What America Stands For Depends on Which America You Mean

Sources (22) ↓

What Jamestown, Plymouth, and Boston Still Tell Us About Ourselves

On the eve of its 250th anniversary, the United States is once again riven with discord over which version of America to celebrate. Is it the divinely inspired nation depicted by Trump-backed "Freedom Trucks" — a beacon to the world, chosen by Providence? Or is it a nation founded, as Nikole Hannah-Jones argues in the 1619 Project, on racism, inequality, and bondage? Is it a dangerous bully on the international stage, or a country withdrawing into itself, hostile to the world outside? The question beneath all of these divergent perspectives is simpler and harder: what does America actually stand for — and why, after 250 years, does the answer still depend on which founding you're looking at?

The contradictions are not subtle. The United States is the most prosperous nation in human history and among the least equitable in the developed world, its wealth distribution ranked by the OECD alongside Turkey and Mexico rather than its Western European and Asian peers. It is the oldest modern democratic republic, heir to Athenian democracy and the Roman Republic, and yet the Economist Intelligence Unit classifies it today as a "flawed democracy," somewhere between 28th and 34th globally. It professes to be a peaceful nation, but has engaged in numerous wars. None of these occurrences are recent developments. They are baked into a nation that defines itself not by blood and soil but by the proposition that all people are created equal, a standard that America has never fully met and never been able to abandon.

The architects of the republic — Jefferson, Washington, Madison, Hamilton — were men of genuine greatness and profound moral inconsistency in roughly equal measure. They built a constitutional order of remarkable philosophical ambition, rooted in the highest ideals of the Enlightenment, while at the same time holding enslaved people, excluding women from public life entirely, and designing a Congress structurally resistant to majority will. The republic they founded was remarkable, but it was, from the outset, burdened with enormous internal contradictions. This is not surprising, since the contradictions reach back long before 1776, to the earliest days of colonial America.

America's three earliest English settlements — Jamestown, Plymouth, and the Massachusetts Bay Colony — each planted a different seed in American soil: exploitation and capitalism, separatism, democratic idealism and missionary zeal. Perhaps the remarkable thing is that all these different impulses have coexisted for 250 years.

Jamestown, founded in 1607 as the first English settlement in America, was not a community of idealists; it was a part of a corporation. The Virginia Company of London, a joint-stock enterprise backed by wealthy English investors, dispatched settlers to extract value from the New World and return it across the Atlantic — the first large-scale deployment of corporate finance on American soil. As historian Edmund S. Morgan demonstrates in American Slavery, American Freedom (1975), the colony's logic was commercial from the start. When timber and mineral schemes failed to turn a profit, the Company turned to tobacco, a crop requiring intensive, controllable labor. Indentured servants came first, then enslaved Africans — the crucial distinction being that indentures expired and slavery did not. When in 1662 a Virginia court ruled that children born to enslaved mothers were the property of their mother's owner, it provided the justification for the racial caste system that would define American life for the next four centuries.

The profit motive that drove the Virginia Company — extract resources, control labor, return value to distant shareholders — is in many ways the template for American capitalism itself, establishing patterns that would echo forward for centuries. As Morgan argues, American democracy and American slavery were not opposites — they grew up together, each sustaining the other. The origins of American capitalism, racial hierarchy, and settler colonialism are all traceable, in their essential forms, to Jamestown.

If Jamestown represents American rapacity, Plymouth’s Pilgrims represents something else entirely: the instinct to withdraw. The Pilgrims were Separatists before they were anything else — not merely a theological label but a declaration of identity. Where the Puritans of the Massachusetts Bay Colony, arriving a decade later, sought to reform the Church of England from within, the Pilgrims had concluded that England was irredeemably corrupt. They fled first to the Netherlands, then to America. For them, Separation from the rest of the world was what mattered most.

Separatism found its most consequential expression not in Plymouth but in nearby Boston, where in 1630 Governor John Winthrop delivered his sermon "A Model of Christian Charity," which gave American political rhetoric the image it has never been able to shake: the shining city upon a hill. Contrary to its later uses, Winthrop was not promising greatness. He was issuing a warning, “The eyes of all people are upon us” meant that failure would be catastrophic — a betrayal of the Puritan covenant and a blow to the cause of reforming English society from across the Atlantic.

In most political traditions, isolation signals weakness. In the American tradition shaped by the Separatist inheritance, withdrawal is coded as moral superiority — a refusal to be contaminated by a corrupt world. It became the operating doctrine of the early republic. Washington's Farewell Address warned against "permanent alliances." Jefferson called for "entangling alliances with none," while the Monroe Doctrine institutionalized separation as hemispheric strategy. “Manifest Destiny” reframed America’s continental expansion as a divine mission — America didn't need the world because it was a world unto itself. The pattern continued into the isolationism of the 1930s — America First committees, the Neutrality Acts, Lindbergh's radio addresses – all of which drew on the same emotional vocabulary: the world beyond the United States was corrupt and dangerous. To its adherents, American isolationism has always felt like a return to first principles.

The central irony of American history is that the same founding communities that gave America the separatist compulsion also gave it the missionary impulse. When Ronald Reagan reimagined Winthrop's anxious warning as a "shining city on a hill" radiating freedom outward, he was not distorting the American tradition so much as activating its other reforming motivations. The city on a hill has always been simultaneously a withdrawal from the world and a model for it.

American foreign policy has swung between these poles ever since — between the isolationist who sees no obligation beyond the nation's borders and the crusader who believes America has a divine duty to spread freedom. Wilson's “making the world safe for democracy” in World War I; the isolationism of the 1930s; the liberal internationalism of post-1945; the neoconservative democracy campaigns of the 2000s; the "America First" retrenchment of today are not random oscillations but rather the recurring expression tensions planted in the Virginia and New England soil four centuries ago.

Alexis de Tocqueville, visiting in the 1830s, saw the underlying contradiction with unsettling clarity. In Democracy in America (1835), he warned of a republic that might hollow itself out — surrendering genuine self-governance to comfortable passivity, mistaking prosperity for civic health, trading the substance of freedom for its forms. He also predicted, in one of political literature's most famous passages, that America and Russia would each "sway the destinies of half the globe" — one through conquest, one through the force of example. That second destiny — influence through example — is precisely what is now in question.

At 250, America is still arguing about which America it wants to be: the exploiter, the isolationist, or the beacon. The founders were never able to resolve these contradictions, and neither has anyone since. When Winthrop warned his flock that the eyes of all people were upon them, he meant it as a warning. Four centuries later that warning endures.

Sources

Links go to the original publishers. Some require a subscription.

  1. Trump-backed ‘Freedom Trucks’ tell a sanitized story of the country’s founding (Laura Meckler/Washington Post) Read article washingtonpost.com
  2. The 1619 Project: A new origin story (Nikole Hannah-Jones/1619 Books) Read article 1619books.com
  3. Declaration of Independence: A transcription (The National Archives) Read article archives.gov
  4. The Constitution of the United States (The National Archives) Read article archives.gov
  5. American Ideals vs American realities: A European observer detects a clash and also a search for new social and political guideposts. American ideals vs realities (Max Beloff/NYTimes (reprint of 1948 article)) Read article nytimes.com
  6. Multiple indicators show decline in the health of American democracy in 2025 (Jonathan Schulman and Richard Wike/Pew Research Center) Read article pewresearch.org
  7. EIU’s 2024 Democracy Index: trend of global democratic decline and strengthening authoritarianism continues through 2024 (Economist Intelligence Unit) - EIU’s 2024 Democracy Index: trend of global democratic decline and strengthening authoritarianism continues through 2024
  8. Society at a glance: OECD social indicators (Organization of Economic Development and Cooperation) Read article oecd.org
  9. For allies and adversaries alike, America at 250 is a solid citizen gone rogue (Guardian reporters/The Guardian) Read article theguardian.com
  10. Jamestown rediscovery (Historic Jamestown) Read article historicjamestowne.org
  11. A short history of Jamestown (National Park Service) Read article nps.gov
  12. American Slavery, American Freedom (Edmund S. Morgan) Read article amazon.com
  13. Why did the Pilgrims come to America? (Christopher Klein/History.com) Read article history.com
  14. Were Pilgrims America’s economic migrants? (Paul Solman and Hari Sreenavasan/PBS) Read article pbs.org
  15. Massachusetts Bay Colony (Janine Ungvarsky/EBSCO) Read article ebsco.com
  16. Albion’s Seed: Four British Folkways in America (David Hackett Fisher, Oxford University Press, 1989) Read article google.com
  17. American Contradiction: Revolution and Revenge from 1950 until now (Paul Starr, Yale University Press, 2025) Read article yalebooks.yale.edu
  18. How Americans see their country’s past, present and future (The Economist) Read article economist.com
  19. Democracy in America (Alexis de Tocqueville/Gutenberg Project) Read article gutenberg.org
  20. What remains of the city on a hill? Michael Bechshloss/The Economist) Read article economist.com
  21. Birth of America: Massacre, chaos, conspiracy (Dan Snow/History Hits) Link not available online
  22. Trump’s anti-patriotic trap: The President celebrates only some Americans. But patriotism is not about who is in the Oval Office (Anne Applebaum/The Atlantic) Read article theatlantic.com

All newsletters