Why 2024 might prove to be the year of living dangerously for the United States

Sources (16) ↓

If 2023 was a challenging year for the United States, 2024 could be even more difficult. While the conflict in Gaza, the Russian invasion of Ukraine and China’s assertive approach to Taiwan have gained most of the headlines, other threats to the global order are simmering on the backburner – and could move to the front burner. These threats come in three flavors: outright invasion of a neighboring state: Venezuela’s threats to invade Guyana, and fears that Azerbaijan could directly attack Armenia, for example. Others are local conflicts that could spread: besides Gaza, the growing insurgency in Myanmar – which could spill over into India and China, a range of conflicts in Saharan and sub-Saharan Africa, and antics of the always dangerous and unpredictable North Korean regime. And some potential dangers come from the collapse of domestic order: Haiti’s internal collapse, the civil war in South Sudan, and Houthi attacks in the Red Sea have all emerged after a breakdown of local control, and all are contributing to global tensions. At present, the most immediate threat seems to be that the Israeli-Hamas war will spread into southern Lebanon and eventually draw Iran into a regional conflagration – the result of a collapse of Lebanese government control over its own territory.

Beyond the potential for direct conflicts arising between states (and from state collapse), there are a number of broader issues which could have important impacts on the United States: the rise of far right parties in Europe, the economic competition between the US and China, migration pressures, trade issues, climate change, and, looming large, digital threats, including the potential use of AI by state and non-state actors to inject instability and uncertainty into the many elections due to take place this year, including of course in the United States.

This array of challenges would test any American administration, even at a time of relative domestic internal political harmony. Yet one of the oddities of the situation is that at a time when the United States is doing remarkably well in both absolute terms and relative to other countries, the single biggest threat to global stability may come from the United States itself. In virtually every survey of global instability, US political polarization ranks at or near the top of concerns. Many countries are starting to hedge their bets as to whether Donald Trump – with his transactional and ill-informed view of the world -- could make a return to the White House. The Economist called such a possibility a “shadow loom[ing] over the world,” and asserted that Trump poses “the single greatest danger to the world in 2024.” The fact that Trump could return as President has baffled global opinion and tarnished America’s image, complicating the Biden Administration’s ability to cope with the aforementioned challenges.

The possibility of Trump’s return is driven by a deep sense of pessimism on the part of the American electorate, with 76% believing that the country is headed down the wrong track. And indeed, there are serious problems with US society and the economy. Income inequality is extreme in the United States, and many Americans in the middle part of the country feel left out of the economic success of the coasts. Conservatives see a culture and society rapidly changing and becoming all but unrecognizable to them. But as Fareed Zakaria notes, Americans are too pessimistic under the circumstances. By an enormous margin, the United States remains the world’s preeminent economic, financial and military power. The IMF estimates the US economy grew at a robust 2.1% in 2023, including a remarkable 5.2% in the third quarter. US technology remains in the forefront of global innovation (with the value of US tech stocks worth more than the entire stock markets of Canada, Britain, Germany and France combined), and American military power remains overwhelming, able to project power into any quadrant of the world, something no other military can do. And that dominance should continue – in part due to immigration, the US is not aging at the same rate as Europe and East Asia.

The clear lesson from these statistics is that the US maintains the capacity to lead. But it can do so only if it can bridge the internal divisions that sap its confidence and determination to remain central to the international system that it has championed for 80 years. Though many fear that the United States will be unable to maintain the Pax Americana, the bigger danger is that it will simply refuse to do so.

Sources

Links go to the original publishers. Some require a subscription.

  1. Biden’s foreign policy headaches (Ivo Dalder/Politico) Read article politico.eu
  2. US foreign policy priorities for 2024 (Voice of America) Read article editorials.voa.gov
  3. Foreign conflicts are taking up a lot of Biden’s time as he fights for his political life at home (Kevin Liptak/CNN) Read article cnn.com
  4. Independent thinking: What can we expect from 2024? (Various contributors/Chatham House podcast) Read article chathamhouse.org
  5. Tom Standage’s ten trends to watch in 2024 (Tom Standage/The Economist) Read article economist.com
  6. More Americans think foreign policy should be a top US priority for 2024, poll finds (Will Weissert and Linley Sanders/LA Times) Read article msn.com
  7. Hold us accountable: our biggest calls for 2023 (Ian Bremmer/GZero) Read article gzeromedia.com
  8. Visualizing 2024: Trends to watch (Matthew P. Goodman, Kat Duffy, Zongyuan Zoe Liu, Lianna Fix, and Will Freeman/Council on Foreign Relations) Read article cfr.org
  9. Can the spread of war can stopped? (David Ignatius/Washington Post) Read article washingtonpost.com
  10. Donald Trump poses the biggest danger to the world in 2024 (The Economist) Read article economist.com
  11. Heading into 2024 most Americans believe country headed in the wrong direction (Meredith Deliso/ABC News) Read article abcnews.go.com
  12. Why foreign policy is no longer in Biden’s “win” column (Joe LaFranchi/Christian Science Monitor) Read article csmonitor.com
  13. 10 conflicts to watch in 2024 (Comfort Ero and Richard Atwood/Foreign Policy) Read article foreignpolicy.com
  14. After Houthi attacks in the Red Sea, fears of a wider Mid-East war grow (Joe Hernandez/NPR) Read article npr.org
  15. Americans are far too pessimistic about the future (Fareed Zakaria/Washington Post) Read article washingtonpost.com
  16. Conflicts to watch in 2024 (Council on Foreign Relations) Read article cfr.org

All newsletters