilson-sponsored League of Nations. In 1936/7, the US Congress passed the Neutrality Acts, which prohibited, among other things, American seamen from sailing on ships owned by belligerent nations. The most prominent and influential group of isolationists in the inter-war period was the America First Committee, supported by such prominent individuals as Charles Lindberg, Henry Ford, Sargent Shriver and Lillian Gish. Opposition to American intervention was so strong that after World War II broke out Franklin Roosevelt stated on the campaign trail in 1940 that "I have said this before, but I shall say it again and again and again: Your boys are not going to be sent into any foreign wars."
But reality has a way of intruding. US abrogation of the alliance with France eventually resulted in an undeclared naval war with Revolutionary France between 1798 and 1800, which forced the US to reconstitute its defunct Navy after heavy losses in shipping. In 1812, the US was again drawn into war with Great Britain over, among other things, issues of freedom of navigation during the Napoleonic Wars. In the 20th Century, previously isolationist US public opinion radically turned against Germany in 1917 with the German declaration of unrestricted U-boat warfare, squarely targeting American ships bound for British and French ports. America’s reluctance to become involved in World War II ended with Japan’s December 7 attack on Pearl Harbor and Germany’s declaration of war on the United States on December 11. The previously well-funded and influential America First Committee disbanded on that same day.
World War II ended America’s reluctance to embrace alliances. In an era of global communications, nuclear weapons, ocean-spanning fleets, and a hostile USSR, American politicians and policymakers realized that American security was best served by making the US the linchpin of a series of alliances dedicated to preserving the peace. NATO, founded in 1949, was in the words of its first Secretary General Hastings Ismay, designed to “keep the Americans in, the Russians out and the Germans down.”
Where NATO and other alliances go from here is now a pressing issue in American foreign policy. Within Europe there is a frightening realization that America may not be the reliable bedrock partner that it has been since the end of the Second World War 79 years ago. But renewed American isolationism would be very dangerous for the US too. In NATO’s 75 years of existence, the only country to invoke Article 5 – which binds member states to assist those under attack – has been the United States in the wake of 9/11. Virtually all NATO allies responded by aiding the US in Afghanistan and elsewhere – along with other US allies such as Japan, Australia, New Zealand, and South Korea. In an increasingly dangerous world, America’s alliances are its strongest guarantee of peace and security. Turning its back on America's allies would almost assuredly end for the United States the same way it has over time – in failure.