Trump and Putin in Alaska: Will it be Munich, Yalta or something else?

Sources (15) ↓

President Donald Trump’s meeting with Russian President Vladimir Putin at Joint Base Elmendorf-Richardson, just outside of Anchorage, has generated a small amount of optimism but probably much more dread. There are two historical analogies that could provide clues for what emerges – the Munich Conference in 1938 and the Yalta Conference in 1945.

The first of these historical connections, Munich, has been used before (not least by me in a previous post). In September 1938, British Prime Minister Neville Chamberlain and French President Edouard Daladier met with German Chancellor Adolf Hitler and Italian leader Benito Mussolini in Munich to discuss the annexation of Czechoslovakia’s Sudetenland – without the presence of any representatives of the Czech government, least of all President Edvard Benes. What resulted was a sell-out of the only real democracy in Eastern Europe, and one with a formidable arms industry. Presented with a “take it or leave” proposition from Chamberlain and Daladier, Benes felt he had no choice and took the deal. There is a clear parallel with the upcoming Trump – Putin summit, since no other country besides the US and Russia will be present, including Ukraine.

Obviously, this agreement did not end well for Europe. Hitler soon broke the treaty, took all of Czechoslovakia and then plunged Europe into a war which eventually became the greatest global conflict in history.

But there is another potential analogy – the Yalta conference in February, 1945, with the three soon to be victorious Allied leaders in attendance: Franklin Roosevelt for the United States, Winston Churchill for the United Kingdom, and Joseph Stalin for the USSR. The discussions at Yalta determined the outlines of Europe from the fall of Berlin on May 2, 1945 until the collapse of the Soviet Union in 1989. At the time, the conference was widely hailed as the height of wartime cooperation, with provisions for the deNazification of Germany, trials of war criminals (which eventually took place at Nuremberg), and the creation of the United Nations. Though there were provisions for free elections in Eastern Europe in countries overrun by Soviet forces, it seems clear now that the Russians never had any intention of allowing that to happen. As a result, the conference is now widely seen as creating the conditions for the Cold War by codifying the division of Europe into Western Allied and Soviet spheres of influence, which in the case of Russia meant an empire in all but name from the Baltics to the Black Sea – the “Iron Curtain” Churchill identified in his famous speech in Fulton, Missouri in 1946.

Which historical analogy appears most plausible? Oddly, both could be. At both Yalta and Munich, the Western allies desperately wanted something. At Munich, Britain and France, that something was peace at almost any price, which Hitler understood and was able to use against them. At Yalta, the Western Allies were unsure about the potential impact of the atomic bomb (and even unsure if it would actually work), and very much wanted Russian help in finishing the war in the Pacific. Roosevelt was also desperate for Russian participation in the creation of the United Nations. In both cases, Hitler and Stalin were able to leverage the Western Allies’ strongly held aspirations to improve their own positions. Trump seems vulnerable to the same sort of pressure. He has telegraphed his desire for a Nobel Peace Prize, and also painted himself into a corner by asserting that he could end the war between Russia and Ukraine in a single day. It also allows Trump to sidestep his self-imposed deadline to impose new sanctions on Russia, something he always seems reluctant to do.

This meeting is therefore something of a throwback to those earlier conferences at Munich and Yalta: Great men representing great nations deciding the fate of smaller countries. While Putin and Trump are quite comfortable with this format, it inspires dread in Western and Central Europeans, especially those living in Ukraine and the Baltic nations which were once part of the Soviet Union. The fear is justified, since Trump does seem quite capable of selling out Ukraine in his pursuit of a Nobel Prize winning end to the war. And, just as Hitler and Stalin understood the weaknesses exhibited by France, Britain and the United States at Munich and Yalta, so does Putin – a trained KGB operative – know how to exploit Trump’s weaknesses for his own advantage.

The question then, is how much Trump has learned from his previous summit experiences. So far, the record is not promising. He has met Putin five times before, including his meeting in Helsinki in July 2018 when he accepted Putin’s denial of election interference over those of his own intelligence agencies (he later said he “mis-spoke”). Little follow up has come from those meetings. Worse, his meetings with Kim Jong Un of North Korea were designed for a breakthrough on North Korea’s nuclear arsenal, and gave North Korea great international prestige. Trump, in return, got nothing.

While Trump may understand real estate swaps, he does not seem to learn from history. But Europeans do. Ukrainian President Zelenskyy has already gone on record in stating that his nation will not trade large tracts of his country for peace – or hollow security promises -- as Chamberlain and Daladier did at Munich. And Europeans have already indicated that, unlike what happened at Munich and Yalta, they will not force Ukraine to accept a disastrous peace agreement nor an artificial barrier which divides Europeans from themselves.

Sources

Links go to the original publishers. Some require a subscription.

  1. What you need to know about the Trump-Putin Summit (Victoria Craw and Victoria Bissett/Washington Post) Read article washingtonpost.com
  2. What Putin wants from Trump in Alaska (The Economist) Read article economist.com
  3. In Alaska, is Putin offering Trump peace – or a trap? (Patrick Reevell/ABC News) Read article abcnews.go.com
  4. Analysis: Which Donald Trump will negotiate with Putin in Alaska (Steve Holland/Thompson Reuters, reprinted in Eye on the Arctic) Read article rcinet.ca
  5. Trump and Putin could decide each other’s fates, echoing Yalta summit (Stephen Earlanger?NYTimes) Read article nytimes.com
  6. Putin and Trump have met before. Here’s how those encounters went (Naomi Schanen/Alisa Shodiyev Kaff/Washington Post) Read article washingtonpost.com
  7. Trump-Putin summit in Alaska resembles a slow defeat for Ukraine (Nick Paton Walsh/CNN) Read article cnn.com
  8. Winston Churchill’s Iron Curtain speech, March 5, 1946 (National World War II Museum) Read article nationalww2museum.org
  9. Ben Wallace: Trump’s Ukraine peace talks have echoes of Nazi appeasement (Danielle Sheridan/The Telegraph (UK)) Read article telegraph.co.uk
  10. Donald Trump’s assault on Europe (The Economist) Read article economist.com
  11. The Nazi’s road to war: Showdown in Munich (Dominic Sanborn and Tom Holland/The Rest is History Episode 529 (podcast)) Read article open.spotify.com
  12. 1938: Chamberlin addresses the nation on peace negotiations (BBC Archive) Read article bbc.com
  13. Appeasement and “Peace for our time” (National World War II Museum) Read article nationalww2museum.org
  14. Yalta (Diane Shaver Clemens (free to download book by the premier historian of the Yalta conference)) Read article archive.org
  15. The Yalta Conference, 1945 (Office of the Historian, State Department) Read article history.state.gov

All newsletters