The Better Angels of our Nature: Lincoln, Moral Purpose, and America's War with Iran

Sources (19) ↓

“[We are] dedicated to the great task remaining before us …. that this nation, under God, shall have a new birth of freedom -- and that government of the people, by the people, for the people, shall not perish from the earth." President Abraham Lincoln, November 19, 1865, at the dedication of the National Military Cemetery at Gettysburg PA

“Let every nation know, whether it wishes us well or ill, that we shall pay any price, bear any burden, meet any hardship, support any friend, oppose any foe to assure the survival and the success of liberty.” (President John F. Kennedy Inaugural Address, January 20, 1961)

“We negotiate with bombs.” (Secretary of Defense (War) Pete Hegseth, March 25, 2026)

Abraham Lincoln's Gettysburg Address is probably the most famous speech in American history. Delivered in less than three minutes, it reframed the entire Civil War — moving away from a struggle to preserve national boundaries toward a struggle for the principle of human equality. In doing so, Lincoln redefined the meaning of American democracy itself.

The contrast with Donald Trump and his cabinet's rationale for the attacks on Iran could hardly be starker. Not every presidency faces the epic challenges Lincoln confronted, but most American presidents have articulated a vision consistent with the sense of exceptionalism that has defined the American experience since before the nation's founding. America is unusual among nations in that it was established not on the basis of ethnicity, religion, or geography, but on an idea: that all men are created equal and endowed with inalienable rights. That sense of unique purpose means America has always had to justify its actions, including its wars, by reference to something larger than raw national interest. When presidents fail to do so, they create a crisis of identity, not just a policy dispute.

This is not a burden most countries carry, and it creates a unique and demanding rhetorical obligation for American presidents. When Lincoln sent hundreds of thousands of men to die, he had to explain why their deaths served something greater than the preservation of federal tax revenues or the territorial integrity of the Union. When Wilson asked Congress to send American boys to the trenches of Europe, he could not say "because it is in our economic interest" — he had to say "to make the world safe for democracy." When Roosevelt mobilized the entire American economy for war, he gave the sacrifice a name: the Four Freedoms. These were not mere rhetorical flourishes. They were load-bearing arguments, connecting the cost of war to the values that defined the nation's reason for existing.

When a president fails to make that connection — when he substitutes bluster for vision, or personal grievance for principle — something deeper than public support erodes. Americans begin to ask not just "is this war wise?" but "is this war us?" That is a far more destabilizing question. A policy dispute can be resolved by evidence and argument. A crisis of identity goes to the heart of what the country believes itself to be, and those crises do not resolve quickly or cleanly. They linger in the culture, breeding cynicism, division, and a corrosive suspicion that the nation's stated values are simply a costume worn over the exercise of naked power.

That is the crisis Trump's war with Iran has accelerated. Not because war itself is un-American — America has been at war for much of its history — but because this war has been waged without the moral vocabulary that Americans have historically required of their leaders. In its absence, the country is left not just debating strategy, but questioning its own values.

No one understood that moral obligation better than Lincoln, who throughout the Civil War gave the North an unfailing sense of purpose, a belief that seeing the conflict through to its end would lead to a better America. The absence of any such purpose in America's attack on Iran is reflected in public opinion today: a majority of Americans opposed the war when it began, and even more oppose it now.

It may not be fair to measure Trump against possibly the greatest orator in American history, but many presidents and statesmen — before and after Lincoln — have risen to the challenge of aspiring to something greater than narrow national interest. Patrick Henry famously declared "Give me Liberty or Give me Death!" more than a year before the Declaration of Independence. As noted above, in 1917 Woodrow Wilson asked Congress to declare war to "make the world safe for democracy," while Franklin Roosevelt prepared the nation to enter World War II by calling on America to become the "Arsenal of Democracy" and identifying the Four Freedoms worth fighting for: freedom of speech, freedom of worship, freedom from want, and freedom from fear. John F. Kennedy framed the Cold War as a contest between freedom and totalitarianism, and in his inaugural address urged Americans to "ask not what your country can do for you — ask what you can do for your country." Ronald Reagan challenged Soviet Premier Gorbachev to "tear down this wall." Even George W. Bush, in the immediate aftermath of September 11th, rallied the nation with an explicit call to resist Islamophobia while confronting terrorism.

America's sense of national purpose has long rested — however imperfectly realized — on the idea that its power should be exercised in service of something greater than itself: democracy, human rights, the rule of law. Trump and Hegseth have largely stripped such language from this war, substituting bombastic statements and juvenile memes for clear and coherent objectives. No one in the administration has been able to articulate such a vision — for the presidency or for the war. The result is a perilously divided country with no overarching sense of purpose.

In his First Inaugural Address, Lincoln tried to head off the impending Civil War by appealing to the "better angels of our nature." But it was his Second Inaugural, delivered in March 1865, that truly set the tone for the American presidency that followed — one that every president until Trump at least paid lip service to. With remarkable humility, rather than rejoicing in the Union's imminent victory after four years of devastating war, Lincoln offered conciliatory words to citizens in both the North and the South, including the now-famous lines: "With malice toward none, with charity for all, with firmness in the right as God gives us to see the right…"

The next president will face an enormous task in rebuilding the sense of civic purpose that was Lincoln's great legacy to America.

Sources

Links go to the original publishers. Some require a subscription.

  1. The Gettysburg Address (Abraham Lincoln Online) Read article abrahamlincolnonline.org
  2. “We negotiate with bombs,” Hegseth says of strikes on Iran (Michelle L. Price/AP, carried by PBS) Read article pbs.org
  3. Trump’s changing messages on the Iran war. What does it say about US strategy? (Yasraj Sharma/Al Jazeera) Read article aljazeera.com
  4. 4 weeks in, Trump’s conflicting signals on Iran frustrate GOP and political allies (Adam Cancryn and Sarah Ferris/CNN) Read article cnn.com
  5. Republicans in Congress fret over Iran war as Pentagon offers few answers (Robert Jimison, Megan Miniero and Eric Schmitt/NYTimes) Read article nytimes.com
  6. Trump throws Hegseth under the bus …(Christelle May Napizia/International Business Times) Read article ibtimes.com
  7. Fact check: Trump’s barrage of false or unproven claims about the Iran war (Daniel Dale/CNN) Read article cnn.com
  8. Trump tries to spread blame for Iran war (Nikki McCann Ramirez/Rolling Stone) Read article rollingstone.com
  9. Trump loses the home front (William Galston/Wall Street Journal) Read article wsj.com
  10. Patrick Henry’s speech to the Virginia Convention (1775): Give me Liberty or Give me Death! (The White House 250th Anniversary) Read article whitehouse.gov
  11. Lincoln’s first inaugural address (Yale University, The Avalon Project) Read article avalon.law.yale.edu
  12. Lincoln’s second Inaugural Address (Yale University, The Avalon Project) Read article avalon.law.yale.edu
  13. Joint address to Congress leading to a Declaration of War against Germany (1917) - (National Archives Milestone Documents) Read article archives.gov
  14. President Franklin Roosevelts Annual Message (Four Freedoms) to Congress (1941) – (Milestone Documents/National Archives) Read article archives.gov
  15. President John F Kennedy’s 1961 inaugural address (Milestone Documents/National Archives) Read article archives.gov
  16. The fifteen most inspiring speeches in American history (HeinOnline) Read article home.heinonline.org
  17. What’s the point of presidential speeches? (Kitty Kay/BBC) Read article bbc.com
  18. Speeches that defined a presidency (C-Span) Read article c-span.org
  19. Looking at 10 great speeches in American history (Staff/National Constitution Center) Read article constitutioncenter.org

All newsletters