According to The Economist, there are 76 countries that will hold nationwide elections in 2024 (some, such as Taiwan, have already held them). These elections theoretically represent the popular will of nearly 4 billion people, half of the world’s population, but not all elections are alike – or even democratic. At stake are not just the question of who governs, but also in many cases whether institutional guardrails remain in place and these countries remain democratic in a form we currently recognize as a democracy. “We will know whether democracy lives or dies by the end of 2024,” stated Nobel laureate Maria Ressa at the National Press Club in Washington, DC last September.
Democracy is not just on the ballot in the United States. Many other elections have regional if not global implications, a fact recognized by President Biden, who has increasingly asserted that the defense of democracy is a primary goal for his administration. The good news is that so many countries are having elections, demonstrating the importance of citizen participation. The bad news is that in many countries, the elections are severely circumscribed or a sham, or the citizens themselves seem to want to limit the franchise.
Faith in democratic institutions is declining worldwide, even in wealthy, industrialized countries such as the United States and among EU member states, with many voters increasingly attracted to authoritarian strongmen promising to fix societal problems. Observers of democracy have noted that several factors are contributing to democratic decline in well-established democracies such as the United States.
Freedom House, which measures the state of democracy worldwide, notes that in older democracies, youth discontent is creating serious strains, “driven in large part by perceptions of economic exclusion, illustrated by high youth unemployment and widening economic inequality. In the emerging democracies of Latin America, sub-Saharan Africa, and southern Europe, there is similar disappointment with democratic performance on issues important to young people: education, employment, and opportunity.” Cornell political scientists have observed that such societal cleavages “make it easier for autocratic leaders to leverage democratic institutions – election officials, legislatures, courts and the media – to consolidate executive power. Such processes are incremental and harder to recognize in real time… and may exacerbate polarization that further weakens trust in democracies.”
Of course, for many countries, elections are just window dressing. Russia, Belarus, Venezuela, Tunisia, Pakistan and Bangladesh will all have outcomes that will simply buttress regimes already in power, though some of these countries could find themselves with serious unrest if the vote rigging is too blatant.
In the middle are “hybrid regimes,” which range from “flawed democracies” (countries that retain democratic characteristics but are lacking in key elements of democracy) to “competitive authoritarian” regimes, which have elections but make it difficult for opposing parties to win, often by muzzling the press, jailing opposition leaders, or outright banning opposition parties. India, Turkey, Hungary, Indonesia are all considered to be in this category. It is worth noting that the Economist Intelligence Unit rates the United States as a “flawed democracy,” in part because of the impact of gerrymandering and the electoral college on the voting system.
While some countries may follow Poland’s recent example and turn away from authoritarianism, many more seem to be moving in that direction. As long governments fail to address basic issues of income inequality, voter participation, education - including civic education, unemployment and underemployment, a growing cohort of disaffected citizens will become an ever greater threat to stability around the world.