Texas was a warning – and not just about climate change

Sources (22) ↓

"By failing to prepare, you are preparing to fail." ~ Benjamin Franklin

“The primary task of government is to keep us safe” – Michael Lewis

Americans have a long history of disliking government – until they discover that they actually need it. The disaster along the Guadalupe River in Texas is a case in point. While no one could have predicted the scale of the tragedy, there were clear deficiencies in the Federal Government’s response, most assuredly within the Department of Homeland Security and Federal Emergency Management Administration (FEMA), but also with the National Weather Service as well.

Disaster response can never be as fast as needed, but FEMA’s reaction to the flood was particularly sluggish and poorly coordinated; it took Homeland Security 72 hours to deploy FEMA rapid response teams, no disaster relief supplies were prepositioned, and thousands of frantic phone calls went unanswered by call centers whose staff had been fired. This was apparently the result of Secretary Kristi Noem’s efforts to control expenditures as she prepared to eliminate FEMA at the behest of the White House and DOGE. And while the dedicated professionals at the National Weather Service did their best to warn the residents along the Guadalupe River, coordination with other agencies and with state and local government in Texas was lacking – also as the result of lack of staff due to budget cuts.

The disaster in Texas is a foreshadowing of the dangers that are emerging across the environmental spectrum, where climate events (wind events, floods and fires) are growing increasingly powerful and happening more frequently than at any time in history. Yet rather than doubling down on preparedness, the Trump administration is cutting back on the tools needed to effectively cope with the myriad challenges confronting the United States, both domestically and internationally. This includes the inter-agency communications process, an unglamorous but vital element in coordinating government policies across multiple agencies.

The increasing lack of preparedness is mirrored in many areas, but none perhaps more dangerous than the foreign policy and security arena, where the White House and Secretary of State Marco Rubio have eliminated many National Security Council and State Department positions (including that of the former director, Mike Waltz – now replaced by Rubio). The NSC was created in 1947 by President Truman to manage the complex relationship between the State Department, Pentagon and intelligence agencies, and there are already signs that it's “decapitation” by the White House is taking a toll: as the Washington Post and Politico have detailed, the inability of the NSC to set priorities for the administration has led to free-lancing by Pentagon staff, including a botched reexamination of the AUKUS (Australia, United Kingdom, United States) trilateral security pact - undone after a hasty meeting at the White House - and an unauthorized decision to cut off of military assistance to Ukraine, also rolled back after President Trump became aware of it from the press. There is also evidence that Trump’s decision to join the Israeli strike against Iran’s nuclear facilities was not communicated in a timely fashion to service members and State Department officials in the Middle East, putting them at risk had the Iranians decided to immediately respond. All of these near misses give the impression of a discoordinated national security apparatus, heartening for America's adversaries and worrisome for America's allies.

In his book The Fifth Risk, written after the first Trump administration was voted out of office, award-winning author Michael Lewis asserts that the government's primary function is “to keep us safe,” and warns of the danger of electing leaders who lack the understanding to manage the complex machinery of the Federal Government. So long as things go well and the world is quiet, no one pays attention. But the world is not quiet, and indeed is now much more dangerous than before. The cuts from the Trump administration – supposedly in the name of efficiency – undermine the ability of the government to react to unanticipated crises, whether they be pandemics, natural disasters, or international emergencies. At a time when the social safety net is fraying domestically and America's position abroad has become much more insecure, wagering that the world - and mother nature -- will remain quiet seems like a bad bet.

Sources

Links go to the original publishers. Some require a subscription.

  1. FEMA didn’t answer thousands of calls from flood survivors, documents show (Maxine Joselow/NYTimes) Read article nytimes.com
  2. As floods hit, key roles were vacant at weather service offices in Texas (Christopher Flavell/NYTimes) Read article time.com
  3. FEMA’s response to Texas slowed by Noem’s cost controls (Gabe Cohen and Michael Williams/CNN) Read article cnn.com
  4. Texas flood aftermath shows how Trump is breaking FEMA (Nikki McCann Ramirez/Rolling Stone) Read article rollingstone.com
  5. Experts question of Weather Service operating at its best when Texas floods strike (Time Magazine) Read article time.com
  6. Kristi Noem laughs off criticism of her Texas flood response (Alllison Quinn/New York Magazine) Read article nymag.com
  7. Inside the dysfunction in Rubio’s National Security Council (Nahal Toosi/Politico) Read article politico.com
  8. Decapitating the National Security Council leads to foreign policy chaos (Max Boot/Washington Post) Read article washingtonpost.com
  9. Trump’s cuts could leave the US exposed during heightened national security threats (Zolan Kanno-Youngs and Adam Goldman/NYTimes) Read article nytimes.com
  10. National Security Leaders for America warns that State Department layoffs threaten national security Read article nsl4a.org
  11. 100 days of DOGE cuts: Lots of chaos, not so much efficiency (Tim Reid, Alexandra Alper and Nathan Layne/Reuters) Read article reuters.com
  12. DOGE says it has saved taxpayers $160 billion. Those cuts have cost taxpayers $135 billion, one analysis says (Aimee Pichee/CBS News) Read article cbsnews.com
  13. How NOAA cuts could affect you (Tyler Nicole/Yahoo News) Read article yahoo.com
  14. Trump Administration tells State Department tells workers will begin soon (Michael Crowley/NYTimes) Read article nytimes.com
  15. President Trump’s war on America risks a wave of catastrophes (Tom Moore/Center for American Progress) Read article americanprogress.org
  16. State Department firing over 1,300 employees under Trump administration plan (Matthew Lee/AP-PBS) Read article pbs.org
  17. No alternative funding sources (Thomas Frank/Politico) Read article politico.com
  18. Trump’s cuts are making Federal data disappear (Molly Smith/Bloomberg) Read article bloomberg.com
  19. Trump’s cuts are making disasters deadlier (Kate Aronoff/The New Republic) Read article newrepublic.com
  20. Tracking Trump’s overhaul of the Federal workforce (Anette Choi, Danya Gainor and Kate Caroll/CNN) Read article cnn.com
  21. Trump’s budget cuts are adding to risk in life threatening floods and emergencies (Clodagh Harrison/The Conversation) Read article theconversation.com
  22. The Fifth Risk (Michael Lewis) Read article amazon.com

All newsletters