Losing the Room: China Builds While Trump Dismantles

Sources (20) ↓

On July 15, the Pew Research Center released a remarkable — and unsettling — survey of global attitudes toward the United States and China. For the first time in two decades of Pew polling, more people worldwide expressed confidence in China's global leadership than in America's. Views of the US are now the most negative Pew has recorded since it began tracking global opinion in 2002. Of 36 nations surveyed, America was viewed more favorably than China in only six: India, Israel, Japan, the Philippines, Poland, and South Korea. Most strikingly, citizens of Canada and Mexico — America's closest neighbors and largest trading partners — now view China more favorably than they view the US itself.

Respondents see China as the more reliable partner, and as more likely to promote global peace and stability. Negative views of America track closely to Trump's tariffs and his buccaneering foreign policy — threats to seize Greenland, insults hurled at foreign leaders, and, above all, the war with Iran — along with the erosion of civil society at home.

This is an extraordinary comedown, though not unprecedented: Vietnam, the Iraq invasion, and Trump's own withdrawal from the Iran nuclear deal all provoked global unease in their time. But that unease was historically cushioned by American soft power — backing for the UN and NATO, leadership on trade, health, and climate cooperation, an unrivaled university system, a free press, and reliable rule of law. It's almost as if Trump and his lieutenants set out — insanely — to dismantle every one of those cushions at once.

China is the direct beneficiary, banking on Trump's chaotic "America First" governing style, his naked transactionalism, and his general lack of competence and coherence. Beijing has pursued a sophisticated strategy to present itself as the reliable, stable alternative, filling the void created by US withdrawal.

Multilateralism with Chinese Characteristics

China's rise over the last four decades owes much to working within the international order the US built after World War II — the UN, the World Bank, the GATT-turned-WTO. Xi and his comrades want to participate in these institutions, not destroy them; the old order has been too good for Chinese interests. Like any rising power, Beijing wants to bend the rules in its favor, not tear up the rulebook.

In parallel, though, China has built an entirely separate architecture anchored in Beijing: the Shanghai Cooperation Organization, RCEP, the Belt and Road Initiative, the Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank, the New Development Bank, the cross-border payment system CIPS, and an expanded BRICS that now includes Argentina, Egypt, Ethiopia, Iran, Saudi Arabia, and the UAE alongside its founding members. Beijing has also launched region-specific clubs that exclude the US entirely — the 14+1 in Europe, FOCAC in Africa, the China-Arab States Cooperation Forum, China-CELAC in Latin America, the China-Central Asia Summit — plus broader initiatives like the Global Development, Global Security, Global Civilization, and Global Governance Initiatives. Building new institutions is a deliberate strategy for extending Chinese influence, executed while Trump deepens America's polarization and isolation.

The newest entry came just last week. On July 16, President Xi launched the World Artificial Intelligence Cooperation Organization, headquartered in Shanghai, with 29 founding countries signing on. Xi wants China to define the rules of the road for AI independent of the US, pitching the Chinese development model to the same developing-world audience he's courted through CELAC and FOCAC. Not coincidentally, Chinese AI firm Moonshot released its new open-weight model, Kimi K3, the same day — performing competitively with America's leading frontier models at a fraction of the cost.

Trump has pursued the opposite strategy: exit old institutions, build nothing new. Across two terms he has withdrawn the US from the Trans-Pacific Partnership, the Iran nuclear deal, the Paris Climate Accords, the WHO, the UN Human Rights Council, UNESCO, and five dozen other multilateral bodies, half of them UN-affiliated. He is a militant unilateralist who treats organizations like the UN as constraints rather than tools — launching the war against Iran without seeking a UN Security Council resolution, and without even consulting NATO before complaining that NATO didn't back the war with more vigor. His bilateral tariffs on nearly every country except Russia have assaulted the multilateral trade order in the same spirit.

The consequences follow directly, in both directions. China's "China rising, America declining" narrative is landing across Africa, Latin America, and Asia, and the Pew data confirms it. Trading partners are hedging: Canada and the UK are absorbing more Chinese goods, including EVs, while China-CELAC gains real traction in Latin America and FOCAC deepens African participation. Short term, this makes it harder for Trump to rally allies around US-led initiatives — the reluctance to help reopen the Strait of Hormuz is exhibit A. Longer term, the risk is structural: American power has always rested on being seen as a model worth emulating, the very thing that pulled in global talent, capital, and diplomatic alignment. Erode that, and it becomes harder to write the rules on AI, trade, or global health — especially as the younger generations now coming of age abroad increasingly see China, not America, as the more stable partner.

Elites often act independently of public sentiment, and opinion can shift quickly. But these polls are a genuine signal of where the world is moving — and American policymakers ignore it at their peril.

Sources

Links go to the original publishers. Some require a subscription.

  1. People in many countries now view China more positively than the United States (Jonathan Schulman, Laura Silver, Laura Clancy and William Miner/Pew Research Center) Read article pewresearch.org
  2. The world is giving up on America (Richard Wike/Foreign Affairs (Wike is director of global attitudes at the Pew Research Center) Read article reader.foreignaffairs.com
  3. More people around the world favor China over the US, Pew study suggests (Tessa Wong/BBC) Read article bbc.com
  4. Historic reversal confirms Donald Trump’s worst nightmare as China overtakes the US (Alex Blair/news.com.au) Read article news.com.au
  5. Many countries favor China and Xi over Trump and the US: Polling (Laura Kelly/The Hill) Read article thehill.com
  6. America is losing friends: China is courting them (Mark Hertling/The Bulwark) - () Read article substack.com
  7. After hegemony (Gideon Rose/Council on Foreign Relations) Read article substack.com
  8. Ex-Ukraine foreign minister predicts China is the “main beneficiary” of Trump’s foreign policy (Finbarr Bermingham and Laura Zhou/South China Morning Post) Read article scmp.com
  9. America’s African apoplexy is China’s gain (Derek Grossman/Africa Report) Read article theafricareport.com
  10. A Chinese scholar shares some thoughts about what Trump is doing to the US (Steve Inskeep, interviewing Da Wei/NPR) Read article npr.org
  11. How Trump is making China great again, and what it means for Europe (Timothy Garton Ash, Ivan Krastev, and Mark Leonard/European Council on Foreign Relations) Read article ecfr.eu
  12. Trump is good for China. But is he good for America? (Sam Bresnick/Newsweek) Read article newsweek.com
  13. Trump’s kiss of death (Thomas Edsall/NYTimes) Read article nytimes.com
  14. The dangers of unilateralism abroad and polarization at home (Michael McFaul/Substack) Read article open.substack.com
  15. Trump exits 66 international bodies: What the US loses in global influence (Gov Facts Research Report) Read article govfacts.org
  16. Advantage China: Trump’s tantrums push US allies towards China (Amy Hawkins/The Guardian) Read article theguardian.com
  17. Is Russia the main beneficiary of Trump’s mistake (Ravi Agrawal/Foreign Policy) Read article foreignpolicy.com
  18. How China is winning friends and influencing people (Lizzi C Lee and Eric Olander/(Foreign Affairs) Read article reader.foreignaffairs.com
  19. Trump 2.0: Is China filling the void? (Yun Sun/China Leadership Monitor) Read article prcleader.org
  20. Is Russia the winner in Iran? (Alexander Gabuev/Foreign Policy) Read article foreignpolicy.com

All newsletters