The murder of prominent conservative commentator Charlie Kirk comes at an ominous time for the United States. According to Axios, the level of political violence in America is greater than at any time since 1968, when within two months Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr and Robert F. Kennedy were both assassinated. Despite the turmoil in America’s cities and college campuses in the sixties, nearly all civic leaders urged restraint and appealed to America’s better nature. In response to King’s death, for example, President Lyndon Johnson appealed for calm, stating that he hoped all would join him in “praying for peace and understanding throughout this land….We can achieve nothing by lawlessness and divisiveness among the American people. It is only by joining together and only by working together that we can continue to move toward equality and fulfillment for all of our people.”
Johnson and other community leaders’ statements in the 1960s stand in stark contrast with this Administration’s response to the murder of Charlie Kirk. Commentary from Administration officials has focused on assigning responsibility for the murder on the “radical left” in general and Democrats in particular, despite little information on the assassin or his motives. Vice President Vance (inaccurately) claimed that liberals are more to blame for violence than conservatives and asserted that the government should “go after the NGO network that foments, facilitates and engages in violence." Deputy Chief of Staff Stephen Miller asserted that progressive groups are part of a “vast domestic terror network” and vowed to “identify, disrupt, dismantle and destroy these networks.” In contrast to LBJ’s calls for “peace and understanding,” President Trump stated that “for years, those on the radical left have compared wonderful Americans like Charlie to Nazis and the world’s worst mass murderers and criminals. This kind of rhetoric is directly responsible for the terrorism that we’re seeing in our country today.” Like Miller, Trump warned that he would go after “each and every one of those who contributed to this atrocity … including the organizations that fund and support it.” Trump threatened to use RICO (the Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations Act) to go after George Soros and the Open Society Foundation, an organization particularly disliked by Trump. Other Administration officials have jumped in, including Federal Communications Commission Chairman (and Project 2025 co-author) Brendan Carr, who seems to have been a key player in Disney’s decision to remove Jimmy Kimmel from ABC’s lineup. Trump has also stated that stations that criticize him should “lose their licenses.”
The Trump Administration’s attacks on liberal groups and the media are ominous. And even more ominously, this script has been used before – extremely effectively – in Germany in 1933. On the evening of February 27, 1933, a Dutch communist, Marinus van der Lubbe, was arrested for starting a fire in the German Parliament – the Reichstag. To this day, historians argue about van der Lubbe’s guilt in setting the fire, but what is not in doubt was what happened afterwards. Blaming the Communists for the fire and warning of a vast leftist plot to take over Germany, Chancellor Adolf Hitler prevailed upon President Paul von Hindenburg to invoke Article 48 of the Weimar Constitution and sign the “Reichstag Fire Decree.” The decree suspended nearly all civil liberties in Germany, including the right to privacy, freedom of the press and the right of public assembly. The suppression of these civil liberties were used to eliminate newspapers and radio stations not seen as sympathetic to National Socialism, to allow the government to tap phone lines, and to imprison individuals without cause. It also gave Hitler the right to make laws for German states, overriding local legislatures. Acting on the false assertion that van der Lubbe was an agent of a Communist conspiracy planning to take over Germany, the Communist Party was banned and thousands of Communists were arrested, an act which removed some 20 % of the electorate at a stroke and paved the way for the Nazi Party to take power. None of the statutes abrogated by the “Reichstag Fire Decree” were ever reinstated by the Nazi regime.
While it is unlikely that Trump understands the history of the destruction of democracy in Weimar Republic Germany, many of those around him obviously do. The targeting of liberal groups and funders, efforts to censor the press, threats to remove passports and revoke citizenship, suppress free speech and override mayors and governors of states – all of these policies have been used before, and very effectively. One area in which there is an important divergence between America today and 1930’s Germany is in the strength of the judiciary, which was weak in Weimar Germany but, so far, has generally proven to be an effective bulwark against some of the Administration’s worst excesses. How effectively that bulwark holds could become a crucial question in the next few months as the Administration tests the boundaries of its ability to suppress dissent.