The term “soft power” was coined by Harvard political scientist Joseph Nye in his 1990 book, Bound to Lead. As Nye himself relates, soft power defines “the ability [by a country] to attract others by attraction and persuasion rather than simply coercion and payment.” Other nations have their own versions of soft power, but no country is more associated with the now generally accepted concept than the United States.
While humanitarian assistance – arguably even back to the Marshall Plan and American support for the institutions of peaceful global order after World War II -- are a part of soft power, one of the oddities of the concept is that it is not something a government can really set out to create, unlike military or political power. Indeed, soft power is frequently defined by opposition to government control. Rock bands, political protests, subversive art and humor – all feed into the concept, as does America’s frequently over the top consumer and media culture. The global appeal of America’s soft power has often left other countries frustrated – notably France and China, both older civilizations with long cultural traditions of their own.
But if American soft power has been one of the country’s most enduring sources of strength, that dominance is now under threat from a wide range of sources – most of which are internal. The global view of America as a stable society has been under threat since the chaos and inward turn of the Trump presidency. The transactional nature of the Trump team’s approach undermined many of the fundamental assumptions of American stewardship of the international system – particularly American support for international institutions. The January 6 insurrection further added to that sense of American political instability. More recently, America’s health care system – or rather, its lack, and the prevalence of guns, along with the seemingly endless string of mass shootings, has also had a decidedly negative impact on foreign views of the United States, even among America’s friends. And for the those who see the American economy as a cornerstone of the larger global economy, the threat of a budget default – potentially as soon as early June – also undermines the credibility of the dollar as the world’s reserve currency. And while most of America’s allies take heart in the steadiness of the Biden Administration, the fear is that a Trump II administration would prove even more unhinged and destructive to the global order than the first time around.
As bad as things are for America’s image, it could be worse – at least comparatively speaking. Much of the world sees President Biden as an earnest and decent president, committed to stable international system. While the chaos of the American departure from Afghanistan was a black mark, the Administration’s handling of the Russian invasion of Ukraine has garnered praise from many foreign leaders, even though not all have gone along with sanctions or condemned Russia. China and Russia, by comparison, have suffered in recent global opinion polls for both their internal and external policies. Russia’s invasion of Ukraine has wrecked what little soft power that country had, while international polls cite China’s policies towards Hong Kong, its Uighur population and threats to Taiwan as tarnishing that country’s international image. It may be hard to fix some of the myriad problems that have undermined America’s image abroad, but a good second choice is simply to avoid making things worse – which of course could prove challenging over the next few years.